First US presidential debate: Obama v Romney

Key Points

  • President Barack Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney clash on the economy in the first of three presidential debates
  • The rivals addressed domestic policy in their first face-to-face meeting of the campaign, 34 days before the election
  • The 90-minute debate also focused on healthcare, the deficit and government's role. All times MDT (GMT -6)

Join the discussion

Comment here

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published.
Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.

Terms and conditions

  1.  
    1757:

    Welcome to BBC's live page of the first presidential debate between President Barack Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney. We'll bring you all the insights from our correspondents at the event in Denver, as well as a selection of your e-mails and tweets.

     
  2.  
    1809:

    The head-to-head begins at 19:00 local time (02:00 BST) and runs uninterrupted for 90 minutes, focusing on domestic policy, including the economy and healthcare. It is the first of three presidential debates and a vice-presidential one before the election on 6 November.

     
  3.  
    1810:

    If the US presidential campaign and the candidates are relatively new to you, here's a quick look at where each stands on the key issues - and our full election coverage.

     
  4.  
    1817:

    And here's our candidates...

    Zach Gonzales and Dia Mohamed stand in for the candidates

    No, you haven't been transported to an alternate reality: two University of Denver students - Zach Gonzales (left) and Dia Mohamed - stood in earlier for the former Massachusetts governor and current US president during a rehearsal and camera test.

     
  5.  
    1828:

    Recent polling suggests Obama has maintained a slight lead nationally as well as in several key election states (our poll tracker has the big picture). A crash-and-burn by either candidate tonight could really hurt his approval rating.

     
  6.  
    1838:

    Pundits say Obama must ensure he doesn't damage his buoyant likeability ratings, while bringing the attack to Romney. The New York Times has reported that aides are encouraging Obama to use humour and his wide smile, and to avoid coming across as smug.

     
  7.  
    1843:

    Romney has reportedly been equipped with an arsenal of "zingers" - the one-line put-downs that leave spin-doctors drooling and YouTube creaking.

     
  8.  
    1843: Adam Blenford BBC News, Denver

    With 15 minutes to go, the audience have taken their seats and are being given a stern warning about keeping their phones off and refraining from cheering and applause throughout the debate.

     
  9.  
    Aide to Mitt Romney, D.G. Jackson

    tweets: Backstage with family playing jenga. pic.twitter.com/tDXeJHmT

     
  10.  
    US vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan

    tweets: In tonight's debate, we will see a clear choice between broken promises and bold leadership. @MittRomney is the right man to lead.

     
  11.  
    1847:

    But do presidential debates matter? BBC North America editor Mark Mardell says that while these clashes may not change minds, they do make for better informed voters.

     
  12.  
    1850:

    The moderator for this evening, Jim Lehrer, has run a presidential debate 12 times in his career. His day job is executive editor of PBS Newshour, a nightly US news programme. A former CNN anchor called Lehrer the "dean of moderators", but others suggest his style is too gloves-on.

     
  13.  
    1853:

    The New York Times previews the debate through numbers or statistics likely to be used to buttress arguments or provide rhetorical flourish this evening.

     
  14.  
    US Vice-President Joe Biden

    tweets: To Barack: Good luck tonight, and happy anniversary to you and Michelle. -Joe and Jill

     
  15.  
    1854:

    The format for tonight's debate is designed to get a bit more discussion going - the 90 minutes will be split into six 15-minute segements, each themed around a policy issue.

     
  16.  
    New York Times White House correspondent, Mark Landler

    tweets: Romney campaign won the battle of the crowds outside, as the president's motorcade arrived. A sea of Romney-Ryan signs. Fewer Obama signs.

     
  17.  
    1857:

    The two men have rarely met in person in the past few years - and according to Politico, Obama is no admirer of Romney, regarding the former governor as "a political shape-shifter".

     
  18.  
    1857: Adam Blenford BBC News, Denver

    Jim Lehrer's final request for silence before the debate is being immaculately observed - in the media room as well as in the debate hall itself.

     
  19.  
    BBC's Glenn Anderson

    tweets: Heard in the #debates press room: "Are we seriously just going to wait for them in silence?"

     
  20.  
    1904:

    And the two big beasts of the American political jungle stride on stage, all smiles. Obama claps Romney on the arm. Mr Obama in a blue tie - Mr Romney in red. They make quick waves to the audience and arrive back at the podium.

     
  21.  
    1905:

    The first question is - unsurprisingly - about jobs.

     
  22.  
    1907:

    Romney cracks a joke, saying it is very romantic that Obama is spending his wedding anniversary on stage with the Republican. Obama laughs.

     
  23.  
    1911:

    Looking his rival in the eye, Mitt Romney denies Obama's claim that he has a plan to cut taxes, says middle-income Americans have been "buried" and "crushed".

     
  24.  
    1912:

    Romney says he wants "tax relief" - arguing that Obama's policies have hit the poor the worst.

     
  25.  
    1913:

    Expressive with his hands, Romney says he likes coal and wants to bring in a disputed oil pipeline from Canada (the Keystone XL project has been a bone of contention during Obama's first term). Says Obama's characterisation of Romney's policies are "simply not accurate".

     
  26.  
    1917:

    Back to taxes - Obama repeats his line that Romney will bring in a $5.4 trillion tax cut and says Romney hasn't been clear about what the loopholes in the tax system he would close. Romney is now fighting back firmly against Obama's claims.

     
  27.  
    Mark Mardell BBC North America editor

    tweets: #debates Romney says middle class has been buried - echoing Biden's words

     
  28.  
    1918:

    Obama is shaking his head at Romney's claim that six studies have contradicted the president's characterisation of the Republican's economic plan. "For me this is about getting jobs for the American people," emphasises Romney.

     
  29.  
    1922:

    Romney adopts a respectful tone, referring to Obama as "Mr President".

     
  30.  
    1923:

    Obama says that Romney's tax plan is "mad". "Math, common sense and our history shows that's not a recipe for job growth". Says it's the same Republican sales pitch that led to the Great Depression.

     
  31.  

    The BBC's Helena Merriman, at a debate-watching party, tweets: "Romney citing various studies - dems here at watch party saying "what's the name of those studies?" #debates"

     
  32.  
    1925:

    Social media website Tumblr is live giffing during the presidential debate. If you want to know what this is all about, click here to see what is being created.

     
  33.  
    1926:

    Romney ends the first segment by again emphatically denying that he is planning a $5 trillion tax cut.

     
  34.  
    BBC's Glenn Anderson

    tweets: #Romney's mic is cutting out in the press room. Lots of "What?" going on here #debates

     
  35.  
    1928:

    A light moment, as Romney refers to the president's signature healthcare reform as "Obamacare", adds that he uses that term "with all due respect". Obama says: "I like it."

     
  36.  
    1929:

    Romney spells out his test for dropping government programmes: "Is it so essential that we need to borrow from China to pay for it?"

     
  37.  
    NPR's White House correspondent, Ari Shapiro

    tweets: Romney keeps telling individual stories of Americans in trouble. Obama hasn't gone there yet.

     
  38.  
    1932:

    Obama cites Romney as saying during the Republican primaries that he would not exchange $10 of government cuts for $1 of tax revenue, calls that an "unbalanced approach".

     
  39.  
    1934:

    Romney hits Obama hard on the economy, saying he's had four years to fix it. Obama says Romney has ruled out extra tax revenue. Romney interrupts and says "absolutely", before going on to riff about how tax increases harm the economy.

     
  40.  
    Sam Wetmore in Oxfordshire, UK

    emails: "Romney has started strongly, although he has an advantage of being able to attack Obama's record while being able to be "agile" in defence against Obamas attacks. If this was boxing, looks like Romney may have the first round - he seems a lot more personable."

     
  41.  
    1936:

    Romney cites Spain's percentage of government spending - and brings up the spectre of that country's economy: "We don't want to become Spain."

     
  42.  
    1936:

    A fact-check from NYT: "It's not true that Obama added as much to the federal debt as all the prior presidents combined."

     
  43.  
    Sid Lodi in California

    emails: "Romney is not at all qualified for the leadership of this great country. Obama is not only qualified to run this office, he has saved America from the worst financial calamity this country has ever faced."

     
  44.  
    1937:

    Obama attacks "corporate welfare" - saying Exxon Mobil doesn't need tax breaks - and neither do the owners of private jets.

     
  45.  
    Washington bureau chief for The New York Times, David Leonhardt

    tweets: I feel like the conservatives in my feed are unhappy with Romney's performance and the liberals are unhappy with Obama's.

     
  46.  
    1939:

    Former private equity chief Romney brings up what his campaign sees as his unique selling point as he takes a swipe at Obama: "I've been in business for 25 years - I have no idea what you're talking about."

     
  47.  
    1940: Jonny Dymond BBC News, Washington

    Obama looks tired, fails to tell a story, has no spark, gathers a bunch of points together and spools them out. So far, a dismal performance. A car crash. Fortunate for Dems that very few debates change campaigns in any way.

     
  48.  
    1941:

    Mitt Romney attacks Obama's policies on green energy, mentioning Solyndra, a high-profile solar firm that failed after receiving major government subsidies.

     
  49.  
    1946:

    Romney and Obama may look like long-lost buddies in this picture, but they're not.

    Romney and Obama
     
  50.  
    Laura Wales in Manchester, UK

    emails: "I don't understand why Obama and the Democrats aren't going back to Romney every time he talks about being in business for 25 years and point out that he left those businesses massively in debt, while taking multi-million dollar fees for sorting out the debt mess he himself created. Fiscally and economically irresponsible doesn't even begin to cover it. And us Brits think we have it bad."

     
  51.  
    1948:

    Obama says that if you repeal Obamacare (he's owning the name now) seniors will lose out and insurance companies will gain.

     
  52.  

    What's up with the black dot on Romney's flag pin? The Associated Press tweets: "Romney's lapel pin has the Secret Service logo - a star - on it. The Secret Service agents who protect him gave it to him. #Election2012"

     
  53.  
    BBC World Service Newshour presenter, Razia Iqbal

    I'm in Charleston, South Carolina - a solidly Republican state, at a Republican watch party. There are 200 people in a cinema heckling President Obama and cheering Mitt Romney, calling out "liar" when Obama talked about energy. When Obama talks about his family story the audience say: "Wake me up when you're done".

     
  54.  
    1958:

    Obama makes a case for regulation of Wall Street - asking ironically if anybody thinks the cause of the 2008 financial crisis was too much red tape.

     
  55.  
    2000:

    Romney hits Obama's healthcare law hard - bad for small business, too much time spent on the law during his first two years - and not enough on jobs.

     
  56.  
    2001:

    Obama cuts off the moderator as points out his two minutes are up, saying: "I had five seconds before you interrupted me". Softens the sharp comeback with a smile.

     
  57.  
    2003:

    Obama says its more than businesses affected by his healthcare law - argues it will prevent middle-class families from bankruptcy and stop health insurers "jerking" customers around.

     
  58.  
    BBC Washington correspondent, Katty Kay

    tweets: If twitter is the new judge of debates, Obama is definitely losing this one.

     
  59.  
    2005: Adam Blenford BBC News, Denver

    Obama tries to keep the floor, demanding his extra five seconds on healthcare - and uses it to bring up Romney's Massachusetts health reforms. But he stutters slightly and soon has to end his answer. Did he make the most of what was clearly a pre-planned attack? Romney pivots quickly back to why he thinks Americans don't want Obamacare.

     
  60.  
    Senior Washington Editor, NPR News, Ron Elving

    tweets: Romney scoring with lines like "five banks designated too big to fail and given a blank check" like a born-again populist. #debate

     
  61.  
    Former White House Press Secretary under President George W Bush, Ari Fleischer

    tweets: Romney is much more articulate than O. O has lots of ums and ahs...

     
  62.  
    Paul Adams BBC News, Washington

    tweets: "Obama on Obamacare. We've seen this model work really well. In Massachusetts. Crowd at Dem watch party in Va loves that"

     
  63.  
    2009:

    "The private market and individual responsibiity always work best," says Romney, as he attacks the Obama healthcare reform.

     
  64.  
    2009:

    PolitiFact fact-check: Is Romney plan for future Medicare a voucher system? Mostly True

     
  65.  
    2011: Jonny Dymond BBC News, Washington

    Romney is punching through the heartless-corporate-suit caricature and comes across as competent and as normal as presidential candidates get.

     
  66.  
    2013:

    Romney says his Massachusetts healthcare scheme - which was the model for Obama's own reform - was fine as a state-level plan, but not as a national one.

     
  67.  
    Filmmaker Michael Moore

    tweets: Was Jim Lehrer coached by Clint Eastwood? Can anyone out there in the Twitterverse make any sense outta what he's doing?

     
  68.  
    2015:

    Obama suggests Romney is keeping his plans "secret", as he suggests his rival is being vague on the specifics of his proposals.

     
  69.  

    @BBCNewsUS tweets: "Press room reacts strongly each time the candidates step on #Lehrer's attempts to move the #debates along".

     
  70.  
    Journalist Jeff Jarvis

    tweets: Does Obama want to keep this job? #debate

     
  71.  
    2021:

    Another suggestion from Obama that Romney's plans lack specifics. On education, the president says that Romney's proposal "wasn't very detailed - this seems to be a trend".

     
  72.  
    Political analyst, Larry Sabato

    tweets: Interesting. My guess is Obama's advisers said, 'Don't attack. Not presidential.' Leaving attacks to TV ads.

     
  73.  

    Jim Acosta, CNN national political correspondent, tweets: "Romney has not hit Obama on welfare reform. Obama has not hit Romney on 47%."

     
  74.  
    2023:

    Romney says that Obama invested $90bn on green energy, which would have hired two million teachers. Says that government mustn't pick winners and losers in the private sector.

     
  75.  
    2026:

    Romney: "The reason I'm in this race is that there are people who are really hurting in this country... Republicans and Democrats both love America - but we need leadership in Washington."

     
  76.  
    2026:

    In the world of Twitter, one of the big emerging themes from the debate that is now in the top five trending terms worldwide is Romney's remark that he loves Big Bird - apparent concern that Romney might fire Big Bird from Sesame Street.

     
  77.  
    2027:

    How to end partisan gridlock? Romney says he's done it in Massachusetts and he will sit down on day one with Democrats. Obama says he's going to have a busy day, what with repealing Obamacare and then sitting down with its Democratic supporters.

     
  78.  
    2028:

    Obama lost the coin toss and so he makes the first closing statement.

     
  79.  
    2030:

    Obama says America's strength is its people, "their genius, their grit, their determination", says it is important that everybody has a fair shot, everybody is playing by the same rules.

     
  80.  
    Stand-up comedian and political commentator, Bill Maher

    tweets: Obama made a lot of great points tonight. Unfortunately, most of them were for Romney

     
  81.  
    Actress and co-host of The View, Sherri Shepherd

    tweets: Mitt's got this #debate tonight... did he change my mind at all.... not a bit. There's something about him I just don't trust

     
  82.  
    2031:

    Romney says he'll get incomes up again, that he'll create 12 million new jobs, says that if Obama is re-elected the US will see a $716bn cut to Medicare, says Obama will bring drastic cuts to the military.

     
  83.  
    2034:

    And it's over. Obama's wife Michelle joins him on stage, so does Romney's family, they're all talking together, it looks like a parent-teachers' council meeting.

     
  84.  
    2035:

    Obama's left the stage but Romney lingers there with his family, giving the thumbs up to the crowd, before departing.

     
  85.  
    Mark Mardell BBC North America editor

    tweets: #debates Few will doubt Romney had the best of that debate animated, engaged and interrupting an over cautious President @BBCNewsUS

     
  86.  
    2036:

    CNN breaks down the speaking time for the two candidates during the debate: Obama spoke for 45 minutes and 50 seconds, Romney for 38 minutes and 32 seconds.

     
  87.  
    2041:

    As the debate comes to a close, Obama and Romney's surrogates are in the media centre spinning fervently for their candidate. The next presidential debate will be on 16 October, but before that Joe Biden and Paul Ryan will joust in the only vice-presidential debate, on 11 October.

     
  88.  
    Los Angeles Times Washington columnist, Doyle McManus

    tweets: What Obama never mentioned: Romney's 47%, outsourcing, or the Cayman Islands.

     
  89.  
    New York Times columnist, Nicholas Kristof

    tweets: Obama was at his best in his closing statement, presumably because it was all prepared. But he was very rusty tonight.

     
  90.  
    Don Clarke in Atlanta, Georgia

    emails: "I thought it was a terrific exchange! Romney, as I thought he would, burst through the caricature the media has tried to mould of him. I think all Americans need to put prejudice aside - this country is in desperate need of fiscal responsibility, creativity, and a government responsive to the people, not the other way around."

     
  91.  
    Director of Social Media and Engagement for the Wall Street Journal, Liz Heron

    tweets: New Twitter accounts tonight: @SilentJimLehrer @FiredBigBird

     
  92.  
    First Lady, Michelle Obama

    tweets: I simply couldn't be prouder of my husband tonight. -mo

     
  93.  
    2100:

    What was true and what was a distortion? Factcheckers at the New York Times, Washington Post and PolitiFact have been refereeing the candidates' claims.

     
  94.  
    Jonny Rotheram in Denver, Colorado

    emails: "As a Brit living in Denver, I've always been surprised at the levels of poverty here - there are homeless people on almost every corner begging. I don't think a Romney-led government will help these people out of poverty."

     
  95.  
    2106: Mark Mardell BBC North America editor

    Romney was animated, in command of his information, over-riding the moderator and interrupting the president. He seemed to be in charge and enjoying the scrap. On the other hand, President Obama started out looking very nervous, and although he warmed up got into his stride, he ended up giving overly long, mini-lectures rather than engaging and arguing. He seemed unwilling to actually debate with his opponent, and missed a few obvious openings when he should have challenged.

     
  96.  
    Twitter's Government & Politics team

    tweets: Tonight's debate was the most tweeted about event in US political history, topping the numbers from the RNC and DNC.

     
  97.  
    2113:

    That's it for our coverage of the first presidential debate. Join us for the next head-to-head between Obama and Romney on 16 October in Hempstead, New York. It's going to be a town-hall style foreign policy forum and CNN's Candy Crowley will moderate. Thanks for joining us!

     

US Presidential Election 2012

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.