Romania and Bulgaria migration issue divides Germans

Bulgarian Roma man Dimitar Todorov sits in his squat in Berlin, 4 December 2013 Bulgarian Roma man Dimitar Todorov was living in a squat in Berlin last month

It is not just the Brits who are arguing over migrants and what benefits they should receive. In Germany, the first political argument of the New Year and the first divisions within the new coalition have been over migrants.

At the first cabinet meeting of 2014 - on Wednesday - the issue of migrants has forced its way on to the agenda. Chancellor Angela Merkel - presumably on crutches after her skiing injury - is determined to attend.

In Britain the problem is defined as "benefits tourism". In Germany it is referred to as "poverty migration". The angst has been sparked by the lifting of work restrictions on Bulgarians and Romanians since 1 January. As in Britain, the gulf between what a worker on the minimum wage can receive in Germany and Bulgaria is huge. In Germany the minimum wage will deliver 836 euros (£706; $1,156) a month compared to just 150 in Bulgaria.

So to German politics and step forward Elmar Brok. He is a member of the European Parliament and belongs to Angela Merkel's Christian Democrat party, the CDU. He told Bild that "immigrants who only come to Germany [to obtain benefits] should be sent back to their country of origin". Just to ensure they did not return, he suggested they could be finger-printed. His comments infuriated Romanian Prime Minister Victor Ponta to the point that he accused him of having a "Nazi mind-set".

Then step forward Horst Seehofer, the leader of the CSU, also an ally and long-standing coalition partner of Angela Merkel. He suggested that those who abuse the benefits system should be expelled. He wants a three-month waiting period before migrants become eligible for welfare. Other conservative voices argued for payments to be restricted.

Emergency aid appeals

As in Britain, the opposition cannot avoid the debate. The new German Vice-Chancellor, Sigmar Gabriel, a Social Democrat, said: "We don't need all-out discrimination against the Bulgarians and Romanians but nor should we ignore the problems some big German cities faced with the immigration of poor peoples."

Last November 16 German cities sought emergency aid to help cope with migrants, pointing out that free movement of people had "far-reaching economic and social consequences".

The arguments have cut across party lines. Another conservative politician, Armin Laschet, said such ideas as finger-printing migrants "really don't fit into an open Europe".

So just as the Mayor of London, Boris Johnson, is calling for a two-year ban on migrants receiving benefits and Nigel Farage of UKIP is suggesting a five-year ban, Germany too is having its own debate.

All of this touches on much wider questions.

Germany, in its own way, is arguing over how much power should reside at the national level or go to the European Commission. In an interesting article, Der Spiegel quotes an unnamed adviser to Angela Merkel as saying that "only nation states can justify the reforms that are now truly necessary". Some people close to Angela Merkel are arguing for more Europe to integrate further the eurozone but that does not mean necessarily more Brussels.

It is a time in Europe, which will only intensify in the run-up to the European elections, when some of the defining features of the EU will be argued over and debated.

Gavin Hewitt, Europe editor Article written by Gavin Hewitt Gavin Hewitt Europe editor


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    The Romanian PM accusing German politico's of having a "Nazi mind-set" is disgraceful. It's the exactley the same as people shouting 'racist' over here to stifle discussion in their favour.

    When you throw open borders in a Union arrangement where the economies are so disparate what do you think is going to happen? I'm glad the Germans are discussing this, it is unfair on their people.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    sooner or later politicians will have to face up to the utter farce that is called free movement between EU countries. and like Nigel Farage said......its not just about money, even though the true cost of immigration probably outstrips the financial benefits. 75% of the British population cannot be ignored without serious consequences at the ballot box for anyone who treats them with comtempt

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    The argument that they shouldn't get benefits for 2 years is a valid one, people should not be allowed to enter any country unless they have a job to go to, to move over and claim from that countries benefit system is farcical, this should be for any country not just Romanians and Bulgarians. The claim benefit as soon as they get here and the host countries people paying for it is ridiculous.

  • rate this

    Comment number 10.

    It is way past time that we had an honest debate in Europe about the whole project and where it is going, because the divide between politicians and the people is enormous. Historically problems have been swept under the carpet but this is becoming less and less tenable. Europe has too many different meanings to different people.

  • rate this

    Comment number 28.

    Oh dear, EU coming undone in Germany as well?
    What is plainly obvious is that leaders of countries which are considered rich within the EU, are now being forced to listen to their people! In the UK, 77% want to see immigration curbs. Sadly, no national government can do much to curb the naive EU laws blocking the right to control our own borders. So where does that leave us?
    Anyone got a paddle?


Comments 5 of 166



  • A painting of the White House on fire by Tom FreemanFinders keepers

    The odd objects looted by the British from Washington in 1814

  • Chris and Regina Catrambone with their daughter Maria LuisaSOS

    The millionaires who rescue people at sea

  • Plane7 days quiz

    What unusual offence got a Frenchman thrown off a plane?

  • Children testing a bridge at a model-making summer school in Crawley, West SussexSeeding science Watch

    The retired professor who turned village children into engineers

  • Krouwa Erick, the doctor in Sipilou town at the border of Ivory Coast and Guinea - 27 August 2014Bad trip

    The Ebola journey no-one in Ivory Coast wants to take

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.