White House downplays Republican Wisconsin win

Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker holds his first cabinet meeting after winning the recall election, Madison, Wisconsin 6 June 2012 Correspondents say Governor Scott Walker's action against public sector unions could become a template for other lawmakers facing budget deficits

The failure of a Democratic bid to unseat Wisconsin's Republican governor should not alter the presidential election battle, the White House says.

Spokesman Jay Carney said he "wouldn't read too much into" Scott Walker's win over Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett.

But Mr Walker said Wisconsin would be "competitive" when Barack Obama takes on Mitt Romney in November.

Mr Walker's victory could also embolden politicians in other regions to take on organised labour, analysts say.

In other votes, two California cities overwhelmingly approved cuts to state workers' pensions to save public money.

Speaking to reporters on Wednesday, Mr Carney said Mr Barrett was facing an uphill struggle in his battle against Mr Walker.

Start Quote

The fight was about something real and substantial - the role and power of unions -which could be a big issue in the presidential campaign”

End Quote

"What you had was an incumbent governor in a repeat election that he had won once, in which he outspent his challenger by a magnitude of seven or eight to one with an enormous amount of outside corporate money and huge donations.

"I certainly wouldn't read much into yesterday's result beyond who is occupying the governor's seat in Wisconsin."

But Mr Walker said Mr Obama could no longer count on carrying the state with a comfortable margin like he did in 2008.

"I think anyone looking at the results last night would also acknowledge that it's now competitive in Wisconsin," he told US TV network MSNBC.

'Reform momentum'

In California, voters in the cities of San Diego and San Jose - the eighth and 10th largest cities in the US - approved ballot measures that would curb retirement benefits for government workers.

The moves had been touted as a strategy to save public funds, correspondents say, even as residents have seen cutbacks to other public services while the cost of public pensions have soared.

Both measures passed with wide margins: San Diego residents approved the measure by 66% and San Jose by 70%.

"A big win here gives mayors across the country confidence that if they bring this to their voters, the voters will get it," Democratic San Jose Mayor Chuck Reed told the Associated Press.

In addition, Republican politicians in the US states of Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri and New Hampshire are reportedly considering renewed pushes against union rights.

Momentum is with the Republicans now that they have held onto this seat, as Jonny Dymond reports.

"Not only is there the momentum in favour of the kinds of reforms that Governor Walker advocated for and got passed, but there becomes a competitive issue," Minnesota state Senator Dave Thompson told the AP.

In Wisconsin, Mr Walker's divisive plan was aimed at closing a state budget deficit of $3.6bn (£2.3bn), partly through public sector reforms.

His proposals set off weeks of angry protests and even prompted 14 Democratic lawmakers to temporarily leave the state in an effort to stall the bill.

The law that was eventually passed forced employees to contribute more towards healthcare and pensions and limited the collective bargaining rights of public sector unions.

More on This Story

US Presidential Election 2012

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More US & Canada stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Sport in SpainSuper-charged sport Watch

    BBC Travel has a go at an unusual activity which once held the world record for fastest ball speed

Programmes

  • Marc CieslakClick Watch

    On the front-line as Sony and Microsoft go into battle with console wars – but who will win?

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.