Civil War: Southerners remember Confederate president

Sons of Confederate Veterans at a memorial service in 2006 in Fort Smith, Arkansas Members of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, shown here in Arkansas in 2006, encourage Southerners to "proclaim and protect" their heritage

On Saturday, a group will gather in Alabama to mark the 150th anniversary of the inauguration of the first president of the Confederacy, 11 Southern slave states that left the US in 1860 and 1861. They say they are honouring their ancestors and their heritage but, as the BBC's Daniel Nasaw reports, critics view the group as celebrating slavery.

Under a bright Southern sky on Saturday, the Sons of Confederate Veterans will dress in period costume, including replica grey uniforms of the Confederate army, to commemorate the first raising of a national flag and the inauguration of a president.

They won't be saluting the familiar Stars and Stripes or honouring an occupant of the White House. Instead, they will pay tribute to the Confederate States of America, a political entity created after 11 states seceded from the US. That painful division led to the Civil War.

Start Quote

The people who wore those Confederate uniforms were fighting for the wrong side, no matter what their personal intentions might have been”

End Quote Josh Moon Montgomery (Alabama) Advertiser

The event's organisers say that in addition to marking an important moment in US history, the commemoration is intended to instil a sense of pride in Southerners who they say have been taught to be ashamed of their heritage.

"It is imperative that this event be well attended," the Sons of Confederate Veterans Alabama division told supporters on its website.

"We must show the world that we will not permit the history and heritage of the Confederacy to be forgotten and unobserved.

"It is up to us to see that this history is remembered and portrayed in the right way."

'National embarrassment'

But critics see Saturday's planned event differently - as an inappropriate and unsettling celebration of the enslavement of African Americans.

"Montgomery and Alabama will once again be cast as backwards, ignorant, racist hillbillies," wrote Montgomery Advertiser columnist Josh Moon in a recent article that called the planned rally a "national embarrassment" that would hold the state up to "ridicule".

Emanuel Rudasill, Company M, 16th North Carolina Regiment, of the Confederate army Many Confederate troops did not see themselves as fighting for slavery

"And we'll once again make it clear to everyone that some of us just can't let go of our racist past... The people who wore those Confederate uniforms were fighting for the wrong side, no matter what their personal intentions might have been."

The disagreement shows how the spasms of the Civil War continue to reverberate in US society almost a century-and-a-half after it ended with the surrender of the Confederacy, analysts say.

"It shows that we still haven't come quite to terms with the significance of slavery in American history," says prominent US historian Eric Foner, of Columbia University.

Historian Joshua Rothman, of the University of Alabama, says: "I don't think there's any possible way to disconnect the memory of the Confederacy from contemporary racial politics."

The US Civil War began on 12 April, 1861, when the new army of the Confederate States of America shelled US Fort Sumter, in a bay near Charleston, South Carolina.

By the time the war ended in April 1865, three million Americans had taken up arms and 620,000 had perished - 2% of the total population at the time.

Across the US, Americans have begun marking the 150th anniversaries of the events leading up to the fighting and, over the next four years, will commemorate virtually every battle, turning point, victory and surrender of the conflict.

Slaveholders' secession

The Confederacy's only president was Jefferson Davis, a Mississippi senator and former US secretary of war.

He was sworn into office on 18 February, 1861, in Montgomery, Alabama, and the Confederate flag was first flown soon after - events that will be re-enacted on Saturday at the state capitol building there.

Start Quote

The South was saying that they believed that the North was heading in a way divergent from the original purposes of the revolution”

End Quote Chuck McMichael Sons of Confederate Veterans

"What we're trying to do is do a historically accurate portrayal of the inauguration," said Tom Strain, lieutenant commander of the Sons of Confederate Veterans Alabama division.

"The main focus of this sesquicentennial event... is to promote the legacy and the history of the Confederate States of America. That was a pivotal point in this nation's growth. It does not need to be forgotten."

Most historians say confederate politicians were unabashed about the prime motivation for secession - fear that the government in Washington led by President Abraham Lincoln would curtail slavery.

"They said: 'We are seceding because slavery is in danger'," Prof Foner said. "They didn't beat around the bush. They didn't feel slavery was safe in a union governed by the non-slaveholding states, and that is why they created the Confederacy."

But the Sons of Confederate Veterans reject this view.

"The victors write the history," said Chuck McMichael, former commander-in-chief of the group and a member of its governing council.

"If a nation invaded another nation for economic subjugation, they wouldn't portray themselves that way."

The Sons and other Confederate sympathisers say the Southern states seceded to protect "states rights", or in protest against import tariffs backed by northern industrial states.

Re-enactors in replica Confederate uniform in Virginia, 2010 Some historians say Confederate heritage groups misrepresent the history of Southern slavery

Roughly 13% of the US population is African-American, with most of those tracing their ancestry to more than three million slaves living in the Confederate states at the start of the civil war.

"To me it's somewhat akin to celebrating the Holocaust," said Benard [sic] Simelton, president of the Alabama conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), one of America's most prominent and oldest civil rights groups.

"The celebration of this means to me that we still have not come as far as we should have, as we think we have, in race relations in America.

"They wanted to keep African Americans in slavery. That's nothing to celebrate."

A map of the Confederacy, 1861

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More US & Canada stories



  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back

  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6

  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?

  • A man shutting his eyes tightlyStrange light show

    What do you see when you close your eyes?

  • Sony WalkmanLost ideas

    What has happened to Japan's inventors?

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.