Greece election: Temporary relief for eurozone

 
Antonis Samaras, the leader of the conservative New Democracy party, on election night 17 Jun 12 Antonis Samaras faces a new round of tough coalition negotiations

You could almost hear the sighs of relief coming out of Brussels and Berlin when the results from the Greek election were finally established.

One fact stood out above all others from a chaotic and confusing night: Greece, in the short term, would not be leaving the euro with all the chaos that would flow from it. Central bankers and European finance ministers, who had been on standby, could relax just a little.

Like so much in the eurozone, a step is taken that buys time but little more. The winner was Antonis Samaras, the leader of the conservative New Democracy party. He defined the election as a choice between staying in the euro or returning to the drachma. Despite that stark choice only 40% of voters backed parties that supported the bailout deal with the EU and the IMF.

The message from Greece was once more that they wanted to stay in the euro but not at the price of the austerity measures they were enduring.

The outcome does not offer stability to Greece. Waiting in the wings will be a new powerful opposition leader, Alexis Tsipras. This leftist radical got 27% of the vote by promising to tear up the bailout agreement, even whilst insisting he wanted to stay in the euro.

Shortly after the results Mr Samaras said he wanted to build a government of national unity. But Alexis Tsipras wanted nothing to do with it. His calculation is that this new coalition government will last just a few months. Last night he told his supporters: "very soon the left will be in power". And, for good measure, he repeated a message that found such resonance with the voters: "overthrowing the bailout was the only solution". He sounds like a politician not unhappy to be on the sidelines for a short period.

More hard bargaining

Mr Samaras's first priority will be to form a convincing coalition. He will get the support of Pasok, the Greek socialists. That coalition, in itself, brings with it problems. They are the two parties that have governed Greece for the past 30 years and are blamed for many of the country's problems.

Bailout deal - Greek pledges

  • Cut 15,000 state sector jobs this year - aiming for 150,000 to be cut by 2015
  • Cut minimum wage by 22%, to about 600 euros a month
  • Pension cut worth 300m euros this year
  • Spending cuts of more than 3bn euros this year
  • Liberalise labour laws to make hiring and firing easier
  • Boost tax collection
  • Carry out privatisations worth 50bn euros by end of 2015
  • Open up more professions to competition, eg in health, tourism and real estate
  • Greece aims to cut its debt burden to 116% of GDP by 2020

Once he has formed a government his immediate challenge is the bailout agreement. Although he accepted the basic terms of the deal he insisted during the campaign that he wanted concessions. It should be remembered that when Pasok was in power he opposed many of the austerity measures, saying that what Greece needed was growth.

If he is confirmed in power he will have a stronger opposition breathing down his neck. He will say to Europe that he has anchored Greece in the eurozone and wants something in return. That will be difficult. Already the German Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle has come out and said that the substance of the Greek reform (bailout) programme is non-negotiable.

Where there might be some flexibility is over the timing of the implementation of reforms. There may also be some movement over interest rates on the loans and the EU might offer Greece some funds to boost growth.

But the message is clear - the austerity programme with its budget and spending cuts will stay. The German finance minister underlined that message when he said "Greece's path will be neither short nor easy".

And therein lies the instability. The Greek economy is in freefall. The country is in the fifth year of recession. Unemployment is at 22%. Real wages - for many people - are down by 25%. The streets bear the scars of social breakdown. The country does not have much time.

What happens in Greece will be influenced by the outcome of the current tension between France and Germany.

Hollande growth agenda

The French President, Francois Hollande, will be emboldened by his victory in the French parliamentary elections. His Socialist party controls the Elysee Palace and parliament. The French view is that "Europeans need to help Greeks return to growth".

Mr Hollande will push hard for his growth first agenda. He wants more flexibility on meeting deficit targets. He wants a European banking union that contains a joint deposit guarantee scheme. He is pushing a 120bn-euro (£97bn; $152bn) growth covenant for Europe. Chancellor Merkel is cautious as usual. In recent days there have been several warnings from Berlin that Germany cannot take on all of Europe's debts.

And then it should not be forgotten - Greece had the ability to spark a severe crisis.

But the future of the eurozone will be determined by what happens in Italy and Spain. And here two fundamental questions remain unanswered. If those economies get into difficulty what will stand behind them, how will they be supported? And - perhaps most importantly - where will growth come from to relieve two countries mired in recession? Without those answers the can is still just being kicked down the road.

 
Gavin Hewitt Article written by Gavin Hewitt Gavin Hewitt Europe editor

Scotland's vote weighs on Europe

A Scottish Yes vote would pose a big challenge to EU membership rules, Europe editor Gavin Hewitt writes.

Read full article

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 133.

    98 Grant Collier

    You could say that the predictions of some contributors on this forum are coming true in that Americans are taking over the world.

    But this report indicates that space rather than power is the key word.

    If they all ate less not only would they help conserve the world's resources but we would also see less of them!

  • rate this
    +9

    Comment number 129.

    120 LucyJ
    "In choosing the Euro over Europeans Europeans put money over people European debt crisis is the result"

    Odd how Americans hold the strong belief that Anne Coulter's hogwash makes a dent even on European opinion making

  • rate this
    +9

    Comment number 1.

    The Greek people have decided - they dont want any more austerity because it does not work and will disable the economy. The coalition will be governing without the support of the large majority of the Greek people so will not last its term.

  • rate this
    +9

    Comment number 5.

    Most people know the Euro will fail, this is again just delaying the inevitable and making the pain of the process worse. Just admit you got it wrong and revert back to your original currencies before you suffocate the whole European economy.

  • rate this
    +8

    Comment number 79.

    In large part what is going on is psychological, not financial. Italy need not be in trouble. Its deficit is quite good, it just has a big debt. It also needs to reform its economy but there's no need to do it immediately

    Similarly with the other nations in 'trouble'. If the players believed that others in the market would stay in, so would they

    It's the Prisoner's Dilemma writ very large

 

Comments 5 of 333

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.