Advertisement
Print

English

Appreciating the writer's craft

Page:

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  1. Next

This Bite concentrates on purpose of reading e - understanding and appreciating a writer's use of language.

The reader is expected to identify and comment on how the writer has presented information in the text, how the writer has used language to make points or for effect.

In particular, this means that the reader should be familiar with a few language ideas.

Extracts and answers

Extract 1

This short extract is from a story called 'Tunes for Bears to Dance To', by Robert Cormier. In the story, Henry works for a Mr. Hairston, who runs a shop.

"Potatoes to bag up," he called over the shoulder of a customer, and Henry made his way down to the cellar, where a bin of potatoes awaited him. He always tried to hurry the job because the cellar was dark and damp and he often heard rats scurrying across the floor. One day, a grey rat squirted out of a bag of potatoes and Henry had leapt with fright, his heart exploding in his chest. He was afraid of a lot of things - the closet door that never stayed closed in his bedroom, spooky movies about vampires - but most of all, the rats.

The question is in two parts, with a quotation used as an introduction.

Question

"...a grey rat squirted out of a bag of potatoes..."

(a) What is unusual about the writer's use of the word 'squirted' in this sentence ? 2 - 0

(b) Why is it a particularly suitable word to use here ? 2 - 0

toggle answer

Answer

(a) The word 'squirted' is usually associated with liquids and the rat's movement is being compared to liquid being forced out of a container, like a tube or a bottle. (This means that the word is being used figuratively, that an unusual comparison has been made to make the picture more interesting, more colourful, easier to understand, and so on. This means that a figure of speech has been used by the author, such as metaphor, simile, personification, and so on).

(b) The word is suitable (i.e. effective) to use here because it successfully suggests that the rat moved quickly, it was small, it moved suddenly, it appeared as something nasty. It is also onomatopoeic and the word is alliterative (i.e. from the figure of speech called alliteration) when seen with the word 'scurrying' used earlier in the same line of the paragraph.

Extract 2

This short extract is from an account written by an author called Laurie Lee, in which he describes arriving in Spain during the Spanish Civil War in the 1930s.

The people in the kitchen were a people stripped for war-the men smoking beech leaves, the soup reduced to near water; around us hand-grenades hanging on the walls like strings of onions, muskets and cartridge-belts piled in the corner, and open orange-boxes packed with silver bullets like fish. War was still so local then, it was like stepping into another room. And this was what I had come to re-visit. But I was now awash with sleep, hearing the blurred murmuring of voices and feeling the rocks of Spain under my feet. The men's eyes grew narrower, watching the unexpected stranger, and his lumpy belongings drying by the fire.

The question to look at based on this paragraph is again based on having some understanding of figurative language. It has two parts to it.

Question

(a) Why is the expression "silver bullets like fish" a particularly suitable one for the writer to use in this situation ? 2 - 1 - 0

(b) Write down another expression from the same paragraph which conveys a similar idea. 2 - 0

toggle answer

Answer

(a)

  • The writer is reminded of the shape of fish. (1 mark)
  • The writer is reminded of the colour of fish. (1 mark)
  • The writer thinks the pattern of the bullets lying in the box reminds him of a crate of fish. (1 mark)
  • It offers the idea that it is unusual for the ammunition to be found in the place where food should be. (1 mark)

Any two of the above answers would gain two marks, but the easiest ones to identify would probably be the first two, where the ideas would be clear if you had a basic understanding of simile and its use.

(b)"... hand-grenades ... like strings of onions ..."(2 marks) because this expression continues the idea of ammunition being associated with food, as in the original simile

The answer here again looks for an understanding of figurative use of language, but this time you were not asked to prove your understanding by way of explaining something. All you would have to have done would be to quote a statement from the paragraph which supports or echoes the earlier use of simile, because the question simply asks you to 'Write down another expression from the same paragraph which conveys a similar idea.'

Extract 3

The following examples are based upon an area which quite often causes problems for pupils, but it is actually more straightforward than you might imagine to answer these types of questions correctly.

These questions concentrate on sentence structure.

Since it is usually the case that pupils do often find these types of questions more difficult, you may want to skip forward and read over the 'How sentences are structured' page in this Bite.

Read this extract from a story called 'Tunes for Bears to Dance To', then answer the question which follows. Mr Hairston, who runs a shop, is talking to his young assistant Henry. At this point in the story, he is making comments about his customers.

"The customer's always right," he proclaimed one day, as if he could read Henry's mind. "But only in the store. When buying. Otherwise, they're only people. Stupid, most of them. Don't even know a bargain when they see one. So, why give them a bargain?"

The question on sentence structure based on this paragraph asks -

Question

(a) What is unusual about the writer's sentence construction in this paragraph? 2 - 0

(b) What does the writer's use of this construction suggest about Mr. Hairston's character? 2 - 0

toggle answer

Answer

(a) The 'sentences' are grammatically incomplete/they are short.

Either of these two answers = 2 marks:

  • to understand why these ideas are correct, it is important to realise that the sentences referred to are grammatically incomplete because they are not as completely constructed as they should be: for example, 'When buying' and 'Stupid, most of them' would, normally, say 'When they (the customers) are buying things' and 'They are stupid, most of them' or 'Most of them are stupid'
  • what is missing from both of these 'sentences' from the passage is a combination of both subjects and verbs (check over the 'How sentences are structured' page !)

(b)

  • Mr. Hairston is arrogant/short-tempered/self-assured/abrupt/blunt (any one of these ideas = 2 marks)
  • the point here is that even the way a sentence is structured can show what a character in a story is like as a person!

Extract 4

The final example in this revision bite offers another example of a sentence structure question. The extract is taken from a book called 'Yaxley's Cat'. A mum and her two children are in a cottage which needs quite a bit of tidying up and her young son, who is quite practical, has succeeded in getting an old water pump to work.

Timothy, who was practical like his Dad, had discovered a drum of paraffin in a lean-to, filled the oil-lamps and got them going. He used more paraffin, in a careful calculating way that brought her out in a cold sweat, to get the fire in the kitchen range going. He had also got the water-pump over the sink to work. At first it had only made disgusting wheezing sounds, but Tim had poured water down it from a butt in the garden, calling it "priming the pump" very professionally. At first it had pumped evil rusty red stuff, but now it ran clear, though Rose had visions of outbreaks of cholera and typhoid, and hurried dashes to the hospital in Norwich, and how would you ever get an ambulance up that path, but if you boiled all the water . . . Now he was winding up all the clocks and really getting them ticking.

Question

The question asks -

Look at the sentence beginning "At first it had pumped evil rusty stuff...". Show how the writer creates an impression of uneasy thoughts rushing through Rose's mind by his use of sentence structure. 2 - 1 - 0

toggle answer

Answer
  • It repeatedly uses conjunctions ('and' and 'but').
  • Its length (very long set of possible problems Rose sees).
  • It can be said to be a list style of sentence.
  • It is incompletely stated (use of dots, not a full stop, sees it trail off, as if there are more problems unmentioned).
  • Frequent use of commas, extending the sentence.
  • It is made up of a series of short sections.
  • It is not really a 'proper' sentence.

Any two of the above ideas would = 2 marks: any one idea would = 1 mark.

You do not need to know about all of these for every close reading text which you will read and answer questions on, but you should have a working knowledge of them, so that if questions on any of them do occur you are prepared.

If you feel confident enough about them at the moment, then read the following short extracts and study the examples of sample questions and answers. For each example given, try to jot down possible answers to the questions before you read the sample answers. A little more practice never goes amiss!

Page:

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  1. Next

Back to Close reading texts and techniques index

Explore the BBC

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.