On Radio 4 Now

Shipping Forecast

17:54 - 17:57

The latest shipping forecast.

Coming up at: 17:57

Weather

View full schedule

Woman's Hour

Weekdays 10-11am, Saturdays 4-5pm

Celebrating, informing and entertaining women

Brand navigation

Woman's Hour Balloon Debate

Hot Air Balloon

At the start of a new era in politics Woman's Hour asks: who has done the most to put women on the political map in the UK?

On Wednesday 16th June Jenni Murray hosted a live debate at BBC Broadcasting House, where four advocates tried to persuade a 300-strong studio audience that the individual whose cause they were championing has done the most to give women a voice in British politics.

A show of hands by the studio audience decided which characters were thrown out of the balloon and which one remained.

Find out who the audience decided should be the last remaining character in the balloon.

The characters in the balloon have been selected from a long list.

Video Highlight

After the first two candidates have been ejected from the Woman's Hour Balloon, the audience choose between the two remaining women, Mary Wollstonecraft and Emmeline Pankhurst.

More Videos: Caroline Flint MP for Barbara Castle | Louise Bagshawe MP for Margaret Thatcher | Prof. Mary Beard for Mary Wollstonecraft | Shami Chakrabarti for Emmeline Pankhurst

In the balloon

  • Margaret Thatcher

    Margaret Thatcher (1925 - )

    Watch Louise Bagshawe MP advocate for Margaret Thatcher

    The only woman to have served as British Prime Minister, winning three successive General Elections to hold office for eleven years. A powerful force on the international stage, the Soviets dubbed her the "Iron Lady". She was one of the dominant political figures of the 20th century with Thatcherism having a major influence on politics. The daughter of a grocer, upon her election as PM she said she owed "almost everything" to her father. Baroness Thatcher now sits in the House of Lords.

    More information:

    BBC Search+

    Woman's Hour Timeline

    Advocate: Louise Bagshawe, novelist and Conservative MP

    Louise Bagshawe is a best-selling author who has just entered Parliament as the Conservative MP for Corby and East Northamptonshire. She joined the Conservative Party at the age of 14 after being inspired by the then-Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher - a woman she describes as "standing out like a beacon". She started her career in the record industry but left after publishing her first novel, 'Career Girls' in her 20s. She went on to publish 11 more novels, the latest entitled 'Sparkles', 'Glamour', 'Glitz, 'Passion' and 'Desire'.

  •   
  • Barbara Castle

    Barbara Castle (1910-2002)

    Watch Caroline Flint MP advocate for Barbara Castle

    Known as Labour's Red Queen not only for her flame coloured hair but for her trail-blazing for women in politics. A campaigner throughout her political life, she was the architect of legislation in the 1970s giving women the rights to equal pay with men. On her death, Tony Blair described her as "an extraordinary pioneer for women in politics". To an admirer who asked why she was never prime minister, she replied: "They wouldn't have me, darling, because I'm a woman."

    More information:

    BBC Archive

    Woman's Hour Timeline

    Advocate: Caroline Flint MP and former Labour minister

    Caroline Flint served as a minister in Gordon Brown's government. Her resignation last summer grabbed the headlines when she accused the Prime Minister of treating women attending Cabinet meetings as "little more than female window dressing". She was one of 101 Labour women elected to parliament in 1997. In 2003 she got her first ministerial job, and proving herself an able performer, moved swiftly through the ranks to become Housing then Europe Minister. She was re-elected MP for Don Valley in May.

  •   
  • Emmeline Pankhurst

    Emmeline Pankhurst (1858-1928)

    Watch Shami Chakrabarti advocate for Emmeline Pankhurst

    Pankhurst was a leading activist in fighting for women's rights in Britain. She attended her first suffrage meeting aged 14 and went on to set up the Women's Social and Political Union with her daughters to campaign for the right for women to vote. As a figurehead for the suffragette movement she was responsible for increasing militancy among supporters. Her actions led to her being repeatedly imprisoned where she went on hunger strike. She died in 1928, the year that women gained the same voting rights as men.

    More information:

    BBC History

    Woman's Hour Timeline

    Advocate: Shami Chakrabarti, Director of Liberty

    Shami Chakrabarti is Director of the campaign group Liberty. A barrister by training, she worked as a lawyer in the Home Office under both Conservative and Labour governments. She joined Liberty in 2001, becoming its director two years later. A powerful advocate of human rights and civil liberties, she has a high profile as a broadcaster and in print. In 2007 she was appointed CBE for services to human rights. Among her other roles she is Chancellor of Oxford Brookes University, and a Governor of the London School of Economics.

  •   
  • Mary Wollstonecraft

    Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797)

    Watch Prof. Mary Beard advocate for Mary Wollstonecraft

    Viewed by many as the "mother of feminism". In 1792 she wrote her great work, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, in which she extended the Enlightenment idea of the "rights of man" to women and laid the groundwork for women's liberation. She stressed the importance of education and female autonomy. "Strengthen the female mind by enlarging it", she said, "and there will be an end to blind obedience." Although her revolutionary views led her to be dubbed "a hyena in petticoats", she continued to intrigue and inspire generations that followed.

    More information:

    BBC History

    Woman's Hour Timeline

    In Our Time

    Advocate: Mary Beard, Professor of Classics at Cambridge University

    Mary Beard is Professor of Classics at the University of Cambridge and a fellow of Newnham College. She is also Classics Editor of the Times Literary Supplement, and her many books, articles and media appearances have led to her being called 'Britain's best-known classicist'. In her blog for Times online, entitled "A don's life", she describes herself as "a wickedly subversive commentator on both the modern and the ancient world." The most recent of her books are 'The Roman Triumph' (2007) and 'Pompeii: the life of a Roman Town' (2008), which is being made into a BBC series.

Your Comments

During the programme people listened to the debate and contributed comments on this page, via Twitter at #WHballoon and via email directly to the show. The live chat has closed now, but you can still read some of the comments that were made during the show by pressing "replay" on the button below.

The Winner

Margaret Thatcher and Barbara Castle were the first of the candidates to be ejected from the balloon leaving Mary Wollstonecraft and Emmeline Pankhurst. The studio audience selected Emmeline Pankhurst as the woman that they felt had done the most to put women on the political map in the UK.

Do you agree with the audience's verdict? You can leave further comments on the Radio 4 blog.

The Longlist

The Woman's Hour team invited a number of leading women including commentators, academics and politicians to choose which four names from the following list they would put into the balloon.

  • Margaret Thatcher, first woman Prime Minister
  • Edith Summerskill, Labour politician and women's rights campaigner(1901-1980)
  • Emmeline Pankhurst, suffragette (1858-1928)
  • Millicent Garrett Fawcett, suffragist (1847-1929)
  • Barbara Castle, Labour politician (1910-2002)
  • Nancy Astor, first female MP to take her seat (1879-1964)
  • Tony Blair, 1997 election of 101 Labour women MPs
  • Elizabeth I, Queen of the Golden Age (1533-1603)
  • Mary Wollstonecraft, philosopher and writer (1759-97)
  • Eleanor Rathbone, social reformer and MP (1872-1946)

Nominations came from Ceri Goddard, Professor Joanna Bourke, Natasha Walter, Polly Toynbee, Baroness Shirley Williams, Joan Bakewell, Anastasia De Waal, Jude Kelly, Brenda Maddox, Val McDermid, Minette Marrin, Baroness Estelle Morris, Finn McKay, Cristina Odone, Shami Chakrabarti, Ann Treneman and Professor Angela John.

Additional names they put forward included Marie Stopes, Shirley Williams, Constance Markievicz, Helen John, Hilary Clinton, Baroness Boothroyd, Sylvia Pankhurst and Viscountess Rhondda.

Last On

Woman's Hour

Available to listen

Weekend Woman's Hour: Dragons Den's Hilary Devey

Shirley Manson on women in the music business, and Dragons Den's Hilary Devey.

Coming Up

Woman's Hour

28 May 2012

28/05/2012

Mary Tudor's bloody reign, women denied asylum, singer Regina Spektor, and Rebecca Front.

Podcast

Woman's Hour: News, Politics, Culture

Download or subscribe to this programme's podcast

Podcast Button Podcast Help Button

bbc.co.uk navigation

BBC © 2012 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.