BBC HomeExplore the BBC

11 July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
On your behalf

BBC Homepage
Northern Ireland
Radio Ulster

»
ON YOUR BEHALF
GOODS & SERVICES
LEGAL & FINANCIAL
FAMILY LIFE
HEALTHCARE
BENEFITS
TRANSPORT & TRAVEL
TOO GOOD..?
FACTSHEETS
WEBLINKS
GET IN TOUCH

 

 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
You are in : GOODS AND SERVICES

COUNTERFEIT GOODS

How big a problem is counterfeiting?

According to the Global Anti-Counterfeiting Group (GACG), the scale of the problem is huge. GACG estimates that up to 12% of toys and sports goods in the market place are fakes along with 11% of clothing and footwear, and 10% of perfume and toiletries.

A recent GACG report shows that brand counterfeiting results in the direct loss last year of more than 17,000 jobs across Europe - 4,100 of them in the UK alone.

Counterfeiting also results in an annual reduction of the UK's Gross Domestic product of £768m - costing UK companies somewhere between £4 billion and £6.6 billion per year.

Worst hit are clothing and footwear companies - losing a combined £727m per year in the UK due to counterfeiting, with the toys and sports sector suffering to the tune of £358m - some 11.5% of their annual revenue.

The perfume and toiletries sector loses an estimated 7.2% of its annual revenue, or about £289m.

Yet buying or selling knock-off goods still hardly seems the most serious of crimes.

So what if it’s not genuine? Is the attitude of many if it looks like the real thing, and for only a fraction of the price.

If we’re honest, most of us have at one time or another, owned some sort of counterfeit product - be it that £20 Gucci bag, that £10 Rolex watch or even that £5 bottle of Chanel you bought off the street for Mother’s Day last year.

There seems no harm in bending the law a little, we reason. It’s essentially a victimless crime. A recent survey showed that 52% of us would willingly buy fake clothing and footwear and 16% were quite happy to knowingly purchase fake perfume.

Vice Chairman of the GACG John Anderson says:-

"We have to shake members of the public, as well as politicians and the judiciary, out of the mistaken belief that counterfeiting doesn’t hurt anybody.

"The economic impact is not just on brand owning companies, but also on national treasuries from which funds are drained that could otherwise help support health services and education.

"At the most personal level, 17,000 people across Europe who are prevented from legitimate work as a result of counterfeiting wouldn’t agree that it is a victimless crime."

Part of the problem may be the relatively light penalties for the counterfeiters - although breaching copyright can carry a jail sentence, simply selling counterfeit goods carries a maximum £5000 fine per item; it can seem a risk worth taking.

"We can reduce the amount of counterfeit or unsafe goods on sale but we can’t stop it unless tougher legislation is brought in," according to Enforcement Officers.

The real problem however comes from the public. As long as people are prepared to buy fakes - risking fires, computer damage, car crashes, burns and skin complaints from acid "perfumes" even blindness in the name of saving a few quid, then there will be those prepared to supply them.

THE PERILS OF COUNTERFEIT GOODS

  • Alcohol - fake vodka, scotch whiskey and alcopops - many carrying top brand names have been seized containing methylated spirits and antifreeze. Anyone drinking these could literally go blind.
  • Car parts - car wheels made of sub standard alloy and brake shoes made of compressed grass have been seized - both potentially lethal.
  • Christmas tree lights - badly wired fake plugs mean cheap sets of faairy lights are a fire hazard.
  • Toothbrushes - a large consignment of fake Aqua fresh toothbrushes have been seized, made of poor quality materials which threaten breakage and injury.
  • TVs and videos - bad wiring and old components mean that those that work at all are liable to cause fires or even explode.
  • Fake Tellytubby clothing has been seized which is not flameproof. A wearer would be engulfed in flames within seconds.
  • Fake Tetley tea bags have been seized containing metal filings, floor sweepings and rat and mouse droppings.
  • Washing powder - fake powder has been seized containing caustic soda which burned the hands.
  • Fake perfume - using urine as a stablisers has been found. The RUC confiscated 110 boxes at a raid at one popular market.
  • Screwdrivers - 1,500 fake Stanley screwdrivers which could shatter and blind or maim have been seized.
  • Health drink - a potentially lethal workout drink has been seized in Wales containing potentially dangerous levels of ephedrine.

HOW NOT TO GET CAUGHT OUT

  • examine the goods carefully, particularly looking for items which could become detached and choke or cut a child.
  • buy from recognised retailers, look for the BSI Kite and Lion quality marks and check the age group for which the toy is suitable.
  • everybody loves a bargain, but "cheap" can often mean fake. Shoddily made and possibly dangerous If it costs less than half the normal price, it could well be a fake.
  • be wary of goods sold at car boot sales, street markets, short term lease High Street shops, pubs or clubs.
  • examine stitching and seams inside garments and shoes and look carefully for poor quality seals between upper and lower soles on shoes.
  • poor quality labels and packaging on perfumes and cosmetics are often a give-away and some fake fragrances contain substances which can seriously damage the skin and eyes.
  • if suspicious about the credentials of a watch, handle the strap - fakes will feel lightweight and sound tinny when shaken. Logos and brand names are often poorly fixed to the dial of fake watches.

Remember you have no comeback if the appliance breaks

Top ten fakes to look out for...

  • sportswear, including football club strips
  • football and other computer games
  • designer label fleeces and other clothing
  • Pokemon and Tweenies toys and any character merchandise
  • perfume and cosmetics
  • music CD’s and cassettes
  • designer watches and luxury leather goods
  • films in both VHS and DVD format
  • champagne
  • computer software


RELATED LINKS

Commercial crime body

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.  

GET IN TOUCH
Is there a consumer issue you would like On Your Behalf to investigate? Email us here.
LISTEN
On The Web
Listen Live: Saturdays@9.30am

Listen to the Latest Programme


On The Radio
92.4 - 95.4 FM, 1341 MW

On Digital TV
Channel 0118 (Sky), 871 (Virgin) and 89 (Freeview)
You can also navigate the topics by using our comprehensive A-Z A B C D E F G H I J K L M
N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
 

 



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy