Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Radio


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Mysteries of Humpback Migration

We wanted to shed some light on the big questions of Humpback migration so we contacted Professor Scott Baker from Oregon State University. He has been studying Humpbacks in the South Pacific and his work into maternal fidelity might have some answers.

Humpback Whale by Jim Kelnhofer

The Mystery of Migration

How do Humpbacks know what migratory route to take and why do they sing on migration?

Embed this code into your website or blog to display our audio player.

<object width="300" height="222"><param name="movie" value="http://bbc.co.uk/radio4/worldonthemove/share/audio-player.swf"><embed src="http://bbc.co.uk/radio4/worldonthemove/share/audio-player.swf" width="300" height="222"></embed></object>
Close

World On the Move desktop widget

Download the World On the Move desktop widget and keep up to date with the latest audio reports direct to you desktop.

Close

Report information

In our last report, we heard from Yves Lefevre who is based on Rurutu, French Polynesia. Scientists think that what Yves says is right, that they are going south to the Antarctic when they leave Rurutu, but actually there is no evidence of this! We don’t know where they go to exactly.

How do Humpbacks know where to migrate to? The first migration for a young calf, from the feeding ground and then back to the tropical breeding ground is shown to it by its mother. This path is learned by the calf, and remembered. It is then unlikely to deviate from this path, except for one-off ‘holidays’ for the rest of its migratory life – some 60 to 70 years.

Scott and his team tested the Humpback’s migration patterns using mitochondrial DNA. They found young male Humpbacks received their migratory destination from their mothers but it wasn't hardwired. Without the mother physically showing the way, they would not take the right route. The migration is, essentially, learned.

You might think that, having learned from their mother where to go when migrating, and sticking to that path, they might stick with their mother. But they don’t. They tend not to adhere to family groups, although they do travel in small units, of 3, 4 or 5 whales. They’re not like elephants for example who live in matrilineal groups - Humpbacks usually detach from their mother's company after a year when they are adults and can use the migratory route on its own.

This maternal fidelity exists in other species but is very strong in Humpback Whales. Their ability to learn from their mothers has lasted tens of thousands of years, in a habitat with no geographical barriers. To the whales themselves, the oceans are structured, but without physical barriers. They use various mechanisms to get from A to B. They have some magnetic sense, and some scientists are researching whether the whales also use celestial/astrological navigation, the sun, the moon, the stars. Following the topography of the seabed is an important mechanism for navigation. They are able to envisage a map of the seabed by analysing the sound signatures of certain locations.

Sound is therefore important in migration. The Humpbacks use aural cues as well as physical ones. And they are making sound as they move. It was first thought that whales only sang when they were on the breeding grounds, but since the 80s, we’ve known that they also sing as they migrate. The function of this migratory singing is unclear, or at least disputed among whale experts.

Some experts think that the boundaries are unclear in some cases between the migration path and the breeding ground, so what we’ve recorded and think is migrating sound is actually breeding sound. Some think that the breeding is a bit of an ongoing event, and is still happening as the whales migrate. Scott doesn’t think so – for a start, the female cycle is over by the time they’re migrating. And the females don’t respond when they hear the song as they move. The song ends at the feeding ground, when the whales make different noises, calling noises, without the song.

The audio of the Humpback's song was recorded off the SW coast of Madagascar on July 18, 2007.

Further Reading:

Last report: Swimming with Humpbacks

Audio by Salvatore Cerchio for Wildlife Conservation Society
Images from Marine Mammal Institute

User comments

Kathy Lang
Last year my partner and I sailed in a 35ft boat from St Martin, West Indies to France via the Azores between May and July. Before and after the Azores, on 3 separate occasions single fin whales, each around 50-55ft, came close to look at us, each time appearing close and doing a sort of 'cartwheel' in the water before diving under the boat, resurfacing on the other side then leaving. However although I would have loved to have seen a humpback whale we never did. We'd heard that Silver Bank was a good place to see them but didn't have time to go there - for next time we do a long sail [would like to head for Patagonia if possible] is there a good place to see humpbacks, without disturbing them of course? The whale song on this clip is fascinating - we often heard dolphins through the boat's hull before seeing them, and I wonder if a whale song could be heard the same way? Thanks! LOCATION: 51.4036,-3.2712 DATE: Wed, 29 Oct 2008 21:32:22 GMT WOtM team: Well, the great thing about Humpbacks is that they can be found all over the place - Alaska, the Caribbean, French Polynesia. However, the difficulty is all to do with timing. In the northern hemisphere, the Humpbacks spend the summer in arctic waters and move back to tropical waters to breed in time for winter.

Mark Outten
Please tell me more about the wildlife in the Masai Mara and the follow up on the lion that you guys tracked earlier. Reason - I'm going with my family to S Africa 4 my youngest brothers wedding (sunset) 1/nov/2008. Will be staying at WELGEVONDEN GAME RESERVE from 29/11/08 and anything would be helpful - I will of course reciprocate, with whatever I see. LOCATION: 50.7427,-1.9556 DATE: Fri, 24 Oct 2008 16:41:59 GMT WOtM team: Big Cat Live is the place to go to find out about those Lions: www.bbc.co.uk/bigcat

Oliver
These are majestic animals who have been around a lot longer than we have. Is it not possible for our government to pull their finger out and do more to stop the japenese whiping whales off the face of the earth? They must be able to get at least that right! LOCATION: 47.366699,8.550000 DATE: Thu, 23 Oct 2008 05:25:02 GMT

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy