Home > Opinion > Disability Bitch > Disability Bitch vs clever internet stuff
Disability Bitch
Disability Bitch vs clever internet stuff
11th March 2009
Readers, this week my miserable woe-begotten bitchy world was visited by a chink of light. A small chink, but a chink nonetheless. You see, taking time out from reading the very tasteful hour-by-hour coverage of Jade Goody's illness, I discovered that Prime Minister Gordon Brown has come up with a genius plan!
No, he hasn't saved us all from global recession and no, he won't be recommending that Disability Living Allowance increases by 25 per cent, but he has said that public services should be as cool as eBay and Amazon (that's me paraphrasing). Unlikely as it sounds, he wants us all to rate the performance of everything from councils to doctors using a sophisticated online feedback system similar to those employed by the popular web retail giants.
• EBay-style feedback for services
Brown reckons this will lead to 'higher standards of transparency'. Cos reading people's comments on the web is always very useful, LoL, :-) ... It's all part of an 'information revolution', people. I bet you're thrilled.
• EBay-style feedback for services
Brown reckons this will lead to 'higher standards of transparency'. Cos reading people's comments on the web is always very useful, LoL, :-) ... It's all part of an 'information revolution', people. I bet you're thrilled.
After thinking about this for a whole minute, I remembered that I HATE FEEDBACK and I can't see this system working at all. Ever. Don't get me wrong, I think eBay's great; you can buy Kerry Katona's breast implants on there.
There is a whole slew of these public websites planned, and from this summer, you'll be able to leave comments about your GP and local NHS services. Um. I see the good intension behind this, but can you imagine what's going to happen if people use these online tools to describe medical practitioners in the same way they use them to describe internet shopping transactions? Readers, anarchy will happen, that's what!
Let me just furnish you with a recent example of genuine feedback from my own eBay profile. One happy seller has said of me: A+ buyer, prompt payment, great transaction. How nice of them! See, I may be a Bitch, but I pay my dues on time.
There is a whole slew of these public websites planned, and from this summer, you'll be able to leave comments about your GP and local NHS services. Um. I see the good intension behind this, but can you imagine what's going to happen if people use these online tools to describe medical practitioners in the same way they use them to describe internet shopping transactions? Readers, anarchy will happen, that's what!
Let me just furnish you with a recent example of genuine feedback from my own eBay profile. One happy seller has said of me: A+ buyer, prompt payment, great transaction. How nice of them! See, I may be a Bitch, but I pay my dues on time.
Now, let's translate that piece of feedback into something you might leave for your doctor: A+ medic, fantastic drugs, pleasant examination. Thx.
Don't forget that the seller, in this case your doctor, gets to leave feedback in response. I imagine mine would go something like: Five minutes late again. Used deodorant. Hypochondriac. Still spastic. Drool not so bad today. Hell, who needs medical records when you've got this information to hand!
And then there are the times when transactions go badly. In those cases, most online auction sites include a 'Report seller to website' option for when you've been ripped off. I'll be looking forward to being able to threaten my GP with the handy 'Report doctor to the GMC' button, then.
Don't forget that the seller, in this case your doctor, gets to leave feedback in response. I imagine mine would go something like: Five minutes late again. Used deodorant. Hypochondriac. Still spastic. Drool not so bad today. Hell, who needs medical records when you've got this information to hand!
And then there are the times when transactions go badly. In those cases, most online auction sites include a 'Report seller to website' option for when you've been ripped off. I'll be looking forward to being able to threaten my GP with the handy 'Report doctor to the GMC' button, then.
Meanwhile, if you switch over to a certain well known online bookshop, you will note that potential customers are given information on what other customers have done after viewing a particular item. Y'know, 60 per cent of customers bought this item, 10 per cent of them bought a different item, and 8 per cent purchased a different one again.
Translate this to medical services and who knows what we'll find out: "After visiting this doctor, 70 per cent of patients took aspirin, 15 per cent were prescribed Prozac, 5 per cent were referred for physiotherapy, 3 per cent of them dropped dead". It's not the kind of information I need to know, to be honest.
But, come on now, would you ever leave a bad comment about your GP or surgeon anyway? Criticise a waitress and she might gob in your food; God knows what might happen if you get on the wrong side of the person who looks after your health! I'd be far too scared. How useful it'll be remains to be seen.
I'm slightly concerned that Gordon Brown might get over-excited and expand the idea to social networking. Instead of adding friends to your personal profile, you will be able to add your GP, your orthopaedic consultant and your gynaecologist. Instead of being invited to events or to join groups, you'll be accepting referrals to chiropody, hydrotherapy and the NHS stop smoking service. It won't be long before you're able to play Scrabble with the lot of them. I'll be honest with you, readers, the main thing I'm left wondering is whether it's ethical to want to poke your consultant.
Translate this to medical services and who knows what we'll find out: "After visiting this doctor, 70 per cent of patients took aspirin, 15 per cent were prescribed Prozac, 5 per cent were referred for physiotherapy, 3 per cent of them dropped dead". It's not the kind of information I need to know, to be honest.
But, come on now, would you ever leave a bad comment about your GP or surgeon anyway? Criticise a waitress and she might gob in your food; God knows what might happen if you get on the wrong side of the person who looks after your health! I'd be far too scared. How useful it'll be remains to be seen.
I'm slightly concerned that Gordon Brown might get over-excited and expand the idea to social networking. Instead of adding friends to your personal profile, you will be able to add your GP, your orthopaedic consultant and your gynaecologist. Instead of being invited to events or to join groups, you'll be accepting referrals to chiropody, hydrotherapy and the NHS stop smoking service. It won't be long before you're able to play Scrabble with the lot of them. I'll be honest with you, readers, the main thing I'm left wondering is whether it's ethical to want to poke your consultant.
MillsWatch
Yet again, Heather is nowhere to be found in the tabloid press this week. I don't know what's going on, but I'm looking forward to her comeback. Have you seen Heather? Email me at the usual address or better yet, leave a comment below.
I imagine several medical professionals are among my cohort of 1,141 friends, but none of them have offered me virtual treatment yet. If you'd like to join my merry throng then get clicking, add me as a friend ... and enjoy my hilarious updates through the week until next Thursday's column back here on BBC Ouch!
More articles about
Bookmark with
Live community panel
Vote
Vote
Disabled people aren't political enough.
-
Agree
(65.1%) -
Disagree
(34.9%)
Total votes: 725
This is not a representative poll and the figures do not purport to represent public opinion as a whole on this issue
© MMIX~RS~q~RS~_bbc_=0&__ip__=38.107.191.81&dnainitialtitle=Disability%20Bitch%20vs%20clever%20internet%20stuff&dnahostpageurl=http://www.bbc.co.uk/ouch/opinion/b1tch/db_vs_clever_internet_stuf.shtml&dnauid=ouch:article:1973&s_baseHeadingLevel=1&dnashow=&dnafrom=0&dnato=9&dna_encoding=utf-8&s_sssicomponent=1&s_sssiCommentCount=&dnacommentforumlistprefix=[_]&dnarecentcommentsprefix=[_]&s_commentprofileurl=/dna/mbouch/CommentProfile?~RS~z~RS~13~RS~){kind=small}
Comments
Sign in or register to comment.
I do read online comments and reviews and find them very useful in helping me come to a decision - for things where I have a wide open choice, such as which mobile phone to buy. But for things like council services, where you're not choosing a provider and in many cases don't even have a choice about whether to use the service or not, what would be the point? Am I going to be able to decide not to pay my council tax because another user says they found the staff at the payments department "unhelpful"?
Complain about this comment
How about using the money for things which might actually be useful? You know, doctors, equipment, operation... I know it's a novel and rather radical approach.
Complain about this comment
Can I buy a new hip on Ebay?
Complain about this comment
Any feedback left for the ESA would be removed be the moderator due to the contents being declared obscene , immoral and impossible to do.A moderator would have to be emmployed as a lot of comments could not be published .
Complain about this comment
I look forward eagerly to the rate the govt one and the rate the PM one.. maybe if enough people make adverse and supportable comments ab out them we'll be rid...only prob i can see is.. would there be anyone better to take their places ?
Complain about this comment
of course we should be able to "poke " our consultants, after all they spend their lives poking us in many a painfull and/or embarassing places!
This seems crazy, and they already do random surveys about gp's anyway. My pharmacy is always asking people to fill in surveys about their service.
Complain about this comment
I want to be able to ask my doctors questions that are as impertinent and embarrassing as the ones they ask me. Want to know ho nerve damage affects one's sex life, doctor? Either go back to University or damage yourself, don't ask me.
Complain about this comment
View these comments in RSS