BBC HomeExplore the BBC
BBC Northern Ireland Education
KS3 Geography
Sustainable Development
goEcosystems Home goSite Map goGlossary goLinks
Tree Facts Forest Locations Forest Tour Build a Forest Belvoir Timeline
Transport or Trees? Decision Time



Transport or Trees?
Dr Irvine LaveryNorman TaylorGerry RiceValerie Smyth


Val Smyth is Regional Chairman of the Road Haulage Association which represents Freight Companies

Q. What impact do you think a super-route would have on Belvoir Forest

Listen to the audio versionA. First of all I would say that it shouldn't be a bus super-route. It should be for buses and Heavy Goods Vehicles. I think the impact could be minimalised by planners in the way that they would put together the planning for the super-route and in the way they develop it so they could actually enhance the area and try and protect it as much as possible.

Q. What is the effect of doing nothing?

Listen to the audio versionA. Firstly, if things are left the way they are, we are only going to get more congestion on the route into Belfast. More congestion means more exhaust fumes, more exhaust fumes means more damage to the environment and therefore we have to look at other ways of moving traffic. I believe that we should be looking at reducing traffic on the roads. I don't think we can reduce the number of lorries on the road. In the UK we have 422,000 lorries on the roads over 3.5 tonnes but over 23million cars. So the problem aren't the lorries, but the cars. We have to find ways of reducing the cars on the road. I also think that you have to look at it, for instance, one load of goods delivered to a supermarket, one 40 foot load of goods, it takes 500 cars to take away the goods that were delivered by that one 40 footer. So that puts it into perspective, the difference between a lorry and cars.

Q. What is your preference for the future of transport?

Listen to the audio versionA. First of all I would like to see the government invest more in roads. Instead of taking the 35billion from tax on vehicles, from cars and from petrol and diesel tax and using 85% of that in other areas, we should be investing more in our infrastructure. We should also be investing more in our public transport system to encourage car owners to leave their cars at home and use public transport. We need a good reasonable, reliable public transport system to encourage people to take their cars of the roads and free up the roads for essential transport.


GoBelvoir TimelineDecision TimeGo



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy