Akin's folly, Obama's opportunity

Todd Akin and his wife Lulli, talk with reporters while attending the Missouri State Fair in Sedalia 16 August 2012 Were Akin's comments simply "mistakes" or something more?

"The mistake was in the words I said, not in the heart I hold."

So said Todd Akin, who finds himself at the centre of a firestorm that is dominating the election campaign.

Republican candidate Mitt Romney has called on him to withdraw from the Senate race, but the Obama campaign won't let it rest there.

Expect them to stir the pot again today with a mass email to remind liberal voters of previous Republican forays into similar issues.

President Obama reacted with alacrity on Monday, saying the notion of "legitimate rape" was "way out there".

His quickly mounted assault is deeply political - it allowed him to attack the idea of "a bunch of politicians making healthcare decisions on behalf of women".

Odd and odder

This fits neatly with the Democrats' allegation that some conservative Republicans want to wage a "war on women": subjecting them to intrusive scans before an abortion and denying them contraception if their employer disagrees with it (there are many Catholic universities and hospitals in the States).

Those Republicans will retort they are talking about the rights of the unborn child and religious freedoms, but that may not impress those the president wants to fret about the prospect of a Republican victory.

Pregnancy and rape

  • There are more than 32,000 pregnancies from rape each year, the Centers for Disease Control says
  • A woman who has been raped "has no control over ovulation, fertilization or implantation of a fertilized egg (pregnancy)," says the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
  • The same group says that annually, between 10,000 and 15,000 abortions take place as a result of incest or rape

He already has a lead with women and he wants to increase it by suggesting Republicans want to impinge on their rights.

But it is bigger than that. It distracts voters' attention away from the economy, and to what are quaintly called "cultural issues".

To you and me that means attitudes towards sex. Mr Obama's narrative is that victorious Republicans would turn the clock back to the 50s.

Behind Mr Akin's odd phrases and odder understanding of medicine is a belief that abortion is wrong, in all circumstances, even when a woman has been raped.

This is perfectly logical. If abortion is murder, it doesn't stop being murder because of the circumstances of a child's conception.

But many Republicans and many voters are a little more hazy in their logic and more pragmatic in their positioning.

Mr Romney has responded quickly and firmly to Akin's remarks. But if the Obama campaign prods him for more definite answers on this central question it is more difficult.

That's exactly why they are doing it. If Mr Romney backs abortion in some cases, he risks losing the enthusiasm of some conservative voters.

If he suggests it should be outlawed in all cases, he risks losing support in the middle ground.

As for Mr Akin, as so often, his "gaffe" was a compound of more than one mistake.

The phrase "legitimate rape" is ugly and bound to offend. He obviously didn't mean that some rapes were acceptable, but it sounded as if he did.

Truly bizarre

I presume he meant "real" rape, which suggests he either thinks some rapes are not real because women aren't telling the truth, or that a rape is not "real" unless it is accompanied with a high degree of violence.

Many will find either interpretation pretty repulsive. If someone talked about "legitimate murder" or "legitimate burglary", we would be left scratching our heads as to what they meant.

But he was only using the phrase to promote his theory that women who are raped can't get pregnant, because their body shuts down. This is truly bizarre.

I have never heard anything like it before, but apparently it is not the first time an American politician has raised it.

During a 1998 Senate campaign in Arkansas, the Republican candidate Dr Fay Boozman claimed that hormones generated by fear usually prevented rape victims from getting pregnant.

Yet it is much older than that, indeed a favourite theory of 13th Century medicine.

Mr Akin may have many admirable qualities which recommend him to the voters of Missouri. But it seems strange that a 21st Century politician is willing to legislate on the grounds of old wives' tales.

Perhaps he should be explaining that, rather than his clumsy use of language.

Mark Mardell Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell North America editor

Is Obama right over Iraq?

The Obama doctrine says the US will only go to war if its vital interests or those of its allies are threatened, so what does that mean for Iraq?

Read full article

More on This Story

US Presidential Election 2012


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 444.

    My referred comments merely ask where Stalin, a former seminarian, might have gotten his inhumane ideas. It also suggested that the proponents of DOMA and the NC constitutional amendment couldn't be trusted to hold power in the US, the Constitution of which is secular.

    Why should any of that be objectionable or censored, except by those with an interest in concealed intent?

  • rate this

    Comment number 443.

    All for All,

    Our "mainstream" are something like a firestorm.

    Akin's initial statement on "legitimate" rape, implied any woman who became pregnant virtually couldn't have been a genuine victim of rape. Should he become a senator, he would have the right to singlehandedly put a "hold" on any judicial nominee. It's responsible journalism to bring this issue forward, sad as it is.

  • rate this

    Comment number 442.

    Mr Akin sounds like one of those Amish folk who regard the automobile as the work of the devil - is he definitely seeking election as a Republican senator? Can anyone confirm?

  • Comment number 441.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this

    Comment number 440.


    Mark covers "firestorm" around Akin, alleged "war on women", & use of "dictionary murder" & "logic" putting "abortion" (alongside other "killing", judicial, self-defence, legal war, genocide) as "murder", all in context of "mainstream politics"

    On comments: no random Editors' Picks, but mystery in moderation especially deep for N American Editor: 'democracy' surely 'on topic', always?


Comments 5 of 444



  • Shiny bootsMarching orders

    Where does the phrase 'boots on the ground' come from?

  • Almaz cleaning floorAlmaz's prison

    Beaten and raped - the story of an African servant in Saudi Arabia

  • Train drawn by Jonathan Backhouse, 1825The first trainspotter

    Did this drawing mark the start of a misunderstood hobby?

  • MarijuanaHigh tech

    The start-ups hoping to transform the marijuana industry

  • Child eating ice creamTooth top tips

    Experts on ways to encourage children to look after their teeth

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.