Telecoms firm Nitel blames regulator for lay-offs

David Ezekiel David Ezekiel says his company can no longer compete with state-owned JT Global

Related Stories

A Jersey businessman fears his telecoms firm could go out of business in months because of the island's "anti-competitive" regulation.

David Ezekiel, owner of Nitel, said he has already laid off two members of staff.

He blamed Channel Islands competition regulator CICRA for allowing state-owned operator JT Global to retain exclusive use of Jersey's phone lines.

JT denied it acts improperly while CICRA said it is addressing the issues.

Since JT began selling the same phone systems as Nitel two years ago, Mr Ezekiel claims sales have dropped 40%.

'Turnover collapsed'

In an open letter to island politicians, Mr Ezekiel said: "Because JT retains the monopoly... all work carried out by Nitel has to be notified to JT as the network operator, with letters of authority from our clients.

What is CICRA doing?

  • On Tuesday, CICRA announced "wholesale line rental" for single phone lines would be introduced by 1 June 2015.
  • That means other operators should be able to use JT lines to serve single-line customers, typically domestic consumers
  • Critics say such changes happened decades ago in the UK and do not go far enough
  • Multi-line business users, for example, will not be covered
  • JT and CICRA, both government-owned bodies, recently engaged in a £200,000 court battle over CICRA's ultimately unsuccessful attempt to introduce wholesale line rental
  • CICRA says it is committed to creating more competition in Jersey telecoms

"This means that JT are always informed of our business dealings and over time our clients are now, almost invariably, offered cheaper arrangements by JT.

"In consequence our local business turnover has collapsed."

A JT spokesman said: "Our sales team is under strict instructions not to approach [Mr Ezekiel's] clients.

"We would just like to say once again, for the record, that we totally reject the accusations which Mr Ezekiel levels against us; JT has acted properly in all our dealings with him."

Gary Whipp, CEO of Newtel, a different company, said the biggest problem is that customers have no choice of service provider.

He said businesses and consumers are the biggest losers.

"If there was access to JT's infrastructure on a fair and equitable basis a lot of the customers here would be saving a lot of money.

"It's damaging to the customers' businesses and it is anti-competitive."

A spokesman for the regulator said: "CICRA is engaged in progressing a number of the matters, referred to in the letter circulated to States members, which are set out in CICRA's work programme.

"The outcome of those reviews will be published over the coming weeks and months."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Jersey


St Helier

8 °C 5 °C


Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.