Hezbollah and allies topple Lebanese unity government

Energy Minister Gibran Bassil (centre) announces the resignations (12 January 2011) The resignations of more than a third of the ministers were required to bring down the cabinet

Related Stories

Lebanon's national unity government has collapsed after 11 ministers from Hezbollah and its allies resigned.

Energy Minister Gibran Bassil said the decision was prompted by a dispute over the UN tribunal investigating former Prime Minister Rafik Hariri's murder.

The announcement came as Prime Minister Saad Hariri, his son, was meeting US President Barack Obama in Washington.

Tension has been high in Lebanon, amid indications that Hezbollah members could be indicted by the UN tribunal.

On Tuesday, officials said efforts by the Syrian and Saudi Arabian governments to reach a political compromise had failed. The opposition has claimed that a potential deal was blocked by the US.

After meeting Mr Hariri, Mr Obama said the latest moves demonstrated Hezbollah's determination to block the government's work.

There are widespread fears that a collapse of the government could spark an outbreak of sectarian violence, last seen in Beirut in 2008.

Caretaker role

Under a power-sharing deal agreed in November 2009 to end five months of deadlock, the Shia Islamist movement Hezbollah was given two posts in the 30-member national unity government.

Analysis

The ministers who announced their departure from the government said they wanted to force the collapse of Saad Hariri's administration. The issue driving the political crisis is the UN Special Tribunal's anticipated indictment of members of Hezbollah for involvement in Rafik Hariri's killing. Hezbollah has said it will "cut the hand" of anyone who tries to arrest its members in connection with the case.

The timing of the ministers' resignation carried a message. As they spoke in Beirut, Mr Hariri was preparing to meet President Barack Obama in Washington. The departing ministers portrayed themselves as seeking a Lebanese solution to Lebanese problems. The question now is whether the differences between the parties will remain at a political level or spill over into physical violence.

Its allies - the Shia Amal movement and the bloc of the Maronite Christian leader and former general Michel Aoun - got another eight.

Mr Hariri's Sunni Future movement and its Maronite Christian and Druze allies, meanwhile, had 15 ministers in the cabinet.

The five remaining ministers were named by President Michel Suleiman.

The resignations of more than a third of the ministers were required to bring down the government.

On Wednesday, the 10 ministers allied to Hezbollah were joined by one of the president's appointees, Minister of State Adnan Sayyed Hussein, in announcing that they would resign and force the government's collapse.

Mr Hariri will now head a caretaker administration while the president consults parliamentary blocs to seek agreement on an acceptable new figure.

Mr Bassil, a member of the Christian Free Patriotic Movement, said the prime minister had rejected their demands for an urgent cabinet session to discuss withdrawing all co-operation with the UN-backed Special Tribunal for Lebanon (STL) and denouncing any indictments.

Start Quote

They think that by piling the pressure on him, that Hariri will bend, but they are mistaken”

End Quote Mohammad Rahhal Environment Minister

"The grace period has ended, and the waiting stage that we lived through without any result has ended," he told Reuters news agency.

Environment Minister Mohammed Rahhal, a member of the Future Movement, said the resignations were aimed at paralysing the state and forcing Mr Hariri to reject the authority of the tribunal investigating his father's murder, something he could not bring himself to do.

"They think that by piling the pressure on him, that Hariri will bend, but they are mistaken," he told the AFP news agency.

Other allies of the prime minister criticised Hezbollah for making the announcement coincide with his meeting with President Obama.

Mr Hariri made no comment after the talks at the White House, but officials said he planned to fly to Paris this evening to discuss the crisis with French President Nicolas Sarkozy before returning to Beirut.

A White House statement said President Obama had commended Mr Hariri for his "steadfast leadership and efforts to reach peace, stability and consensus in Lebanon under difficult circumstances".

"The efforts by the Hezbollah-led coalition to collapse the Lebanese government only demonstrate their own fear and determination to block the government's ability to conduct its business and advance the aspirations of all of the Lebanese people," it said.

Saad Hariri meets Barack Obama in Washington (12 January 2011) The announcement overshadowed Saad Hariri's meeting with President Obama

BBC Beirut correspondent Jim Muir says this is believed to be the first time in Lebanon's history that a government has been brought down by ministerial resignations rather than the prime minister himself deciding to call it a day.

This is a struggle over the regional balance of power, which was heavily in Washington's favour at the time the UN tribunal was established, but has now swung back in the direction of Syria, Iran and their local allies on the Lebanese stage, our correspondent says.

But, he adds, while bringing down the government is one thing, replacing it with another is something else.

At the moment, Mr Hariri's allies insist that only he should head any new government. So getting them to agree to someone closer to Syria and the Lebanese opposition will be very hard, our correspondent says.

President Suleiman will go through the motions to find a compromise candidate, but the consultations are likely to go round in circles as long as there is no agreement, and certainly there is none in sight, he adds.

Start Quote

Hezbollah's behaviour suggests it believes not only that the UN will accuse it, but that its charges could be detailed and credible”

End Quote Mark Urban Diplomatic Editor, BBC Newsnight

Rafik Hariri and 22 others were killed in February 2005 when a huge bomb exploded next to his motorcade in Beirut.

Syria was initially blamed for the assassination, and eventually forced in its wake to withdraw its troops from Lebanon after 29 years. In the past year, however, members of Hezbollah have emerged as prime suspects.

The Canadian broadcaster, CBC, reported in November that evidence gathered by the Lebanese police and the UN pointed "overwhelmingly to the fact that the assassins were from Hezbollah".

It published diagrams showing how investigators had traced interlinking networks of mobile phones from the vicinity of the blast that killed Rafik Hariri to Hezbollah's communications centre in south Beirut.

Hezbollah has rejected any suggestion of involvement in the assassination. Its leader, Hassan Nasrallah, has called the tribunal an "Israeli project" and warned of dire consequences if it indicts his followers.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Middle East stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.