Perhaps the chamber-orchestral scale of Ives’s Third Symphony wasn’t the ideal work for the hall, but there was plenty of subtle colouring and a robust attitude to the composer’s rhythmic interplay in this, his most unprovocative work.
There was a dramatic immediacy to American soprano Deborah Voigt’s sumptuously voiced performance of the closing scene from Strauss’s Salome along with an ability to defy the hall’s soloist-swallowing properties in getting both the notes and the words across.
THE DAILY TELEGRAPH
With their clean-cut playing and lucid textures, the San Francisco players gave it (The Ives Symphony) a dewy-eyed innocence, motivated by Thomas with care and sensitivity.
THE GUARDIAN
Whatever the intention, this (Shostakovich) was a super-cool, almost abstract performance, at times seeming uncertain as to its own tone of voice, and at times seeking to reveal more about the character of the orchestra than that of the symphony itself.
THE TIMES
What you said:
Geoffrey Norris This a profound thank you for the Music Notes available on Digital , this greatly enhanced my enjoyment I accessed them for the first time in the past week. Thank you.
James Baring Shostakovitch No5: Brilliant camera and sound made this superb performance by the San Francisco Symphony a unique and amazing experience.
Please note that we cannot guarantee to publish all reviews. They should be under 500 words in length and should not contain offensive or defamatory language. See Terms of Use below for more information.