Europe's discontent

Italian navy video grab on 13 October 2013 shows immigrants frisked by crew members of a ship after being rescued from the sea off the Italian island of Lampedusa Hostility to EU migrants seems to have become entrenched in the bloc's biggest economies

The election campaign for the European Parliament has begun. It is not that hopeful candidates are already making their pitches to the voters, but the political battleground for next May's contest is being shaped.

The elections will be fought against a background of Europe's discontent. That was underlined yet again at the weekend when a poll for the Financial Times found that "hostility to EU migrants seeking work and benefits is now entrenched in the bloc's biggest economies".

And on the question of whether the EU would do better with fewer powers, two-thirds of Britons agreed but, more surprisingly, so did half of Germans and nearly half of Spanish voters.

Start Quote

Europe's leaders are currently in a race against time, hoping that economic conditions will improve fast enough before an anti-reform and anti-EU backlash undermines the whole single currency project”

End Quote Nicholas Spiro Spiro Sovereign Strategy

A few weeks ago, a poll for Debating Europe found a majority of Europeans believe that the austerity measures pursued since the start of the crisis have failed.

A few months earlier, the Pew Institute discovered that approval ratings for the EU and its institutions have fallen sharply - in almost every country except Germany. In France, only 41% had a favourable view of the EU, which was less than the UK.

The political consensus behind the European project is fracturing. It is quite possible that come next May, 170 MEPs out of a total of 751 will be broadly questioning of or even hostile towards the European establishment.

The main reason for Europe's discontent is the economy. Even though the acute phase of the eurozone crisis has passed, next year, three of the five largest economies in Europe, according to the IMF, will register tepid growth at best.

"Europe's leaders are currently in a race against time, hoping that economic conditions will improve fast enough before an anti-reform and anti-EU backlash undermines the whole single currency project," says Nicholas Spiro of Spiro Sovereign Strategy.

But economic insecurity is fuelling unease over immigration and migration between EU countries. Anti-establishment parties are tapping into this wider disquiet and voters no longer necessarily believe the Commission's interpretation of figures.

Unpopular compromise
Leonarda Dibrani sits at her home in the town of Mitrovica on 16 October 2013 Leonarda Dibrani was detained whilst on a school trip in France and later deported to Kosovo

The political sensitivity of all this was in full display at the weekend in France, with the government and the president twisting and turning over the case of 15-year-old Leonarda Dibrani.

She had been detained whilst on a school trip and later deported to Kosovo after her family had failed to win asylum. The expulsion of Leonarda had brought "les jeunes" (the youth) on to the streets in protest.

French President Francois Hollande, facing pressure from all sides, came up with a formula that satisfied almost no-one. He said that Leonarda could return to school in eastern France on the condition she come back alone without her family.

The president was accused of splitting families, but instant polls revealed that two-thirds of the French public do not want Leonarda to return. The government, in taking a robust stance, is aware of the growing support for the right-wing National Front.

Much attention has recently been focused on the tragic journeys of migrants crossing from Africa to the Italian island of Lampedusa. My colleagues have been monitoring the speed with which arrivals now move through Europe.

In Italy, where they are supposed to be processed, many are allowed to travel north without having been fingerprinted and without documents.

Rules are bent or ignored in the hope that migrants will move north to places like Sweden where they will get a better welcome. The aim is to make the new arrivals disappear off the news agendas as soon as possible.

Turn back the page?

Start Quote

The reality is that there is no going back to autonomous national policies for the economy or migration”

End Quote Heather Grabbe and Stefan Lehne Centre for European Reform

Polls suggest deep disapproval of Romanian and Bulgarian citizens being able from next January to work in any member state and yet that is one of the EU's main freedoms.

In a thoughtful essay on the European elections for the Centre for European Reform, Heather Grabbe and Stefan Lehne recognise that the European Parliament is still not "accepted as an essential party of the body politic".

They understand the call for democratic legitimacy, but do not believe the answer lies in allowing the parliament's political groupings to essentially nominate the next head of the European Commission.

They argue that not only could it lead to a partisan president, but that it will not cut much ice with the voters.

They suggest the election campaign should focus on what the EU has done well, the single market, freedom to travel, etc. They would like to see the argument of the anti-establishment parties confronted head-on.

"The reality is that there is no going back to autonomous national policies for the economy or migration," the authors say.

They want to remind voters that "going back" would lead to higher prices and make travel more difficult.

So the battleground is being prepared. The European establishment is determined to make the election about the future of Europe. They will ask voters to decide whether they want to turn back the page and to sacrifice what has been achieved.

Ranged against them will be parties who will argue that austerity has led to mass poverty in southern Europe, that budgets and policies are being set by remote masters and that Brussels is insensitive to fears about migration and immigration.

The months ahead will see fierce debates about the future of the European project.

Gavin Hewitt, Europe editor Article written by Gavin Hewitt Gavin Hewitt Europe editor

Anti-Semitism comes back to haunt Europe

Politicians and Jewish leaders voice alarm at a resurgence of anti-Semitism in Europe amid clashes in Gaza.

Read full article

More on This Story

Migrant tragedy


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 151.

    When a BBC story is open to comments and mentions the EU, the comments turn immediately into British nationalistic Europe-bashing.

    Please, messieurs les Anglais - leave Europe if you must, but give us back our excellent BBC debates!

    Provided the next UKIP government does not ban us foreigners from them!

  • rate this

    Comment number 194.

    "hostility to EU migrants seeking work and benefits is now entrenched in the bloc's biggest economies".

    Can't think why, can you? Given that the detoxified Nice Tory party in the UK is sending out "Go Home" vans and texts, yet taking the begging bowl to China. No double standards from our decent Tory led govt then? Contains the Literal Doormats who wanted to give amnesty to all at one time.

  • rate this

    Comment number 199.

    #196 U157....

    "do you hold that all cultures are equal ? well they are not, "

    --what the heck is that supposed to mean ?

    --How inferior are you with resect to Bulgarians and Romanians ?

    (Scale 1-10 please)

  • rate this

    Comment number 192.

    "Europe needs to follow Australia's policy on these troublesome migrants.."

    Surely the most ironic statement ever uttered on these pages.

    If europe were to follow the Australian example, every European citizen will automatically lose their legal status as a human being, and within a few generations the genocide will be complete.

    White power is not harmony.

  • rate this

    Comment number 163.

    149 violet

    "EU . leaving many voters disenfranchised and without a representative voice"

    Because of our 2-party system and living in a constituency that has always voted Conservative I have been disenfranchised for over 40 years. I feel I am better represented by the EU elections

    157 mod

    "UKIP will win the 2014 Euro elections"

    GROAN! That will make us even more of a laughing stock


Comments 5 of 287



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.