Russia plane crash: Pilot error suspected

Fire fighters and rescuers work at the crash site  The plane is reported to have struck the ground at about 450 km/h hour (280 mph)

Related Stories

Russian aviation experts say the pilots of a Boeing 737 jet that crashed in Kazan on Sunday carried out a manoeuvre that put the plane into a dive.

During a second attempt to land, the pilots switched to manual control and made a correction when the plane lost speed, the investigators said.

But the jet then nose-dived and crashed on to the tarmac, killing all 50 people on board.

According to the initial findings, the jet did not have any technical faults.

On-board recorder

The Interstate Aviation Committee (IAC), a body authorised to investigate civil air incidents in the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) comprising former Soviet countries, said that its preliminarily findings were that the crash was caused by pilot error.

Map

It said the two pilots failed to make a proper landing approach on the first attempt and then began a second run.

"Finding out that their attitude was not appropriate for landing, the crew started a go-around manoeuvre," the IAC said.

The report said the plane had lost speed in a steep climb then over-compensated, which sent it into a near-vertical dive.

The report drew its conclusions from data retrieved from one of the plane's on-board recorders, correspondents say, and the climb and subsequent plunge lasted only about one minute.

Analysis

Russia, combined with other ex-Soviet states, has some of the worst air safety records in the world, according to the International Air Transport Association (IATA). In 2011, the number of accidents for the region was triple the global average.

The body investigating plane crashes is the Interstate Aviation Committee (IAC), which operates on behalf of the governments of Russia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Ukraine and Uzbekistan.

In recent years, its conclusions following major accidents have almost invariably blamed the pilots. Ex-Soviet pilots are frequently overworked, poorly trained and having to fly unfamiliar aircraft.

However, critics have questioned the IAC's analyses, pointing to inconsistencies in its accounts of specific accidents.

They have also argued that being a supranational body, the IAC is effectively unaccountable and has a conflict of interest in that it also certifies the fit state of planes, airlines and airports.

Such "loss of control" accidents are responsible for more deaths than any other type of plane crash because they are rarely survivable, the US-based Flight Safety Foundation was quoted by the AP news agency as saying.

BBC regional analyst Pavel Fedenko says that in recent years the IAC's conclusions following major accidents have almost invariably blamed the pilots.

Critics have questioned its analyses pointing to inconsistencies, our correspondent adds .

The Boeing 737 was arriving from Moscow and crashed at about 19:20 local time (15:20 GMT) on Sunday.

It was raining at the time but the weather conditions were favourable for landing, officials say.

The fuel tanks exploded on impact and it took hours to extinguish the blazing wreckage.

Tatarstan Airlines said that both pilots were very experienced and no technical problems had been reported with the plane before the flight.

Airline head Taksan Giniyatullin told a news conference on Tuesday in Kazan that the flying experience of the two pilots ranged from 1,900 to 2,500 hours - and that they had undergone "all the necessary instruction".

But he said that the crew apparently had no experience with attempting a second landing.

Reports said the pilot, 47-year-old Rustem Salikhov, had already tried to land several times before crashing.

The crew also said that they were not ready to land because of technical problems, Russian news agencies reported.

A journalist who said she had flown on the same aircraft from Kazan to Moscow earlier on Sunday told Russia's Channel TV that there was a strong vibration during the landing in the Russian capital.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Europe stories

RSS

Features

  • OrangemanPunctured pride?

    How would N Ireland's Orangemen feel if Scotland left the union?


  • Sheep on Achill IslandMass exodus

    Why hundreds of thousands of people have left Ireland


  • MarchionessThames tragedy

    Survivors and victims' families remember Marchioness disaster


  • A teenaged mother in the Zaatari campUntold misery

    The plight of Syria's refugee child brides


  • Michael MosleyMeat feast?

    Which is the best eco option - eating beef, chicken or mussels?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.