Can Obama jobs plan pass?

US President Barack Obama speaks to a crowd in Ohio to sell the American Jobs Act to voters Recent polls show President Obama's approval rating is low and could jeopardise his re-election prospects

Related Stories

In his speech to Congress the other day, President Obama sounded like an old-time preacher with his thumping refrain "pass this bill". Today, in Ohio, his call got a response.

"Pass this bill," chanted the crowd right on cue.

The president had waved a copy of his hefty American Jobs Act and told them the USA had to catch up with the likes of China and North Korea in spending on high-speed rail and education.

There's little wonder he is warning America could be left behind. There were more bad statistics out today.

There are 43.6 million people living in poverty in the USA now. Not just the highest number but the highest proportion - 15.1% - for 17 years. Mr Obama needs to inspire.

"Lift your voice," he told the Ohio crowd. "Call and email and tweet your congressman. The time for games and gridlock is over."

Start Quote

Mr Obama is portraying a series of pretty partisan, controversial proposals as plain common sense that no-one of goodwill could resist”

End Quote

He built to a crescendo: "If you want construction workers back in work what do you do? 'Pass this bill!' If you want teachers back at work, what do you do? 'Pass this bill!'"

One first-time voter in the crowd should be pleased by the power of the speech.

The president was talking at Fort Hayes art and design college and one pupil, 18-year-old Mel Dodge, told reporters he was an aspiring lyricist and admires Mr Obama's skills.

"He chooses his words so beautifully," said the teenager. "That's why I came out here today, just to hear that in person."

He wasn't so certain about the politics, unsure that the president's jobs plan would work. He wanted to look at the Republican field as well before he decides how to cast his first vote.

If Mr Dodge is not convinced, it won't be through lack of White House effort. Senior advisor David Plouffe is just the latest to offer to answer questions by tweet.

I've just got a detailed White House email on the beneficial impact of the act on Montana. Why Montana, I know not, but I am sure 49 similar missives will soon be in my inbox.

The president will, I guess, be on the road until this is done or dead.

The objective is not just to persuade Americans of the merit of his plan. It is to paint his opponents as wreckers.

He is portraying what is a series of pretty partisan, controversial proposals as plain common sense, that no-one of goodwill could resist.

In fact, there is intense debate about his ideas.

He got backing on Tuesday for more spending from the Congressional Budget Office's director, who warned cuts could damage recovery.

But the president's plan is ideologically objectionable to most Republicans, even more so now that he has revealed how it would be paid for: by taxing what they would describe as "wealth creators" and what Obama would call the rich, oil companies and corporate-jet owners.

This is bound to get messy. The White House has confirmed that they will accept parts of the bill being passed.

The danger for Obama is a loss of his simple message.

He could get drawn into the wrangling and the less attractive aspects of compromise. He needs all the clarity his lyricism and beautiful words can conjure.

Mark Mardell, North America editor Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell North America editor

More on This Story

Related Stories


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    If Dems or Repubs are serious about creating jobs, its time to completely redo NAFTA and WHO trade agreements

    USA has lost and will continue to lose millions of jobs as long as outsourcing is not addressed

    Our economy is collapsing due to outsourcing

    Is there anyone brave enough to stand up for American jobs?

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    "The danger for Obama is a loss of his simple message."

    I have a message for Obama: This is a jobs creation "plan" like your spending was a "stimulus".

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    "He needs all the clarity his lyricism and beautiful words can conjure."

    That's impossible. You are asking a demagogue to give up sophistry. What's left then? He wouldn't be able to talk at all!

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Wow; the U.S. must really be struggling if Mr. Obama thinks they have to catch up with North Korea on education and infrastructure spending! ;)

    And really, does the debate on America's economic future really need to expressed this way? Does no-one have time to listen to a fleshed out, reasoned argument? "Pass this bill" is way too close to "Drill baby, drill" for my liking (and equally innane).

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Many of us in the U.S. have come to recognize the Teleprompter of the United States (TOTUS) for the person he really is. He’s a self interested preacher, he is the “Elmer Gantry” of our generation. While he may not have preached from the pulpit, he earned his bread in the street mobilizing disaffected citizens of the U.S. for his own benefit.


Comments 5 of 171


This entry is now closed for comments


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.