Egypt judges refuse to oversee Morsi referendum

 
Opposition supporters in Tahrir Square - 1 December The opposition says Mr Mursi has failed to seek a wide consensus on the constitution

Judges in Egypt have refused to oversee a vote on the country's new draft constitution, to be held in two weeks.

The Judges' Club's decision follows a confrontation between Egypt's Supreme Constitutional Court and Islamist supporters of President Mohammed Morsi.

The court said it was suspending its work after its members were prevented from ruling on the legitimacy of the body that drew up the constitution.

Opposition groups called for protests against the referendum on Tuesday.

They said Mr Morsi had broken a promise not to call a referendum without gaining a wide national consensus.

"The National Salvation Front condemns the irresponsible act by the president of the republic in calling a referendum on an illegitimate constitution that is rejected by a large section of his people," an alliance of opposition groups said in a statement.

The opposition believes that the draft constitution undermines basic freedoms.

The latest developments heighten the tensions between President Morsi and his Muslim Brotherhood supporters on one side, and his mainly secular political opponents and the judiciary on the other.

Non-binding

Hours after the Supreme Constitutional Court suspended its work, the Judges' Club, the union which represents the profession nationwide, said it had turned down the judges' traditional role of electoral oversight for the referendum.

"We have decided to boycott the supervision of the referendum on the constitution scheduled for December 15, 2012," the club's head Ahmed al-Zind announced.

"This protest is in response to what is being called the 'constitutional decree' and until this decree is rescinded."

Correspondents say the club's decisions are not binding on members, and Vice-President Mahmoud Mekky said he was confident judges would do their job.

Constitution at a glance

  • Sharia remains the main source of legislation
  • Al-Azhar, Sunni Islam's leading authority, to be consulted on "matters related to Sharia"
  • Christianity and Judaism to be the main source of legislation for Christians and Jews
  • Religious freedom to be limited to Muslims, Christians and Jews
  • Limits president to two four-year terms of office

The Supreme Constitutional Court had earlier described Sunday as "the blackest day in the history of Egyptian judiciary" after its judges were prevented from attending a meeting by Islamist protesters.

The court had been scheduled to rule on whether to dissolve both the constituent assembly that passed the draft constitution and the Islamist-dominated upper house of parliament, the Shura Council.

Supporters of President Mohammed Morsi wanted to block any ruling that would question the document's legality.

Mr Morsi adopted sweeping new powers in a decree on 22 November that stripped the judiciary of any power to challenge his decisions, so it is unclear what effect any Supreme Constitutional Court ruling would have had.

However, analysts say any ruling opposing his decisions would be a direct challenge and would bolster the opposition campaign to have his decree annulled.

The president's supporters are wary of the court, as it dissolved an Islamist-dominated lower house of parliament in an earlier confrontation in June.

The draft constitution was rushed through the constituent assembly on Thursday night.

Mr Morsi receives a copy of the draft constitution, 1 Dec Mr Morsi announced the referendum on Saturday

After receiving a copy of the document on Saturday, Mr Morsi called on "all Egyptians" to take part in the referendum, whether or not they agreed with the draft.

The draft constitution and the recent decree have prompted widespread protests by opponents.

Many anti-government activists remain camped out in Cairo's Tahrir Square.

If approved, the new text will overwrite all constitutional declarations - including Mr Morsi's decree - and a new parliament should be elected within 60 days.

Among the historic changes to Egypt's system of government, the draft limits a president to two four-year terms. It also introduces some civilian oversight of the military.

The draft keeps in place an article defining "principles of Sharia", or Islamic law, as the main source of legislation.

Mr Morsi's supporters point to the fact that he is Egypt's first freely elected president and argue that liberals and secularists do not represent the vast majority of Egyptians.

But the extent of Mr Morsi's new powers has raised fears that he might become a new dictator.

 

More on This Story

Egypt changing

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 119.

    DavidinUSA @118
    "weird"?

    But all 'born ignorant'

    Everywhere there is vulnerability in enjoyments, of music, belonging, hypnotic words, rhetorical skill, substance-abuse, legal or otherwise

    The richer West, as the poorer East, equally lacks the key of the shareable

    Where established education has been oblique, perhaps the internet etc will afford sufficient 'connection' - conscience and courage

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 118.

    Weird beard Islamists can hardly be expected to encourage freedom & democratic practice. On the contrary, the Brotherhood's power grab says it all - in Mid East culture (outside Israel) it's all about imposing your will & getting others to lick your boots.

    The Mubarak era seems like a nice dream now - the Western media should be eternally ashamed of stirring up the anti-Mubarak street rabble.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 117.

    Elisa@115
    So sorry

    We seem 'play-things of the gods', local & lent, the more cruel because 'sent by God', in fact in Fear & Greed & Ignorance, mocking every 'prophet' half-worthy of exaltation

    Yet, there is 'The Word', a moral universe that beckons

    Alliance needed between those of moral vision, and all coming to see the logic of Equal Democracy, against chaos

    So sorry so little example here

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 116.

    Are we about to get an Islamist crescent in the Med - an Iron Burkah? When Syria falls hardline Islamists will take over. Egypt could follow. Tunisia is not far off. Libya, who knows. Algeria... it is not exactly safe and secure.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 115.

    Egypt continues to burn to the ground. Unemployment on the sharp rise as well as sexual assults on christian and muslim girls and women. We've seen and witnessed daily attacks on innocent coptic christians. Innocent christian and muslim protestors have been murdered through the streets of Cairo by extremists because they are defending freedom, social justice and democracy, free of sharia law.

 

Comments 5 of 119

 

More Middle East stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Cities and transport in 2050Transport in transit

    With global cities swelling, how will our systems cope and adapt in the future?

Programmes

  • A Cyprus beachFast Track Watch

    How the dream of a home in the sun was turned into a nightmare by the Cyprus banking crisis

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.