Episode 13

Image for Episode 13Not currently available on BBC iPlayer

Sunday Morning Live, Series 4 Episode 13 of 20

Duration: 1 hour

Samira Ahmed and her guests - campaigner Rev George Hargreaves, broadcaster Simon Fanshawe, reality TV star Katie Hopkins, and James Newman from Catholic Voices - debate the ethical and religious issues of the week

This week:

Should teachers be tougher on bad behaviour at school?

Schools are being advised that they should 'systematically measure' children's happiness levels to stop them going off the rails, according to new guidelines from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Some education groups say that this is further evidence of a 'Nanny state'. Have we become too soft on children at school? Or would a harsher approach only make the problem worse?

Should recruitment be based on diversity rather than ability?

Home Office Minister Damian Green says the police must make more use of equality laws to increase the number of black and ethnic minority officers serving. Simon Fanshawe argues in his Sunday Stand this week that all employers should stop simply always hiring 'the best person for the job'. Instead, they should actively recruit as diverse a workforce as possible. Not only will this open up more opportunities for more people - it will also improve business performance.

Does John Paul II deserve to be a saint?

Pope Francis will soon make saints of two of contemporary Catholicism's most important figures - Pope John XXIII and Pope John Paul II. Many Catholics were calling for John Paul II's sainthood immediately after his death. Pope John Paul II is credited with two miracles and is said to have played an important role in ending Communism in Europe, as well as improving relationships with other religions. However, there are some who oppose making him a saint, noting that he oversaw the church during a period in which clergy sex abuse was covered up.

  • This week's panellists

    Samira Ahemd is joined in the studio this week by writer and broadcaster Simon Fanshawe, Christian minister and political campaigner Rev George Hargreaves, business woman and social commentator Katie Hopkins, James Newman from Catholic Voices.

  • Should teachers be tougher on bad behaviour at school?

    Schools are being advised that they should “systematically measure” children’s happiness levels to stop them going off the rails, according to new guidelines from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Some education groups say that this is further evidence of a ‘Nanny state’. 

     

     

     

    Reports also emerged this week that teachers at a school in Birmingham are considering industrial action after a student excluded for threatening fellow pupils with a knife was allowed to return to lessons. Have we become to soft on children at school? Or would a harsher approach only make the problem worse?

  • Should recruitment be based on diversity rather than ability?

    This month the Police Minister Damian Green said the police must make more use of equality laws to increase the number of black and ethnic minority officers serving. He said: “Police legal departments are naturally risk averse when it comes to diversity, they shouldn’t be. 

    “It is unlawful to have recruitment quotas based solely on race or gender, but recruitment quotas are not the only means to achieving diversity.”

     

    Simon Fanshawe argues in his Sunday Stand this week that all employers should stop simply always hiring “the best person for the job”. Instead they should actively recruit as diverse a workforce as possible. Not only will this open up more opportunities for more people – it will also improve business performance.  

  • Does John Paul II deserve to be a saint?

    On Monday Pope Francis is expected to announce the date when he will make saints of two of contemporary Catholicism’s most important figures – Pope John XXIII and Pope John Paul II. 

    Historically it has taken centuries for someone to become a saint, although many Catholics were calling for John Paul II’s sainthood immediately after his death. Pope Benedict XVI waived the five-year waiting period usually considered standard before beginning an investigation. Many consider John Paul II to have had a massive effect on ending Communism in Europe and credit him with improving relationships with other religions. 


    However, there are some who oppose making John Paul II a saint, noting that he oversaw the church during a period in which clergy sex abuse was covered up, causing the greatest damage to the church in memory. There are also many non-Catholics who disagree with venerating a man who spoke out against abortion and contraception.

Credits

Presenter
Samira Ahmed
Series Editor
Dave Stanford
Producer
Neil Dimmock
Participant
George Hargreaves
Participant
Simon Fanshawe
Participant
Katie Hopkins
Participant
James Newman

Broadcasts

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.