Dispute over Jersey police office report
- 26 June 2012
- From the section Jersey
Jersey's government watchdog has rejected a call to take out part of a report on a failed deal to buy a new office building for the police.
The report said former Interim Treasurer Hugh McGarel-Groves suggested a way to remove a civil servant was to threaten his professional reputation.
Mr McGarel-Groves said the section was "far-fetched".
Comptroller and Auditor General Chris Swinson said he was confident about the evidence in the report.
Mr McGarel-Groves described the process used to write a report on the failure to buy Lime Grove House as "flawed".
In an e-mail to Mr Swinson, he described the section in the report where it is alleged he suggested the States of Jersey remove a senior civil servant by threatening to damage his reputation as "far fetched".
Mr Swinson responded: "I am confident of the evidence which formed the basis for the report."
He said he was "not aware of any reason to amend the report" and added that a draft of the report had been e-mailed to Mr McGarel-Groves before it was published, but there had been no response.
The owner of the proposed office site decided to lease it to a finance firm, so instead there are plans to build a new police office on part of Green Street car park.