America's immigration conundrum

The Italian Street Market, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Stallholders at the Ninth Street market

Juan Carlos Romero, a fresh-faced man from Mexico, sets out flowers in aluminium buckets in front of his shop in south Philadelphia's Ninth Street market.

They are a bright splash of colour on what starts as a rather grey day.

Latino music blasts from a clothes shop on the other side of the road. Pineapples and chillies, fresh fish and spicy sausages are on display.

The street is a buzzy, gritty sort of place. Originally home to the Italian Market, it is as much a product of South and Central America as of old Europe.

Everyone seems to know everyone else, it is an antidote to all those depressingly anonymous malls littering every US state.

Start Quote

What is different now is the huge growth in the Latino population far away from the border”

End Quote

The cliche that springs to mind is "tight-knit", but the weave is made up of citizens and illegal immigrants and there are tensions in the fabric between old and new.

The flower man, Mr Romero, has a wife and little daughter. He works hard - sometimes 14 hours a day, he tells me - running both the florist and a restaurant he owns. He has been in the US for 10 years now, an illegal immigrant, without papers.

"I feel insecure, impotent. I feel like I am extraneous. It is a very bad sensation," Mr Romero says.

He is looking to Washington to change that - and now immigration reform has a real chance because of the support of some Republicans.

"I hear the Republican from Florida [Marco Rubio] and he says things that are good news, but the others sound very hard," he says.

The US city of Baltimore is actively inviting immigrants

"Some of them don't trust us - it's very sad. They have a big country, I hope the Republicans and Democrats make a good reform to help us.

"They say there are 11 million undocumented workers. I don't know, maybe it is more. But we need reform to help us live in this very nice country."

Immigration reform is the hottest issue on Capitol Hill right now.

Central is the idea of amnesty - allowing the millions of illegal immigrants to eventually become American citizens.

Many Republicans instinctively recoil from the idea, seeing it as a reward for people who have broken the law.

But it is a huge test for the party after their defeat in the last election.

It was an election where President Barack Obama took 71% of the Latino vote. Some think it tipped the balance here in Pennsylvania and other key states.

Latinos for Obama rally in 2008 Courting the Latino vote in 2008 too

At first sight, it may seem a puzzle how the treatment of people who are not US citizens, who cannot vote, might influence the outcome of elections.

Jorge Salazar, of the Pennsylvania Immigration and Citizenship Coalition, explains it well.

He was brought to this country from Bolivia by his parents when he was seven. They came on a visa, but stayed on when it ran out.

He is now 30 and still has no papers. He talks about the constant threat of deportation as if it was a war.

"Family members can disappear overnight," he says. "I lost my aunt - she was deported 2001. Her kids are citizens, and they've never been the same."

Beyond outdated stereotypes of Latinos in the US

He say all parties have to get serious about changes.

"Republicans have a hard time with the Latino community because of their immigration attitude," Mr Salazar says.

"They are becoming aware the Latino community is very strong. Everybody who is here undocumented has someone who can vote.

"I am undocumented but my sister is documented so she can cast a vote for me. All my cousins, all my uncles - everybody apart from my small nuclear family - have the right to vote.

"They will exercise that right to help me out - a lot of Latinos know what's at stake. We have shown that in the last election and that is why Republicans have started to have dialogue about this."

He is going to the Pennsylvania state capital to talk about this with one Republican who is eager to help and wants to change his party's image with Latinos.

'Living the dream'

The elegant state capital, Harrisburg, is very different to the bustle of Philadelphia.

View of the Capitol building The State Capitol in Harrisburg

State Street is dominated by two buildings. One is St Patrick's Cathedral, built with German marble and the money of Irish immigrants. The other is the Capitol itself.

Inside, under the magnificent classical dome, State Senator Lloyd Smucker is meeting Mr Salazar and other children of illegal immigrants to discuss his new bill.

The proposal would make it cheaper and easier for people like them to go to university in Pennsylvania.

Sen Smucker is insistent this is about principle not politics: "These students came here through no choice of their own. This is their home.

"They are here to stay. They have a wonderful ability to contribute - we ought to give them the opportunity to do so," he says.

I believe Sen Smucker that for him this is not about harvesting votes, but he readily agrees that his party needs to change its image with Latinos.

Start Quote

America is an immigration country - that's us, too”

End Quote Ahslie Rosas Mexican immigrant

"I do think so," Sen Smucker says. "We've had our own share of proposals from the Republican side here that I didn't agree with in the past.

"I think we do need to think about these things differently. The mood is shifting and I am glad to see it."

The immigration bill up in Washington DC is not his fight, but it is clear which side he is on.

"I think the immigration system is broken so I am glad to see debate about that," Sen Smucker adds.

"We should embrace diversity. My own personal view is that many people do still see America as a land of opportunity and we should welcome people who want to come here and live the American dream."

The whole idea behind the senator's bill is to make it easier and more comfortable for some illegal immigrants to stay in the US.

Man walking back streets in Hazleton A coal mining town, Hazleton's fortunes have fallen

I travelled on to Hazleton, one of those broken, old industrial towns of Pennsylvania. The message here is: "go home".

It seems a beaten-down place, struggling to keep its head above water after waves of economic bad news. But some seem to like the place.

In front of shops offering tax advice in Spanish, there is a bright yellow van, a Hazelton address on its side, promising door-to-door delivery from the Dominican Republic.

The Latino population has increased rapidly in recent years.

Way before the state of Arizona came up with stringent laws to encourage "self-deportation", the mayor here pushed for tough new laws punishing anyone who gave an illegal immigrant a job.

The law is now being fought over in the courts. But Lou Barletta is convinced he was right. Hazleton's former mayor is now a congressman in Washington DC and he will fight the new immigration bill all the way.

He says: "I don't think we should be talking about any pathway to citizenship or amnesty.

"At home you wouldn't talk about replacing your carpet if you still had a hole in your roof. On a ship that was taking on water, you would plug the holes first.

"We should be talking about one thing first and one thing only: securing our borders. Until we do that we are only going to make our problem worse."

The congressman says the only reasons Republicans are talking about this are political - and voters hate that. He adds that amnesty has always failed.

"We are only going to make the problem worse like we did in 1986 under Ronald Regan when 1.5 million people were going to be given amnesty," Mr Barletta adds.

Undocumented Latino immigrants look for love

"As soon as that declaration was made, that number quickly grew to three million people and here we are talking about it again and our borders still aren't secure.

"The 11 million that are here illegally now could double or even triple if we continue promising people they could have American citizenship."

Mr Barletta tells me at length about the problems illegal immigration caused his town - he talks about shootings and murders and drug deals.

He talks about illegal immigrants crowding into the local hospital for everything from "hang nails to heart attacks, putting strain on the fire service and the schools".

But he maintains he is pro-immigration. He says the presence of illegal workers hurts those who have come here legally more than anyone else, forcing down wages and damaging the quality of life.

Mr Barletta says his party has got it wrong.

"In a city that is 47% Latino, you would think I would be a poster child for the Latino community to go after," he adds. "I won my third term for mayor with over 90% of the vote.

"Why would the people who know me the best, those that were the closest, while I was proposing these ordinances - why would the Latino population grow every single year since the ordinance?

"I am probably the strongest voice for the Latinos in America because I want them to earn more money, so they can give their children a better life."

This debate is about the direction of a party.

Undocumented immigrants on Alabama's immigration law

But it is also about the continuing conundrum of America's attitude to immigration. On Ninth Street, not all the descendants of Italian immigrants welcomed people from different lands, be they legal or illegal.

There is a question about who should share in the American dream, and when the drawbridge should be pulled up.

I asked one of those meeting with the state senator why she felt she should be allowed to stay when she came here illegally.

At first 17-year-old Ahslie Rosas, who came from Mexico with her family five years ago, disputed the premise - they had come here legally but stayed when her father's visa ran out. But her final answer was eloquent.

"We might be breaking the law but we are seeking a better future," she says.

"America is an immigration country. Americans came from Europe to this land. That's us, too. "

Mark Mardell Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell Presenter, The World This Weekend

Could Greece prompt wholesale change in Europe?

The triumph of Syriza in Greece could lead to renewed tensions - and widespread political change - across Europe, says Mark Mardell.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 135.

    134 If we didn't have a society of exclusivity to its own citizens and those legally invited to come we wouldn't have had an America that invented the modern world, made it work and advanced to the benefit of all others. If we don't maintain that exclusivity then America will be just like every other country, unexceptional mediocrity will be the best we will do. Sellout today condemns the future.

  • rate this

    Comment number 134.

    sieuarlu @132
    Where to start?

    You tap an infinity of inter-related problems, soluble ONLY by address of underlying cause, profound democratic deficit, of which most or too many are in extreme denial

    Sadly for libertarians, & for those who fall under their spell, 'we' cannot expect the fruits of democracy - freedom to live in conscience - without secure equality of means: votes & personal income

  • rate this

    Comment number 133.

    121I've heard this tale more than once.By granting illegal aliens the right to stay and an assured path to citizenship we discourage people who try to comply with out laws.Expediency in the face of a problem that's been unaddressed for decades is an intolerable corruption of the underpinnings of our society.Republicans will sell us out as surely as Democrats did.They're scoundrels not patriots.

  • rate this

    Comment number 132.

    131 Democracy exists in America only for American citizens.We are NOT equal partners with others.We are us, they are them.All are not happy, all are not working and illegal aliens are stealing jobs from Americans and forcing wages down.Benefits to US society are bogus.A few prosper but taxpayers suffer impact.And we are still a nation of laws illegal aliens broke.They're criminals for being here.

  • rate this

    Comment number 131.

    sieuralu @128

    Or seeing the misleading: 'economics' of playground, 'winner takes all'; school-kid scramble for summer pocket-money, @129; acceptance of inherited surrender, to rule of fear & greed

    Maybe an equal partnership democracy will have a few rough edgers, and never manage a tidy goose-step. But IF all ARE 'happy to work as able', what could go so 'economically' wrong?

  • rate this

    Comment number 130.

    'gangsters are hiding- among poor Latino'
    You mean low-level 'gangsters'?

    My reference to those who 'without visible means of support', or with 'cover' of a small estate (their 'personal reward' for managing a farm, or factory, or inheritance, or lottery win), CAN present as 'legitimate rich customers' for tools of trade: and to those higher, 'in a mansion near you', buying & selling...

  • rate this

    Comment number 129.

    If people can't find work, they should put on their boots and goggles and yank that expletive lawn-mower, weed-wacker or leaf-blower out of the guy's hands. That's what I would do.

  • rate this

    Comment number 128.

    120"immigrants can BOOST the GDP to be shared
    Given work"

    Complete misunderstanding of economics.Much of what illegal aliens earn is sent to their home country as remittances to feed their families.The cost to society in other ways can far outweigh the benefits of cost cutting for employers.
    116"A small to moderate amount America can easily absorb"
    There's no justification to absorbing any.

  • rate this

    Comment number 127.

    "Did you really miss my meaning, that gangsters find 'good cover' amongst US rich?"

    Mexican gangsters/narcotraficantes are hiding mostly among the poor Latino immigrants in Us southern states. And do most of their killings there.

    Have you ever been there? Obviously not.

  • rate this

    Comment number 126.

    pmk @123
    Is it really addition of an extra "One", to "11 million", that worries you?

    Worrying about immigration, knowing that 'our system' never fails to keep at least 3% in 'structural' unemployment ('between jobs'), and next-door in Mexico a fine example of US-led employment culture, tough luck on families?

    Did you really miss my meaning, that gangsters find 'good cover' amongst US rich?

  • rate this

    Comment number 125.

    nobody look in case they think they are under surveillance and run away.

  • rate this

    Comment number 124.

    pmk @123

    Sympathy for any in the 99-100% stuck long without a job or, perhaps worse, stuck in a job they dare not give up despite net-dis-benefit to family, BUT we are talkig abut the land of OPPORTUNITY, perhaps not meant, but effectively of 'strong trample weak', 'winner takes all', & 'trash thy neighbour'. BOUND to attract kindred spirits along with the desperate. Deal with the CAUSE, or fail

  • rate this

    Comment number 123.

    "in a land of 1% super-rich, who notices an extra 'One'?"

    99% looking for jobs notice ca 11 milion of illegal aliens illegally
    employed. Bringin in, succesfully, their wives, sisters, brothers ,cousins, etc. Hoping for another amnesty.

    Do you really don't understand a difference between LEGAL immigration controlled by the state and an ILlegal one?

  • rate this

    Comment number 122.

    paul @119
    'US needs to secure porous border'

    However much steel, however many guards, however rigorous the system, always corruption: some cases 'noble', many frankly criminal. 'Always', because the rewards of crime are far higher than of 'an honest day' looking for work (on benefit), or working (even for 'above average' pay); AND, in a land of 1% super-rich, who notices an extra 'One'?

    As @101

  • rate this

    Comment number 121.

    I came from England to the US legally. I did the whole admin from England and it took years and was incredibly stressful and costly. I had to meet my US wife for occasional weekends in Toronto, Canada during that time. After more years I became a citizen. Now these jokers are just going to climb the fence and get everything I have fought for legally - and handed to them on a plate ! Disgusting.

  • rate this

    Comment number 120.

    "Pandora's Box"
    Noting sieuarlu @111 'hopeless poverty..I'd probably do the same'

    marieinaust@112, missing FORCE of situational/moral complexity AND Hispanic vote AND retreat of WASP to TP ghetto

    "Can America afford this to happen?" Happening, ill-afforded or not

    Of equal partnership, "can the US afford it?"
    Like 'unemployed', immigrants can BOOST the GDP to be shared
    Given work

  • rate this

    Comment number 119.

    The US needs to secure it's borders, the current changes to the immigration bill are good- but depend on people being documented- and they are not- with a porus border- unknown number of illegals the bill itseslf does not bring anything but more hardship to the US.

    oh an did anyone notice that there is no education or salary level to immigrate in the new bill- compare that to other countries?

  • rate this

    Comment number 118.

    "Your genuine equal sounds like take more from the working people and give it to the non-working people"@101

    Why assume / suggest 'schoolboy inflammatory', as if good boys about to be robbed of 'tuck' to buy favour with bad?

    We move in & out of 'the working people', havoc for domestic & national economics, not to mention mental health & international relations-of-fear

    FULL employment key

  • rate this

    Comment number 117.

    Not only did US Govt allow American companies to EXPORT their capital & technology abroad, but its immigration policy of letting in poorly trained and/or low wage foreign immigrants also has had the effect of keeping down the wages of LOW-SKILLED American workers.
    Who benefits from this cheap labor?

  • rate this

    Comment number 116.

    Probably the biggest thing about the illegal immigration is the fact that there is simply so many of them

    A small to moderate amount America can easily absorb

    But when you are talking millions upon millions
    along w/ an unsecured border which offers limitless illegal immigration
    it is incredibly overwhelming

    If the amnesty bill is passed
    illegal immigration will be neverending


Page 2 of 8



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.