High stakes for Obama and Chen Guangcheng

Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng (L) is led out of the US embassy in Beijing by Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell (R) and US Ambassador Gary Locke (C) in Beijing, China, 2 May 2012 Chen Guangcheng (left) was led out of the US Embassy by Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell (right) and US Ambassador Gary Locke (centre)

Related Stories

The fate of Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng is not yet clear. But that won't stop many from judging that this muddle is of US President Barack Obama's making.

The Obama administration looks like it has been caught on the hop and the embassy is being portrayed by many as either fools or knaves.

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney says it is a dark day for freedom and a day of shame for the Obama administration.

In some of his numerous telephone interviews, Mr Chen suggests that he feels let down by America. Although he did not say that talking to the BBC.

Elsewhere, he has suggested that he was pretty much forced to leave to save the US embarrassment as important talks get underway.

President Obama's spokesman says it is "not the case" that Mr Chen has been abandoned, adding that talks were still going on with him, his family, and the Chinese government.

High stakes

The confusion has arisen because Mr Chen has changed his mind about staying in China, although that is not the central problem.

Start Quote

Before he went into the van, I asked him again, 'Is this what you want to do? Are you ready to leave the Embassy?' And he said yes”

End Quote Gary Locke US Ambassador to China

He changed his mind because he took the threat to send his family home as a death sentence, whereas the embassy seems to have missed this interpretation.

The US ambassador to China, Gary Locke, says he spent five hours a day he spent five hours a day with Mr Chen and at that no point did he ask for asylum.

"He made it very, very clear from the very, very beginning that he wanted to stay in China, that he wanted to be part of the struggle to improve the human rights within China, and to gain greater liberty and democracy for the people of China.

"We asked him, did you want to go to the United States, and he said no," Mr Locke told reporters.

He says that Mr Chen rejected one deal but then accepted another.

"And then we asked him what did he want to do, did he want to leave, was he ready to leave. And we waited several minutes and then suddenly he jumped up, very excited, very eager, and said, 'Let's go,' in front of many, many witnesses.

"We then proceeded to take him down to the van with the doctors, translators, and many other personnel. Before he went into the van, I asked him again: 'Is this what you want to do? Are you ready to leave the embassy?' And he said yes."

But the heart of the affair remains the same.

What still strikes me is the promise, made by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, that the US would act as guarantors that the Chinese would keep their promises to allow Mr Chen liberty and freedom to study law.

"The United States government and the American people are committed to remaining engaged with Mr Chen and his family in the days, weeks, and years ahead," Mrs Clinton said.

When she first said this it looked bold, but now it seems reckless.

Some critics of the administration are portraying the embassy as inept bunglers under pressure to remove a distraction before the big talks got under way.

Others claim that others that President Obama has been cold-blooded and ruthless.

Until we know the outcome it is not wise to rush to judgment. But President Obama is playing for high stakes, at home and abroad.

Mark Mardell, North America editor Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell North America editor

More on This Story

Related Stories


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Great another news story where people that have no actual knowledge or authority in regard to,can comment on the wisdom or lack of others that very likely also does not know jack about. Just the making of more noise makes the world go round.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Is it worth it to go to war over this guy?

    Most Americans would probably say No

    Although we would love to help people out
    we can't take in every single person
    mistreated by their country
    cause' thats far too many people

    The Chinese themselves are the ones who have to stand up for Mr Chen+ for their freedom+justice

    USA cannot do it for Chinese

    Chinese must do it for themselves

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    @2.LucyJ ,
    America has a longstanding policy of offering political asylum.
    Most people love their own countries & cultures&don't necessarily wish to leave.In Mr. Chen's case ,he may have no other option but to seek asylum.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    MsC: Most people love their own countries & cultures&don't necessarily wish to leave

    Mexico, North Korea, China, Taiwan, Haiti, Venezuela, Cuba, Africa, Middle East, Thailand, the list goes on+on of billions of people who do wish to leave

    This Mr Chen is one thing
    but we can't take in all of China

    That being said,
    how big of a deal would it be for Mr Chen
    to be granted asylum in USA?

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    He could have become a prisoner [by Chinese] in the US Embassy as happened occasionally during the cold war. He could have been got there as a part of a devious Chinese plot to embarrass the US. We don't know yet. It will be used by the GOP, in our dirty politics even pets are abused, why not a Chinese dissident as well?


Comments 5 of 59


This entry is now closed for comments


  • June plays with a pelicanDad's menagerie

    An extraordinary childhood growing up in a zoo

  • US soldier, part of the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF), manning a machine gun onboard a Chinook helicopter over the Gardez district of Paktia province on 11 August 2014Viewpoint

    Nato's role in making the Afghan army sustainable

  • Architect's drawing of bedroomDeep dreams

    The homes where you can live under the sea

  • A snailHard to stomach?

    The IT worker who quit his job to farm snails for restaurants

  • An assortment of secret menu itemsMcSecret

    The fast food items you've never heard of

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.