BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

16 October 2014

Arnish Lighthouse

BBC Homepage
»Island Blogging
Western Isles

North Uist
South Uist

Argyll & Clyde Islands
Northern Isles

House Rules

From the BBC

Contact Us

Windfarm rejected?

It was reported on Friday evening that the windfarm, proposed for the north of Lewis, is set to be rejected by Scottish Ministers. The project was for 181 turbines, each standing 450 feet tall, marching from Port of Ness in the north to Bragar in the west and Stornoway in the south. This would have meant one turbine for every 400 yards.

The windfarm was approved by the Western Isles Council, who had hailed the proposal as the salvation for the local economy. WIC convener Alec MacDonald expressed his deep disappointment at the likely rejection. Saliently, the Isles MSP [Member of Scottish Parliament], Alasdair Allan, was happy at the turning-down of the windfarm, saying it was too big for Lewis.

The main reason for Scottish Ministers not to approve the windfarm would seem to be environmental considerations. The islands are peppered with environmental designations, and the bird charity RSPB was most vocal in its opposition. Granting approval would have exposed the UK government (note!) to legal action from the EU, as the scheme is in violation of various environmental directives.

A final decision is likely within the next few weeks, as the developer (Lewis Windpower, LWP) has been given three weeks to come up with a reason why the project should go ahead after all, in the face of the opposition put forward by the Scottish Government.

If the decision is confirmed as a rejection, this puts the other two projects (in Eishken and Pairc) in doubt as well, to my mind. The reason is the Interconnector, the link-up with the electricity grid on the mainland across the Minch. It is not at all certain that the 50-odd turbines on the Eishken Estate and the 26 in Pairc would justify a £1bn cable across the water.

All shall be concluded by the middle of February.
Posted on Arnish Lighthouse at 18:52


As soon as I heard this on the news, I thought of you, AL. Great news for the mainland too, the Interconnector would be a monstrosity running across the landscape.

Jill from EK

Excellent news. If true, it means that hundreds of long-term jobs in the tourist industry have been saved at the expense of a handful of short-term jobs erecting the turbines.

Malkie from Glasgow

"All shall be concluded by the middle of February." - very untrue. Whichever side "loses" this particular decision will fight on. The Calmac sunday ferry issue has much more of a chance of being resolved beforte the Lewis windiefarm one.

Digital Sands from Republic of Berneray

DS, you may well have a point. The fight is already on - see two posts on ("The Lewis Windfarm and the Council").

Arnish Lighthouse from Stornoway

And so to Europe...

Flying Cat from ...not Europie

This blog is now closed and we are no longer accepting new posts.

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy