Abstract Christmas tree sparks protests in Brussels


Brussels' controversial Christmas tree in action

Related Stories

Thousands of people have signed a petition against an abstract light installation replacing the traditional Christmas tree in Brussels city centre.

More than 11,000 signatures have been gathered in the online petition and a Facebook page attacking the new feature has been launched.

Critics accuse officials of opting for the installation for fear of offending non-Christians, especially Muslims.

But the mayor's office said it was part of a theme this year of "light".

Start Quote

We know we are living in a country with a Christian culture, we take no offence over a traditional Christmas tree”

End Quote Semsettin Ugurlu Belgian Muslim Executive

Traditionally, a 20m (65ft) pine tree taken from the forests of the Ardennes has adorned the city's central square, the Grand Place.

This year, it has been replaced with a 25m (82ft) construction, though smaller real Christmas trees still decorate the square, a spokesman at the mayor's office said.

The city's website said the new "tree" was one of five "light" installations around the Grand Place this year, offering visitors the chance to climb to the top and enjoy "beautiful views" of the city.

Tourism councillor Philippe Close at the mayor's office said the aim was to show off the "avant-garde character" of Brussels by blending the modern and the traditional, to produce something new and different.


Brussels hosts one of the most popular winter markets in Europe and many are worried that the contemporary construction is incongruous with the 17th-Century buildings that surround it, the BBC's Maddy Savage reports from the city.

The light installation has even been nicknamed The Pharmacy by some who say the glowing cubes resemble the green cross symbol you find outside many chemists around the world.

Bianca Debaets, a Brussels councillor from the Christian Democratic and Flemish party, said she believed a "misplaced argument" over religious sensitivities had moved Brussels to put up the light sculpture.

"For a lot of people who are not Christians, the tree there is offensive to them," she told reporters.

Erik Maxwell, from Brussels, told BBC News: "We think the tree has been put up for cultural reasons.

"A tree is for Christmas and Christians but now there are a lot of Muslims here in Brussels. So to avoid discussions they have just replaced a tree with a couple of cubes! I am more traditional, I prefer the usual tree. That's better for the Belgian people."

A recent estimate in the Belgian newspaper Le Soir suggested Muslims made up 22% of the population of Brussels and its region as of 2010.

'Pleasure of winter'

Parts of the Belgian press have been keen to suggest that the tree is an example of "political correctness", designed to be more appealing to non-Christian religious groups than a traditional fir tree, our correspondent says.

However it seems likely that the media storm is influencing public opinion rather than reflecting it.

There was applause and plenty of oohs and aahs in the square at a preview of the nightly sound-and-light show that will take place there until the New Year, our correspondent reports, adding that the enthusiasm suggests some sceptics have been won over.

"What we want is just to modernise the pleasure of winter, of this Christmas market and all the image of Brussels," said Councillor Philippe Close.

"The Christmas tree is not a religious symbol and actually lots of Muslims have a Christmas tree at home.

"For people who want a traditional religious symbol, we have the nativity scene here in the square. For people who want modernity, we have this new tree."

Semsettin Ugurlu, chairman of the Belgian Muslim Executive, representing the Muslim community in Belgium, said his organisation did not mind any kind of Christmas tree.

"We know we are living in a country with a Christian culture, we take no offence over a traditional Christmas tree," he said.

Miryam Oostling, a visitor from Leeuwarden in the Netherlands, told the BBC: "I quite like the tree. It's a piece of modern art. It's cosy!"


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    The Christmas tree never had anything to do with Christianity in the first place, so I don't see any valid objection there. However, the fact that it is hideous and looks like a meccano project gone wrong must offend offend anybody with a sense of visual perspective.

  • rate this

    Comment number 14.

    The whole Christianity/Islam argument seems very tacked on here, trying to turn a non-story into something more controversial. Personally I'm not in favour of this particular tree - not because it's too Christian, not because it's non-traditional, just because it's a bit sterile. It's a minor aesthetic issue, not a religious war.

  • rate this

    Comment number 15.

    What on earth has this do with Muslims or Islam........ the truth is however, what has Christianity got to do with Xmas trees. Nothing at all.

  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    What is wrong with a traditional christmas tree; why does it have to be something which portrays a christmas tree? Modernism is for people who like to move forward with art - a Christmas tree is a Christmas tree - leave it alone!

  • rate this

    Comment number 139.

    As a permanent resident in Brussels, I find this decision to replace the Christmas tree as totally unwise. The tree added to the festive mood, gave the Grand Place a very special atmosphere at Xmas. Why do authorities tinker with unnecessary, uncalled for changes? Tourism will suffer as a consequence. Situated at the heart of a vibrant city, the Grand Place has always appealed to tourists galore.


Comments 5 of 395


More Europe stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.