Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Radio


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Top Goose Question Time

Oscar Merne posed this very interesting question via the Comments board:

"Crossing the Greenland icecap at over 2,700 m must push the Light-bellied Brent Geese into an area of quite low oxygen, and air temperatures of minus many degrees Celsius. I presume their feathers are capable of keeping them well insulated from the severe cold, but how do they cope with oxygen deprivation during a crossing that must take many hours?"

We thought we'd get our migration guru and Fellow of the Royal Society, Professor Colin Pennycuick to answer this question.

Report information

Bird respiratory systems are more complicated than those of mammals.

The lung itself is a compact organ with air channels running through it, and a system of air sacs draws air through these channels, always in the same direction, whether the bird is breathing in or out. The blood vessels in the lung run parallel to the air channels, with the blood flowing in the opposite direction to the air. This counter-current arrangement allows a bird to extract oxygen from the air, even when the air pressure is too low for the dead-end lungs of mammals to operate.

Bar-headed geese migrate over the Himalayas, doing much better than mountaineers (mammals!) struggling below.

Actually 2,700 m is not all that high. Mountaineers function all right at that height, and plenty of birds (especially waders) fly higher when they migrate, even without any mountains to get over. We do not have a usable theory to calculate the actual rate at which a bird can extract oxygen for the air at a given height, but we hope to get a handle on this by observing the maximum rate of climb that our geese can manage at different heights, as they climb up to get over the Greenland ice cap.

Geese are indeed well insulated, but when they fly the thinly-feathered area under the wing is exposed to the air flow. That is necessary, because the problem in flapping flight is disposing of excess heat, rather than keeping warm.

Colin Pennycuick

Further Reading:

Next report: Top Goose migrates to Iceland
Last report: Brett and Larry tag 3 Geese in Scotland
Where are they right now? Maps can be found at the Top Goose website

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy