iPlayer Radio What's New?
Listen
Series 10 - 3. Treating Patients with Dementia
Image for Lords, lordlings and....crumpets

Listen now 10 mins

Listen in pop-out player

Lords, lordlings and....crumpets

Duration:
10 minutes
First broadcast:
Friday 04 May 2012

Fifteen years ago - Will Self writes - he had afternoon tea in the House of Lords with the late Conrad Russell. The distinguished historian was a hereditary peer who was entirely in favour of Lords' abolition. What Will Self remembers most about the encounter was the crumpets. "'Do have another crumpet" he'd say, 'they really are awfully good'". Fifteen years on, Will says: "Russell was right about the crumpets - and he was right about the hereditaries".

He looks forward to the Queen's Speech, which is widely expected to include a bill on Lords reform. A waste of time, he believes. But that matters little in his view. "After all, the first bill to create an elected second chamber was introduced over a century ago - and doesn't this simply prove that the great and glorious fudge that's the unwritten British constitution thrives on such slow and organic change".

Via what he calls the "Googlisation" of the political process, he attacks the move towards the centre ground by all three main UK parties. "We...are tormented by politicans who look the same, sound the same and spout so-called 'policies' that are usually only marginally different versions of the same routine ideas".

Back at the Lords, he concludes, hereditary peers "are still busily tucking into their excellent crumpets. Yummy-yummy".

Producer: Adele Armstrong.

  • A POINT OF VIEW: LORDS, LORDLINGS... AND CRUMPETS

    A POINT OF VIEW:  LORDS, LORDLINGS... AND CRUMPETS

    Reforming the House of Lords is a topic that, for some, can have a soporific effect (much like too many buttered crumpets in the peers' tea room). But is this torpor - and the slow pace of change - adding to a democratic deficit, asks Will Self.

    Read Will Self's article on BBC News website

Broadcasts

The Best of A Point of View

The Best of A Point of View

Explore highlights from the A Point of View archive.

Free downloads

  1. Image for A Point of View

    A Point of View

    Weekly reflections on topical issues from a range of contributors including historian Lisa Jardine,…

  2. Image for A Point of View: Clive James

    A Point of View: Clive James

    Clive James presents reflections on topical issues ranging from politics to pop culture in this…

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Added. Check out your playlist Dismiss