9/11 anniversary: Time for nation-building at home

Ground Zero memorial in New York on 10 September 2011 9/11 altered perspectives for many Americans

It is the first time I have seen the Memorial Fountains at Ground Zero working. They are pretty impressive. The footprints of where the towers once stood have been turned into square pools, dark and huge, a waterfall on each side. All around the edges are engraved the names of those who died in the buildings.

But looking out of the window as I write, part of the area is still a building site, a huge square of churned-up mud. Five giant diggers squat, for the moment idle, the area scattered with concrete cylinders and metal parts.

It has taken a long time to turn a scar into a memorial, and the job is not yet done. America too has not fully absorbed and digested the events of that day, but it is beginning to do so.

President Obama's weekly radio address suggests some of the ways he thinks America should move on. But some of the changes will probably never go away.

When I arrived in New York, I left the train at Penn Station under the watchful eye of a man holding a heavy machine gun. On the concourse, a video was playing on a huge TV screen about a "three foot hero" keeping us all safe - the tale of a sniffer dog. As I made my way downtown, the police were stopping every large van and lorry. This is exceptional, but every time you go into an airport you know life has changed.

During the summer, when I first started asking Americans about how 9/11 had changed their country, I was surprised. I had been expecting something about the wars, or other philosophical reflections. Instead they talked about queues at airports. It has become a new way of a life in the last 10 years.

Security has got tighter in the UK too but, because of the IRA campaign, it had always been there in the background. For us in Britain the change was incremental, for Americans it was the start of something new. The USA's enemies have imposed an irksome but necessary burden on all Americans.

So a sense of vulnerability and the priority of protection will remain.

Decade of war

But, although President Obama will stand alongside former president George W Bush on Sunday, I expect he will make clear in his evening speech in Washington that the priorities are rather different to the initial response.

Rather like his speech to congress, his weekly radio address appealed for a common spirit and unity but was quite political.

He pointed out that it was only while he was president that the war against al-Qaeda had scored major triumphs.

"Over the past two and a half years, more senior al-Qaeda leaders have been eliminated than at any time since 9/11. And thanks to the remarkable courage and precision of our forces, we finally delivered justice to Osama bin Laden."

He suggested that at least some of the military action that flowed for 9/11 was falling into al-Qaeda's trap.

"They wanted to draw us into endless wars, sapping our strength and confidence as a nation. But even as we put relentless pressure on al-Qaeda, we're ending the war in Iraq and beginning to bring our troops home from Afghanistan."

Then another critical point.

After a hard decade of war, it is time for nation-building here at home.

On Friday night, on the Ten O'Clock news, I had used the same phrase - saying that is what some Americans were reflecting. I had no idea of course the president was about to use it.

It is a new formulation, but I had most recently heard it from Republican candidate John Huntsman in their recent debate.

It suggests that, on left and right, the biggest change is that an enthusiasm to re-shape the world has faded, even if there is still a determination to make it safer for America and its allies.

Mark Mardell Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell Presenter, The World This Weekend

Has Libya been let down by the West?

The West has failed to support nation-building in Libya, and we are now seeing the consequences, says Mark Mardell.

Read full article

More on This Story


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 670.

    how ..well..fun I and you, truly are!

  • rate this

    Comment number 669.

    Dont go away, Amr, its ok to be different---you know it, I know it,

    Also, beliefs, opinions stink from many others besides us....might as well stay and just give Your opinions...IM NOT afraid of appearing ...different or ignorant of some things

    Its probably obvious to some

  • rate this

    Comment number 668.


    Not a complex concept.

    Bush borrows from China to fund wars and tax cuts.

    US saddled with colossal debt mountain + interest repayments

    What's not to get?

  • rate this

    Comment number 667.

    A min. wage job is considered worse than no job at all? Or than the govt. directly paying people to work? Wow.

    What if the govt. paid minimum wage?
    Andrea - you seem to be enjoying a debate with yourself - keep asking yourself questions and maybe, one day far into the future you'll come up with an answer or even a policy that you're prepared to commit to.

  • rate this

    Comment number 666.

    if you fall down culturally due to the scrutiny of moralality and ethics then more fool you for defending such absurd barbaric actions.it's always easy to look the other way eh?
    My culture is the best,its mine and I will defend it. I will not offend any other cuclture unless ofcourse someone asks me to do it, and then I will offend it so bad that the person will think twice before asking


Comments 5 of 670



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.