BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Thursday 3rd December 2009
Text only
BBC Skillswise
BBC Skillswise BBCi Skillswise - Words  Words BBCi Skillswise - Numbers  Numbers BBCi Skillswise - For tutors  Tutors
Home   Your stories   News quizzes   Glossary   Games   Contact us   Help  
News quizzes archive: News to me  
Fighting for 'invisible' victims
Windows on the World workers
Click to hear the story
Get RealPlayer

For some families, the loss of a husband or father on 11 September was only the start of their nightmare.

One year on, they are living in fear of being deported.

They are the families of ‘undocumented’ workers who died in the wreckage of the World Trade Center.

That is another way of saying they were illegal immigrants, who were not entitled to live and work in the United States.

They gave a false social security number to their employers, and hoped the authorities would not catch up with them.

But in death, their illegal status poses a problem for bereaved families trying to obtain financial support from government agencies.

Their cause is being championed by the ‘Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees International Union’.

On the morning of 11 September 43 of its members were working at the World Trade Center.

They had jobs as cooks, dishwashers, waiters and bartenders.

Obstacles

Fifteen of them were ‘undocumented’.

They were trapped on the blazing upper floors, and were unable to escape. All died.

"The families suffered this terrible loss and then encountered a mind-boggling maze of obstacles trying to get the essential relief they needed," said Bill Granfield, president of the Local 100 branch of the union.

Some families were afraid even to go into the union office to get assistance. To add to their problems, many spoke little English.

Carmen Mejia from Ecuador lost her husband Manuel. The union is now trying to ensure she can remain in the United States with her children.

"I was afraid to go for help because I have no papers," she told a union conference, speaking through an interpreter.

Long-term support

After the attack, when a loved one failed to return home, many were afraid to approach the police or hospitals.

Some charities have paid out without asking too many questions. But the problem has been how to get longer-term support.

Social security is supposed to provide a monthly payment for the surviving spouse until he or she remarries, and for the children until they are 21.

"For undocumented immigrants, their families couldn't collect social security, even though deductions were made from their pay, in some cases for years," said Bill Granfield.

Compassion

But the prospects for the families living and working illegally in New York may be worse.

The union wants an assurance from the government that the families of these ‘invisible victims’ can remain in the United States, as an act of compassion.

"These people left their homelands to take a risk to come to the land of the free in pursuit of the American dream," said Bill Granfield.

"Now a part of their families, the ones that were lost, will never leave America, and their families want to stay here."

"It was their dream to bring up their children in America, and we think the government could offer them permanent legal status."

What do you think of this story?
Share your thoughts on the messageboard

  See other archived 'news to me' stories



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy