Turkey talks tough over Syria

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan addresses the lawmakers of his Justice and Development Party at the parliament in Ankara, 26 June 2012 Our friendship is powerful, but so is our anger, Mr Erdogan told lawmakers

Turkey's prime minister has told parliament that Syria is a "clear threat" to both its own people and to Turkey, days after a Turkish fighter jet was downed. But to what extent will Ankara's approach to its neighbour really change?

In today's Turkey the final word always belongs to Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

He stayed uncharacteristically silent in the days following the incident, but has now delivered a speech to his party in parliament, which will probably shape Turkish policy towards Syria from now on.

Mr Erdogan aimed at several targets in his speech.

The first was to win as much international support as possible for the official Turkish account of the incident.

He restated that view: that the F-4 Phantom was unarmed, clearly identifiable, and, after briefly entering Syrian air space, was back in international air space when it was shot down without warning.

Nobody can use such a brief incursion as justification for shooting down a plane, he said.

Turkey has mustered all the data it has from the plane's flight, and used it to convince its allies of its case.

'New phase'

Britain and the United States have expressed support for the Turkish position, and, after an extraordinary meeting on the incident in Brussels, so has Nato.

Turkish F-4 Phantom jet (file) The search continues for the F-4 plane shot down on Friday and its crew of two

Syria has continued to contest the Turkish account, insisting that the aircraft was flying low and fast, close to the Syrian coast, when they fired at it.

A Syrian foreign ministry official said the plane was hit by land-based anti-aircraft guns with a range of only one to two kilometres, not by a missile, to back its assertion that it was well within Syrian air space.

Mr Erdogan also needed to look strong to his own people, given the fact that Turkey has no way of making good its threat to "punish" Syria.

Military retaliation is too risky. It has not been mentioned at all by Turkey, and has been dismissed as inappropriate by its allies.

Instead the prime minister resorted to some tough-sounding, feel-good rhetoric. No-one should be fooled by our cool-headed and reasonable response to this crisis, he said.

Our friendship is powerful, but so is our anger.

He described the government of Bashar al-Assad as a clear threat now not just to the Syrian people but also to Turkey, and warned that relations have entered a new phase.

'Harsh words'

Turkish account

  • Friday 22 June, early morning: F-4 leaves Erhac Nato airbase
  • Flies over Hatay province (Turkey)
  • 11:42 GMT: mistakenly enters Syrian airspace near Latakia at 200ft (61m) at 300 knots
  • 11:47: leaves after Turkish radar operator warning - no Syrian warning
  • 11:56: radio contact lost: hit 13 nautical miles from Syrian coast at 7,400ft by heat-seeking or laser-guided missile
  • 11:58 crashes into the sea

From now on, he warned, any Syrian forces approaching the border would be treated as hostile and may be targeted by the Turkish military.

Mr Erdogan has clearly been stung by the small but increasing number of critics here of his foreign policy, and he fired back at them with a sweeping justification for his government's approach to the region.

Referring back to 1,000 years of Ottoman history, he said Turkey's security was tied up with that of the wider region.

We have no territorial ambitions in neighbouring countries, he said, but we will always raise our voice on behalf of brothers whose blood is being shed - we will be a torment for those who hurt the innocent. No-one should fear a stronger Turkey that is re-embracing its historic friends.

There were particularly harsh words for those Turkish writers who have questioned what the F4 jet was doing so close to the sensitive Syrian border.

Syrian account

  • 11:40 GMT Friday: F-4 flew at 100m (330 ft) altitude, 1-2km (0.6m-1.2m) from Syrian coast
  • Surprise meant no time to give warning
  • Anti-aircraft gun shot it down in Syrian waters with fire of maximum range of 2.5km
  • Radar-guided missile not deployed
  • Tail wreckage shows it was hit by anti-aircraft fire

No-one, he said, could take the luxury of making statements that would damage the Turkish government or state at this time - the Turkish people would punish them.

He repeated the official explanation that the plane was testing Turkish radar systems and carrying out routine surveillance of the eastern Mediterranean, which he said was a sovereign right.

That last attack will not go down well with those who already charge Mr Erdogan of intolerance of any criticism. And questions surrounding the precise mission of the downed F-4 will not go away.

Cautious

There will also be some doubts over how much Turkish policy will really change towards Syria.

Mr Erdogan has used dramatic language to condemn President Assad many times in the past, but Turkish policy has remained cautious. It hosts the Syrian National Council, and some commanders of the Free Syrian Army.

But it has until now blocked or restricted arms supplies to Syrian insurgents over its border, and banned attacks on Syrian forces from Turkish territory.

It is possible Turkey will now give greater backing to the armed opposition.

Already the prime minister's foreign policy adviser has stated that the rules of engagement for Turkish troops towards their Syrian counterparts have been changed.

Alleged flightpath of downed Turkish F-4 Phantom

 map

1. F-4 Phantom takes off from Erhac airbase, Turkey, at approximately 10:28 local time (07:28 GMT), on 22 June

2. Syria says the jet enters its airspace at 11:40 (08:40 GMT)

3. Turkish military loses contact with the plane at 11:58 (08:58 GMT), while it is over Hatay province

4. Syria says its air defences engaged aircraft about 1km (0.5 nautical miles) from the coast and that it crashed into the sea 10km (5 nautical miles) west of Om al-Tuyour. Turkey says the plane was 24km (13 nautical miles) from Syria, which under international law is considered international airspace

More on This Story

Syria's war War in Syria

More Europe stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.