BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

BBC Homepage
BBC Radio
BBC Radio 4 - 92 to 94 FM and 198 Long WaveListen to Digital Radio, Digital TV and OnlineListen on Digital Radio, Digital TV and Online

Radio 4 Tickets
Radio 4 Help

Contact Us

Go to the Listen Again page
Inside the Ethics Committee
Wednesdays 6 - 27 August 2008 8.00-8.45pm
Repeated Saturdays 9 - 30 August 10.15-11.00pm
Contact us
Wed 6 August 2008 (rpt Sat) 
Listen to this programme in full
Vivienne Parry returns with a fourth series of Inside the Ethics Committee. She is joined by a panel of experts to discuss real-life medical cases.
Full Programme Transcript >>

Programme 1 – Saviour Siblings

Three-year-old Catherine has a life-threatening condition. She desperately needs a bone marrow transplant from a sibling who matches her tissue type, a so-called 'saviour sibling'. But what are the ethics of creating a child, and then putting him or her at risk, to save another?

In the first of this returning series of Inside the Ethics Committee, Vivienne Parry is joined by a panel of experts to discuss Catherine’s case.

Catherine was born with Diamond Blackfan Anaemia, a rare blood disorder in which few, if any, red blood cells are produced by the bone marrow, causing anaemia.

She has to endure a gruelling regime of medical treatments to boost her red blood cells, but it’s by no means perfect. A quarter of patients die before they reach the age of thirty five.

A bone marrow transplant from a saviour sibling could save her.

Should baby be risked for sister? Read Vivienne Parry's aticle for the BBC News web site.

Ethical Issues

- Should Catherine’s parents select an embryo to be a saviour sibling for Catherine?

- What are the ethical considerations of extracting bone marrow from a sibling donor, when s/he won’t personally benefit from the procedure?

- A bone marrow transplant could cure the anaemia part of Catherine’s condition, but it doesn’t cure the condition. And the transplant itself carries numerous risks, including death, bone marrow rejection and sterility. So how do parents and medical staff weigh up these risks against the potential benefits she may reap?

- What is in the best interests of the family as a whole?

The Panel

- Deborah Bowman is a Senior Lecturer in Medical Ethics and Law at St George's Hospital University of London.

- Prof Peter Braude runs the largest pre-implantation genetic diagnosis centre in the UK at Guys and St Thomas’ Hospital NHS Trust.

- Dr Simon Meller is a Paediatric Oncologist, formerly of the Royal Marsden, who has a special interest in medical ethics.

Archive: Series 1
Archive: Series 2
Archive: Series 3
    Listen Live
    Audio Help

    Current Programmes

    Archived programmes

    About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy