Frozen body: Can we return from the dead?

Patient Care Bay - dewar being filled with liquid nitrogen

Related Stories

The idea of preserving a person's body at very low temperatures in the hope that it will be restored by future medical technology has been a staple of science fiction. But could cryonics be a genuine way of being brought back to life, years into the future?

What is the cryonic process?

How can water stay liquid beneath the freezing point?

Ice cold water in bottle
  • Water freezes at 0C, but there needs to be a "nucleus", like a piece of dust for example, around which the crystalline structure of ice can form
  • This means that it's possible to chill a purified liquid well below freezing point without it becoming a solid
  • You can witness this phenomenon by "supercooling" filtered water, which turns to ice as soon as it's poured from the bottle

When a person has been declared legally dead, the cryonic preservation company is informed and it dispatches a response team to attempt to keep the person's blood pumping around their body. The body is packed in ice and injected with various chemicals in an attempt to reduce blood clotting and damage to the brain.

Once the body reaches the cryonics facility it is cooled to just above water's freezing point and the blood is removed and replaced with organ preservation solution. The body's blood vessels are injected with a cryoprotectant solution to try to stop ice crystal formation in the organs and tissues and the corpse is cooled to -130C. The final step is to place the body into a container which is lowered into a tank of liquid nitrogen, kept at -196C.

Latest figures reveal that around 150 people have had their whole body stored in liquid nitrogen in the United States, while 80 have had just their heads or brains preserved. However, there are more than 1,000 living people who have instructed companies to preserve their bodies after their death.

Why do some people think it might work?

Cryonic preservation enthusiasts say there are three reasons to be hopeful. Firstly, despite an organisation being required to wait for a patient to be declared legally dead before they can be frozen, they claim that damage to the brain can be reduced by ensuring oxygen levels are maintained.

Secondly, cooling a body to a low enough temperature slows chemical processes in cells and tissues sufficiently to prevent any further degradation of the body.

Finally, while damage is inevitably inflicted on the body from the cooling process and any illness or ageing they might have suffered, they hope that future nanotechnology may be able to repair this.

What problems have scientists identified?

If a person is cooled below -5C the water inside their cells freezes and creates ice crystals. As ice is less dense than liquid water, it takes up more space. So the crystals punch through the cell membranes causing severe damage.

Cryonic preservation facilities attempt to overcome this by employing a process known as vitrification. This replaces some of the body's water with cryoprotectant agents, in an attempt to reduce the amount of ice crystal formation.

History of cryonics

  • 1964: Physics teacher Robert Ettinger publishes The Prospect of Immortality, the book that kick-starts the modern cryonics movement
  • 1967: James Bedford, a 73-year-old psychologist, becomes the first person to be cryogenically frozen
  • 1970s: The first commercial cryonics services start operating (though preservation is so costly that many of these will have closed by the following decade)
  • 2005: Scientists announce they have managed to plunge several dogs into a state of clinical death before bringing them back to life
  • 2011: After his death aged 92, Robert Ettinger becomes the 106th person to be stored at the Cryonics Institute, the cryopreservation company he founded in 1976

As yet there is no proof that we can vitrify human organs. Cryobiologist Dr Dayong Gao from the University of Washington, Seattle, said: "We know we can successfully vitrify very small things like insects and simple tissues like blood vessels. This is because the smaller size makes it easier to control cooling and cryoprotectants can be properly diffused."

So how will the organs of cryonics patients be affected? Dr Gao said: "We simply don't know if they've been damaged to the point where they've 'died' during vitrification because the subjects are now inside liquid nitrogen canisters."

The outcome isn't hopeful according to biochemist Prof Ken Storey, from Carleton University in Ottawa, Canada.

"We have many different organs and we know from research into preserving transplant organs that even if it were possible to successfully cryopreserve them, each would need to be cooled at a different rate and with a different mixture and concentration of cryoprotectants.

"Even if you only wanted to preserve the brain, it has dozens of different areas, which would need to be cryopreserved using different protocols."

Could a human survive the thaw?

If scientists did one day work out how to successfully cryopreserve a whole human body, there is still the matter of bringing the body back to life.

Dr Gao said: "Even if you manage to limit the damage from cryoprotectants, the question remains of how they would be safely removed."

Mark Miodownik freezes and thaws a carrot to show how ice damages cells.

There are other significant complications, such as the fact that cooling a body to -196C makes it incredibly brittle.

"The body could easily fracture like glass during warming due to thermal stress," Dr Gao said.

He added that the brain, which has as many as 10,000 connections for each of the 100 billion neurones, is particularly sensitive to heating and cooling.

What's the damage?

There is also the issue that bodies are likely not to be at the pinnacle of health, but at the end of life after illness and ageing have had their effect.

Cryonic preservation advocates say nanotechnology, which is the manipulation of matter at a molecular level, could one day provide a solution.

However, Prof Storey is extremely doubtful of this claim, because of the scale of the problems in each cell.

How much does it cost to be frozen?

  • Cryopreservation costs vary depending on whether the patient chooses to have their head or their entire body frozen
  • Patients can pay up to £52,000 to preserve their head, whereas freezing a full body is more difficult and can cost up to £130,000
  • Cryonics companies require patients to pay up front, instead of relying on family members or friends to pay the costs
  • This means the funding for preservation often comes from life insurance policies

"A human cell has around 50,000 proteins and hundreds of millions of fat molecules that make up the membranes. Cryopreservation disrupts all of them," he said.

A far more detailed understanding of how the brain works would also be critical in knowing what would need to be repaired.

Neuroscientist Dr Martin Ingvar from the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm said: "The subtle properties of the brain network are uneven. Some of these connections are crucial whereas others could be lost - but we do not know which ones."

Still, Dr Ingvar said a person's identity could theoretically be retained in the future if scientists worked out how to overcome the destructive effects of cryopreservation.

"If that could be solved, there is no reason why (in theory) a cryonic procedure couldn't preserve memories. However, it would be like time travel with a lot of confusion for the subject."

An uncertain future

However you look at it, cryonics is a matter of hope and belief in the future. Broad statements crop up on all cryonic organisation websites stating that while "there are no guarantees" cryopreservation can work "technology is always improving".

"People can always have hope that things will change in the future, but there is no scientific foundation supporting cryonics at this time," Dr Gao said.

More on This Story

Related Stories

Programmes

BBC iPlayer
  • Cloud LabCloud Lab Watch

    On BBC Two, the lab in the sky explores dramatic variations in the atmosphere


  • Dr Helen CzerskiHorizon Watch

    On BBC Two, physicist Dr Helen Czerski makes sense of Britain's extreme weather


Things To Do

RUN BY THE BBC AND PARTNERS

More Science Activities >

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.