BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.


Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Radio
BBC Radio 4 - 92 to 94 FM and 198 Long WaveListen to Digital Radio, Digital TV and OnlineListen on Digital Radio, Digital TV and Online

PROGRAMME FINDER:
Programmes
Podcasts
Schedule
Presenters
PROGRAMME GENRES:
News
Drama
Comedy
Science
Religion|Ethics
History
Factual
Messageboards
Radio 4 Tickets
Radio 4 Help

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Science
CASE NOTES
MISSED A PROGRAMME?
Go to the Listen Again page
PROGRAMME INFO
Tuesday 21:00-21:30
Repeat Wednesday 16:30
Dr Mark Porter gives listeners the low-down on what the medical profession does and doesn't know. Each week an expert in the studio tackles a particular topic and there are reports from around the UK on the health of the nation - and the NHS.
Contact Case Notes
LISTEN AGAINListen 30 min
Listen to 19 July
PRESENTER
DR MARK PORTER
Dr Mark Porter
PROGRAMME DETAILS
Tuesday 19 July 2005
A homeopathic remedy and drawers

Full programme transcript >>

Homeopathy

In the UK today there are five NHS homeopathic hospitals, in Bristol, Liverpool, Glasgow, London and Tunbridge Wells.

In this episode of Case Notes Dr Mark Porter visits one of them: the Bristol Homeopathic Hospital.

He discovers how patients get referred there and with what kind of conditions.

He explores the relationship between homeopathy and orthodox medicine by talking to experts from Bristol and Glasgow who have been trained in both disciplines.

Like cures like

Homeopathy is based on the principle that like cures like.

Homeopathic practitioners believe that whereas mainstream medicine seeks to relieve illness by suppressing a patient's symptoms, their approach helps to stimulate the body to deal with the underlying problem.

By using doses of substances which have been diluted so much that they are undetectable, to enhance the symptoms of a specific condition, homeopathy seeks to trigger the body's own defences.

A holistic approach

Mark sits in on a consultation between Dr David Spence, Clinical Director of the Bristol Homeopathic Hospital, and one of his patients.

As well as having more time - up to 45 minutes for an initial consultation - homeopathic practitioners look at the person, not just the symptoms.

This overall picture helps them to select exactly the right remedy to suit the individual - and there are more than 3,500 to choose from.

A controversial therapy

Despite its growing popularity, there's mixed evidence to back up the claims of how effective homeopathy is.

This means that many in the mainstream medical community are cynical about its usefulness.

Dr Elizabeth Thompson, Consultant Homeopathic Physician at the Bristol Homeopathic Hospital, tells Mark why she feels that it's the type of trials, rather than the medicine itself, that causes these poor results, and that a different approach is needed to prove that homeopathy is a helpful treatment.

24 hour homeopathic care

Mark talks to Dr David Reilly, Consultant at the Glasgow Homeopathic Hospital about the hospital's unique in-patients ward.

The ward recently escaped closure due to proposed budget cuts. 

Dr Reilly tells Mark why he feels it offers a vital service to these patients, 500 of whom stay use the 15 beds every year.  

He says that a year after their stay at the hospital, up to 70% of them report a real change in the quality of their lives, they visit their GPs less often and have fewer visits to hospitals elsewhere.

Future Doctors

Medical student Charlotte Ellis is doing a placement at the Bristol Homeopathic hospital, as part of her training. 

She's keen to listen to patients' needs, and hopes to use some of her experiences when she qualifies.
Listen Live
Audio Help
DON'T MISS
Leading Edge
PREVIOUS PROGRAMMES
Emergency Services
Ovary
Heart Attacks
Appendix
Insects
Cot Death
Antibiotics and Probiotics
Taste
Abortion
HPV 
Hair
Poisons
Urology
Aneurysms
Bariatric Surgery
Gardening
Pain
Backs - Slipped Discs
Prostate Cancer
Sun and Skin
Knees
Screening
Rheumatology
Bowel Cancer
Herpes
Thyroid
Fainting
Liver
Cystic Fibrosis
Superbugs
Side Effects
Metabolic Syndrome
Transplants
Down's Syndrome
The Voice
M.E./CFS
Meningitis
Childhood Burns
Statins
Alzheimer's
Headaches
Feet
Sexual Problems
IBS
Me and My Op
Lung Cancer and Smoking
Cervical Cancer
Hips
Caesarean Sections
The Nose
Multiple Sclerosis
Radiology
Palliative Care
Eyes
Shoulders
Leukaemia
Blood Pressure
Contraception
Parkinson's Disease
Head Injuries
Tropical Health
Ears
Arts and Health 
Allergies
Nausea
Menopause and Osteoporosis
Immunisation
Intensive Care (ICU)
Manic Depression
The Bowel
Arthritis
Itching
Fractures
The Jaw
Keyhole Surgery
Prescriptions
Epilepsy
Hernias
Asthma
Hands
Out of Hours
Kidneys
Body Temperature
Stroke
Face Transplants
Backs
Heart Failure
The Royal Marsden Hospital
Vitamins
Cosmetic Surgery
Tired All The Time (TATT)
Obesity
Anaesthesia
Coronary Artery Surgery
Choice in the NHS
Back to School
Homeopathy
Hearing and Balance
First Aid
Dentists
Alder Hey Hospital - Children's Health
Thrombosis
Arrhythmias
Pregnancy
Moorfields Eye Hospital
Wound Healing
Joint Replacements
Premature Babies
Prison Medicine
Light
Respiratory Medicine
Indigestion
Urinary Incontinence
The Waiting Game
Diabetes
Contraception
Depression
Auto-immune Diseases
Prescribing Drugs
Get Fit and Get Well Food
Autism
Vaccinations
Oral Health
Blood
Heart Attacks
Genetic Screening
Fertility
A+E & Triage
Antibiotics
Screening Tests
Sexual Health
Baldness


Back to Latest Programme
Health & Wellbeing Programmes
Current Programmes
Archived Programmes

News & Current Affairs | Arts & Drama | Comedy & Quizzes | Science | Religion & Ethics | History | Factual

Back to top


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy