Why Kentucky might 'Ditch Mitch'

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell speaks with reporters following the weekly policy luncheon for Senate Democrats in Washington DC 8 April 2014

The latest battle in the Republican civil war is the campaign to get rid of one of the longest serving, most prominent conservatives in US politics.

I'm here at the Ronald Reagan Day Diner at Kentucky's Russell County middle school to find out why some want to "Ditch Mitch" - Mitch McConnell, the Republican leader in the Senate.

Amid the oval and rectangular tables, some draped with T-shirts and banners, a 16-year-old girl takes to the stage. As they tuck into the country buffet of chicken, ham, green beans and cornbread (no alcohol, this is a dry county) she intones:

"Yes, Mr Obama, there are two Americas - not the have and the have not's, but the wills and the won'ts".

The 300 or so Republicans here like the sentiment - President Barack Obama has built an army of the feckless with welfare cheques - and it is hard for honest, decent, hardworking folk to beat him at the ballot box.

It is what Mitt Romney said in the 2012 election with his remarks about 47% of Americans. That caused outrage on the left. It is the accepted wisdom here.

'Hungry to be heard'

The diatribe is just the warm-up act at the dinner. But this evening is not just about self-congratulation - the corridor is lined with Republicans fighting it out for the plum elected jobs in the state and in the local area.

In this county, a Republican is going to win every one of them - it is just a question of which Republican.

But the prize, which will be a real contest with the Democrats, is for Kentucky US senator. The first contest is again, an internal one.

But Mitch is missing - a factotum reads a letter of apology, and a video is played.

His Tea Party challenger Matt Bevin is very much present, shaking every hand. His pitch stresses his essential virtues - conservative, Christian, father, military veteran and entrepreneur.

US Senate candidate Matt Bevin, speaks to a gathering at FreePAC Kentucky in Louisville, Kentucky 5 April 2014 Tea Party challenger Matt Bevin hopes conservative dismay with Mitch McConnell will propel him to a Senate seat

"What people are hungry for is to be heard," he tells me.

"They do not feel represented by Mitch McConnell, or career politicians in general. He's been there too long - this is not Washington DC, this is Kentucky, this is where the real people live."

He says those he calls the "crusty curmudgeons of Congress" are too willing to do bad deals and Mr McConnell is among them.

"When one capitulates... in bad governance, that's not something to be applauded."

Start Quote

On the economic message we'd beat the pants off the Democrats, but when we begin to get into their bedrooms, their lives, their eyes glaze over”

End Quote Steve LaTourette Former Republican congressman

"People in America are fed up with the levels of debt - Mitch McConnell was the fellow who broke the back of any effort by conservatives to instill any sense of fiscal responsibility into our government.

"The people out here in Kentucky don't applaud that. We resent that."

Not everyone agrees. Even before I get into the dinner I am greeted by a large bearded gentleman who proffers a bumper sticker for "Team Mitch".

He says the 30-year senator is a pragmatic politician and doesn't think much of the Tea Party criticism.

"They've never been married."

I laugh and say I think I understand - but ask if he'd like to spell it out.

He says that a fellow who's married compromises every day. If he doesn't, he's not going to stay married. He'll end up with half his stuff and no wife. If he compromises, he can have all his stuff and a wife. That's the danger for the Republican party, he tells me.

The conventional wisdom is that most of Kentucky's Republicans will feel the same way and while Matt can shake all the hands he wants, he won't win.

There's a strong mood in Washington that after last year's shut down and gridlock, the Tea Party's day is done, the establishment are standing up to them and fighting back. That last part is certainly true.

Find out more

  • Mark's documentary, The Party of No, is on BBC Radio 4 at 20:00 BST (15:00 ET) on Tuesday, 29 April

But former Congressman Steve LaTourette worries that simply reflecting back the fury and frustration out here could lose the Republicans the chance of real power - and he's spearheading the fight back, working through the Main Street Partnership.

He says his party is at a crossroads - it must become more moderate and inclusive to have a chance of getting a Republican inside the White House in 2016.

"Our choice is we can become the permanent minority and never elect another president of the United States or we can pivot and resonate with the electorate," Mr LaTourette says.

"On the economic message we'd beat the pants off the Democrats, but when we begin to get into their bedrooms, their lives, their eyes glaze over. They think 'all the Dems can to do is take money out of my wallet, you want to control my life'."

As a former congressman he will know the electorate, but one of the reason I wanted to come here, is that I think many Washington-based commenters are missing something.

They tend to dismiss vocal Tea Party politicians as extremists - when they just reflect what a slice of the population take as axiomatic.

Flea market woes

That's why I do a swift U-turn and head off the highway when I spot a big sign saying "The most awesome flea market in the world".

One stall holder, gun holstered at his hip, pulls up his jeans to show me a war-wound from Iraq. Out of the Army, he's now selling knick-knacks from butter knives to old bottles. One of the few things not on offer here is sympathy for the senator.

"Mitch? Get rid of him! I don't like him and I don't like what he stands for," he says, so I ask him what Mitch stands for.

"Nothing." What do you stand for? "Freedom".

Mitch McConnell said in December 2012 Republicans would not "write a blank cheque" to Democrats to avert the fiscal cliff

He goes on to say he fought for his country but Mr McConnell hasn't fought for Kentucky. He claims there's too much immigration and "the country is billions in debt because of it".

"China pretty much owns us now - well it's true, everything here pretty much is made in China," he says, sweeping his hand across the stall. It's true - the rows of leather belts with big Western buckles are all made in China.

At a gun stall, I tell the owner that as a Brit it is still weird to see guns on sale so casually.

"I feel sorry for you," he says, adding guns are the guarantee of freedom. He despairs of "what is happening to America".

And he does blame Mitch McConnell for compromising. "Mitch is a dinosaur. We need somebody saying 'No, we are not doing a deal.'"

A customer joins in saying that he has just about given up - Americans will soon be living in grass huts, competing with slave labour.

The customer gets half what he used to earn, but at least he still gets up to work, he says, unlike many people: "The American dream nowadays is 'Sit on your ass and do nothing.'"

No-one I talk to disagrees with these sort of sentiments. As I walk back to the car park, I reflect that these are the complaints I hear again and again, immigration and guns, welfare cheats and China.

Some of it is true. The impact of globalisation on manufacturing jobs, for instance. Some of it, like the emphasis on the impact of welfare on debt, is far more contestable. Much of what is called "entitlements" here is made up of public pensions and healthcare for the retired.

But in some ways it is the perception that matters. Out here, few would question the sort of statements and values that get the Tea Party mocked in what the right loves to call "the lamestream media".

It worries Steve LaTourette.

"We can count on the votes of 57-year-old angry white men who live below the Mason-Dixon line. We'll probably get 80% of them."

Tea Party backers in Washington (13 October 2013) Republicans may be pushing back but the mood that inspired the Tea Party is not going away

But he says they are not getting the votes of African-Americans, Hispanics and women.

"When some of these candidates start talking about how precious life is when a woman has been raped, that really doesn't help our cause."

The Kentucky establishment is confident Mitch McConnell will win. It is more than possible that even if the people I spoke to at the flea market are registered Republicans, they may not bother to vote in a primary election.

But if the day of large Tea Party meetings and vocal protests outside the US Capitol are past, the mood it represents is far from over.

On Tuesday, I'll be in Texas looking at the Tea Party, immigration and life on the range.

Listen to Mark's radio documentary: The Party of 'No'on Radio Four at 20:00 BST (15:00 ET) on 29 April.

Mark Mardell Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell North America editor

Is Obama right over Iraq?

The Obama doctrine says the US will only go to war if its vital interests or those of its allies are threatened, so what does that mean for Iraq?

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 54.

    McConnell has been obstructive, self absorbed and a truly worthless leader of the Senate opposition - Senate leader actually as that wimp Reid let him filibuster everything Obama tried to get passed in the Senate - gridlock = a total waste of the taxpayer's time and effort electing this useless body of multimillionaires!

  • rate this

    Comment number 53.

    OMG I never thought that there were right wingers out there that make Mitch McConnell look like a liberal. Just too reasonable and practical minded for the tea baggers?

    Looks like we are in for some really strange politics this season.

  • rate this

    Comment number 52.

    The Tea Party and Republican mainstream are still feuding, so the formerly indistinguishable voterbases are pulling apart. Largely, this is the Tea Party refusing to negotiate. The Democratic party is profiting from the general rancor. I generally vote Dem, but I would prefer real contests so we get politicians who can govern from the middle, not just play fringe politic, so the TP need not apply.

  • rate this

    Comment number 51.

    This thread is down to 5 posts and no history and Kirin back to double posting, again!

  • rate this

    Comment number 50.

    Mardell and pretty much all journalists refuse to but are astro turf. Made main stream by a massive PR campaign via organizations like Freedom Works and Americans for Prosperity and then given legitimacy by the news media giving voice to these ideas when they were on the fringes. The reality is Americans are fed up with oligarchy but don't know it as such. Oligarchs capitalize on this.

  • rate this

    Comment number 49.

    ref #42

    there is far more racism and intolerance on Chris's left. If you watched Fox or read a non extreme paper, both men were roundly condemned.

    Not lets compare Al sharpeton who is far worse than either man or members of CAIR or left wing professors.Where is the call from the left for NBC to fire Al or force the American Studies association board to resign from colleges

  • rate this

    Comment number 48.

    ref #42

    there is far more racism and intolerance on Chris's left. If you watched Fox or read a non extreme paper, both men were roundly condemned.

    Not lets compare Al sharpeton who is far worse than either man or member of CAIR or left wing professors.Where is the call from theleft for NBC to fire Al or force the Amaerican Studies association embers to resign from colleges

  • rate this

    Comment number 47.

    44. Good luck fighting off the US Govt with your switchblade when they come for you.

    And if you believe they are "the biggest threat there is
    to my families health safety and welfare." then why join up to fight for them?

  • rate this

    Comment number 46.

    45 Chris A

    If 44 thinks the US government is his biggest threat then he should emigrate. Though likely no one would have him. I have neighbors like this guy. They nice enough until you their delusions get the better of them and then, well, it's just paranoid schizophrenia after that. It's not rational and fact has nothing to do with it

  • rate this

    Comment number 45.

    44. You have been drinking too much NRA 'freedom' Kool-Aid - just how does your being armed protect you from your perceived biggest threat - the US Government? When they come for you they will have 'cause' and 'statute' and your pea shooter will not be up to the task of keeping you from arrest, or execution on the spot!

    Foreign Gov'ts don't figure, period!

  • rate this

    Comment number 44.

    You have some interesting but very wrong ideas about Americans.
    I carried a switch blade knife from age 8.
    Gun from age 18. I'm a Vet.
    You have to understand we protect ourselves.
    My American Government is biggest threat there is
    to my families health safety and welfare.
    Foreign Governments are #2.

  • rate this

    Comment number 43.

    42. MK uses anti-Semitism for any mention of Israel, period. The blunt racism of the rabid right: Bundy and Sterling this month, is given a pass of course as Obama is despised.

    McConnell stated from day 1. that the voter's choice of Obama was wrong and anything he did was to be obstructed. Pulled all the stops (filibusters) to ensure Obama was a one term president - voters disagreed, again.

  • rate this

    Comment number 42.

    So MagicK (40), by your logic, then the GOP, who most people regard as promoting racism, do not have any validity either? Why is it that you are so affronted by anti-semitism, yet seem to show indifference to the regular racism displayed by members and supporters of your party here in the US? Surely as a "victim" of prejudice, you would feel empathy with other victims of prejudice and persecution?

  • rate this

    Comment number 41.

    40. Dream on.

  • rate this

    Comment number 40.

    ref #39

    since Wiki promotes anti-semtism they have no validity. And yes anyone who equates Israel the most progressive nation in that part of the world is an anti-semite even if his name is Tutu. Jews are the most persecuted int he world. No one would take the lies of the Palerstinains seriously if Israel was another arab country

    They are the spirtual sucessors of the Nazis as is Wiki

  • rate this

    Comment number 39.

    As expected, anti Semitism hurled, as always (best you can do?) - read the Wiki for the facts. And to counter, Israelis have no historical claim whatsoever on Jerusalem (an Islamic center) or the territory, a Bedouin roaming territory. (Bedouins' did not do land registration - Israelis did starting in the 1870's.) Pre-1870 there were less that 10,000 Jews in the whole territory.

  • rate this

    Comment number 38.

    ref #37

    That is the usual drivel from anti-semtite racist and wikipedia spouts Jew hate on a regular basis. There is more racism into today's South African and Tutu is one of the leading ones

    Christians and moslems have equal rights in Israel unlike the rest of the Middle East. The Palestinians have no claim to Jeruslalem

  • rate this

    Comment number 37.

    34. Israel is a de facto apartheid state: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_and_the_apartheid_analogy The Israeli pull out from Gaza was all about voting rights and ethnic cleansing. The East Jerusalem and West Bank settlement expansion is again about ethnic cleansing (look at the Palestinian land shrinkage since 1967). Israel is on track to have the Palestinians pushed out of 'Israel' by 2050!

  • rate this

    Comment number 36.

    35. 'Keep saying it until it is so' was very effective for Bush Jr.
    34. You wish on miscreant, McConnell; Sterling a classic racist - since Obama was elected the US looks and sounds like it did in the 60's; the IRS canard again - tea party folks actually reported themselves as charities and tax exempt, good grief. As if it was not bad enough that the churches pushed Bush Jr from the pulpits!

  • rate this

    Comment number 35.

    LucyJ is one of those all to common people who just make stuff up, or let Fox News or a conspiracy web site do it for them. Then if they believe it hard enough, repeat it often enough, and are angry enough they are right. It helps if they gather in large groups and wear silly costumes. The political equivalent of trekkies or steam punkers.


Page 1 of 3



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.