BBC One
 
  1. BBC One
  2. Programmes
  3. Film 2009 with Jonathan Ross
  4. Episode 22

Episode 22

Watch:

Availability:

Sorry, this programme is not available to watch again but we do have these Clips.

Last broadcast on Wed, 11 Nov 2009, 00:25 on BBC One (Wales only) (see all broadcasts).

Synopsis

Jonathan reviews Michael Caine's new urban drama Harry Brown, the disaster movie 2012, and Amelia, the biopic of world famous aviatrix Amelia Earhart, starring double Oscar winner Hilary Swank. Another Academy Award recipient, director Ang Lee, joins Jonathan in the studio to discuss his latest film Taking Woodstock.

JONATHAN'S REVIEW OF 2012

"AS RELENTLESSLY UNIMAGINATIVE AS IT IS INSULTINGLY LAZY".

No one expects subtlety from a Roland Emmerich film, but you do have a right to anticipate more than a continuation of his last movie but one. And at times during '2012' I thought I was watching out-takes from 'The Day After Tomorrow'.

All that can be said for this film is that, unsurprisingly, the computer-generated effects are impressive. Other than that it offers the standard disaster movie set up, then watches a group of characters escape one natural disaster after another - on foot, in cars, in helicopters, in planes - in a way that strains the suspension of disbelief well beyond breaking point.

The potentially intriguing piece of hokum about the Mayan calendar is thrown away in the first five minutes, and what follows is a film that's as relentlessly unimaginative as it is insultingly lazy.

How could untold millions have been spent on making it when the script doesn't make any kind of sense even in terms of its own internal logic?

With an awful, embarrassing sub-plot about John Cusack and his family thrown in for good measure, the whole sorry mess made me yearn for the work of 70s 'Master of Disaster' Irwin Allen. And if the world really is going to end in '2012', at least I'll never have to sit through a film like this again.

JONATHAN'S REVIEW OF HARRY BROWN

"HARRY BROWN IS A GOOD EFFORT"

Once the straightforward premise of 'Harry Brown' has been laid out, it's not difficult to work out where we are or where we're heading.

If it rises above the obvious line that it's 'Death Wish for Pensioners', that's not because it lives up to its makers' billing as "an urban Western". What lifts the film out of the ordinary is not any sense of poetry or the timeless values of a classic genre, but Michael Caine's command of the screen and his skilful portrayal of a wounded, frustrated and very angry man.

And with such a dominant performance at its heart, it's maybe no great surprise this picture feels rather uneven in places. Emily Mortimer isn't at her most comfortable as a policewoman in a particularly grim inner city environment, while her boss seems to have been transplanted from another film altogether - possibly a Miss Marple mystery starring Margaret Rutherford.

In turn those kinds of characters from a bygone age are at odds with the streak of violence which runs through the film. But those weaknesses aside, 'Harry Brown' is a good effort - the story holds together, and while these days much of his film work consists of interesting supporting roles, Michael Caine reminds us that he still has plenty of shots in his locker as a leading man.

JONATHAN'S REVIEW OF AMELIA

"DESPERATELY UNEXCITING"

To an extent, 'Amelia' looks and sounds rather like a biopic which might have rolled off the production line during the heyday of the studio system. But only to an extent, because while it's slick and thoroughly professional, it's also desperately unexciting.

It's not too difficult to imagine this story being made in the 40s with Bette Davis or Katharine Hepburn in the lead role - when the treatment would probably have been rather livelier than it is here, and maybe even a bit raunchier.

As it is, despite the fact that Amelia Earhart seems to be a very contemporary figure, the treatment of her unconventional love life is so coy that it's not just oddly genteel but also rather boring.

That sense of being overly respectful runs right through the film. Everything's staged in an attractive way by director Mira Nair, and there are no holes to pick in the leading performances - Hilary Swank and Richard Gere are both absolutely solid, while Christopher Eccleston and Ewan McGregor deliver perfectly adequate support.

The problem is there's nothing to get excited about either, and that's the major flaw in this strangely stately film. With such a strong, vivid story to draw upon, it somehow manages to be completely devoid of passion or drama.

Credits

Presenter
Jonathan Ross
Director
Emma Pollock
Producer
Tom Webber
Assistant Producer
Bex Palmer
Assistant Producer
Howard Brenner

Broadcasts

  1. Tue 10 Nov 2009
    23:25
  2. Tue 10 Nov 2009
    23:55
  3. Wed 11 Nov 2009
    00:25

More details

Episode 22 of 28 from

In this series

Previous:
Next:

Duration

30 minutes

More like this

Find related BBC One programmes.

Explore the BBC

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.