Your questions to Jeremy Bowen

Benjamin Netanyahu tells Jeremy Bowen Israel won't deal with a Palestinian government backed by Hamas

After nine months of faltering negotiations peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians have collapsed.

BBC Middle East editor Jeremy Bowen answered your questions in a live Twitter Q&A on Friday 25 April.

This is an edited version of the session.

Question from @MuellerNora: What are the prospects for a negotiated two-state solution?

Jeremy answers: At the moment non-existent. There's no agreement on what kind of independent state Palestinians would have.

Keith Hendry emails: Why do the Israelis find it so difficult to agree to a Palestinian state?

Jeremy replies: Israel says it has many concerns, inc. borders, refugees and security. On the Israeli right state idea still controversial.

Mark Haugaard from Galway, Ireland emails: If we take it that talks have collapsed what is plan B?

Jeremy answers: Depends who you ask. Both sides say they want peace & both say it won't happen until the other offers more concessions.

Question from @Anarchasm: Will Palestinians eventually have to drop right of return as a realistic demand?

Jeremy replies: They've discussed ways of retaining the principle while conceding that only a small number would be allowed back. But no deal.

Question from @K_Anckarstrom: Why is Israel allowed to have nuclear weapons without declaring them or signing NPT? International law?!

Jeremy answers: Because Israel keeps its programme undeclared and enjoys diplomatic protection from the US and other western powers.

Question from @tapaccos: Is there any "sort of" accepted peace that is accepted by both sides even if behind the scenes?

Jeremy replies: There's a status quo everyone is used to. It's often quiet, but it's not peace. It suits some on both sides.

Question from @dannighirl: Would Hamas likely win in Gaza if elections held now? If so does that indicate more support for war not peace?

Jeremy answers: Too early to say how elections would go. But vast majority of Palestinians in Gaza & elsewhere don't want more wars.

Question from @simoneyvan: What will it take to bring Israel and Palestine back to the negotiating table now?

Jeremy replies: Israel says end of pact with Hamas. The question though is what they'd discuss if and when they get there.

Question from @marcomartini: Do you think that the peace process will only resume if & when both the Palestinians and Israel have new leaders?

Jeremy answers: Whoever is the leader of either side a process without desire to make hard choices isn't going to work.

Question from @philipmoor: Why are the Israelis able to ignore all UN resolutions?

Jeremy replies: Israel doesn't ignore all resolutions but it's protected at the UN by the US veto, which has been used many times.

Question from @mjwright95: Is there much public support on either side for peace deals or are they as hawkish as the decision-makers?

Jeremy answers: Public on both sides are as sceptical as their leaders about the chances of a deal.

Question from @Aichadell: How do you forecast the impact of the new coalition Hamas-Fatah on peace process between Israel-Palestine?

Jeremy replies: Right now Israel has suspended talks. But US appetite for cajoling two divided parties is reaching its limits.

Question from @DTraynier: What would you say is the single biggest misconception the British public has about the conflict?

Jeremy answers: Dunno if it's the biggest but people should know that between crises this is a great place for a holiday.

Question from @jomah162: Is there still any chance of Kerry achieving substantive progress before the Obama administration leaves office?

Jeremy replies: Doubt it. After 20 plus years of failed talks time to ask whether it this model of negotiation will ever work.

Question from @shanemuk: Does this collapse represent what each side really wants? It maintains preaching to their own parochial choirs.

Jeremy answers: Both sides want peace and quiet. But their definitions of what that is and what it would take are way apart.

Question from @DTraynier: Why does the BBC routinely say Hamas "seized control" of Gaza in 06? They were elected Govt.

Jeremy replies: We don't. They won election in 06 but seized control from Fatah by force in 07.

Question from @Anarchasm tweets: How likely do you think the Fatah-Hamas talks are to mean any real change?

Jeremy answers: If the deal sticks Palestinians will feel stronger. But big differences between them, and making it real unity not easy.

John Duffy emails: Is it fair to say that Netanyahu will always find an excuse to avoid sitting down with the Palestinians?

Jeremy replies: No his govts have been in many negotiations. He says he's doing all he can for peace. Palestinians don't believe him.

Question from @rk70534: BBC seems to be afraid of publishing news that portray Israel in negative light. Why?

Jeremy answers: We have no problem showing any country in a negative light if justified. We are not pro Israeli or pro anyone else.

Question from @emilyhilton: Is it likely Israel will increase its military presence in the West Bank after Hamas-Fatah reconciliation?

Jeremy replies: No. Daily life goes on. But Israeli military can mobilise more forces very quickly if it wants to.

Question from @aaronadams17: With what conditions do you think peace will finally arrive?

Jeremy answers: I doubt they'll ever get the classic 2 state solution. But lots of long term problems piling up if they don't.

Question from @WeAreNIRV: Did you feel intimidated by Netanyahu during your interview?

Jeremy replies: Not at all! I've been in many scary places but his office wasn't one of them.

Question from @EstherJudah: What are the chances of Hamas/Fatah coming out and declaring recognition of Israel to relaunch peace?

Jeremy answers: Fatah recognised Israeli state years ago. Hamas says it wants a long term truce. Maybe absence of war is only thing possible.

Question from @JohnTomkins: What does Tony Blair do and is he of any use whatsoever?

Jeremy replies: As envoy he does econ stuff not political negotiation. Some projects effective. But Iraq legacy undermines his credibility.

Question from @Aichadell: What about a one-state solution with a federal system?

Jeremy answers: If no 2 state soln a single state is logical in next generation (or 2) who that benefits is another matter.

Question from @961a tweets: After your own experiences do you ever see a light? Just ain't going to happen is it?

Jeremy replies: 1st visit here was 1991. Lived in Jerusalem 1995-2000. Many visits since. I don't see things getting better. Hope I'm wrong.

For more tweets from Jeremy Bowen you can follow his Twitter account.

More on This Story

Mid-East crisis

More Middle East stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.