Dinner in Brussels - jobs, growth and break-up on the menu

Francois Hollande and Angela Merkel at the Nato summit in Chicago, 21 May 2012 The relationship between Francois Hollande and Angela Merkel is getting a lot of attention

It might only be an informal dinner but this is the 18th time in the past two years that Europe's leaders have gathered in Brussels.

The menu might have changed but the agenda has not: to fix a crisis threatening the future of the euro and the world economy.

Never has the pressure been greater. The once taboo subject of the eurozone breaking up is openly discussed.

Already plans are being drawn up as to how such a break-up could be "managed".

Britain's Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, said the eurozone was at a "critical point".

The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) warns of a "severe recession" in the zone.

President Obama has been twisting arms - much to the irritation of some of Europe's leaders.

Jobs and growth

What the markets want to know is who and what stands behind this currency in the final resort. There is currently no answer to this.

The dinner only underscores the difficulty of taking decisive action.

The agenda is jobs and growth.

Until recently the emphasis in Europe was on austerity, on driving down deficits.

Many say that policy has failed; that it has driven weaker countries into a cycle of decline.

It is now forecast that Greece faces a sixth year of recession.

Both Italy and Spain - currently in recession - are expected to see their economies shrink next year too.

It is the arrival of Francois Hollande as French President that has forced growth up the agenda.

It was being debated before. David Cameron energetically pushed ideas for growth at a summit in March.

But Francois Hollande directly challenged the German narrative during his election campaign.

His priority is growth and the early signs are that he will not back away from that - particularly with parliamentary elections due in June.

Person voting in Greece, 6 May 2012 Greece's future will be decided when the country holds a new election on 17 June
Long term view

He said he wants no taboos when it comes to tonight's meeting. So he will raise the idea of eurobonds - a sharing of the debt burden.

If all countries stand behind eurozone debt then the borrowing costs for most countries will fall although they will edge higher for Germany.

At least for now Germany remains implacably opposed to the idea.

It sees it as removing the incentive for countries to get their finances in order.

Yesterday German officials were briefing that they will not bend on this.

The Austrian finance minister described the French plan as "nonsense".

Other measures may be easier to agree on: deploying unused EU structural funds to support growth, boosting the capital of the European Investment Bank to help small businesses, backing a trial project to invest in infrastructure, expanding the single market.

The problem is that the impact of these ideas lies in the long term.

The German view is that growth will best come through tough reforms, freeing up the labour markets.

The French disagree. They favour spending on infrastructure projects and quickly.

The Germans have a red line; they will oppose increasing debt to stimulate the economy.

A German minister told me in Berlin last week "if we go down that road we have learnt nothing".


Much attention will focus on the relationship between the German chancellor and the new French president.

It was a rather edgy first encounter last week. Both of them know that come the major summit in June they have to be on the same side.

Crowds of protesters in Germany, 11 May 2012  Germany's IG Metall union organised protests earlier this month calling for pay rises

Angela Merkel is not isolated. The Austrians, the Dutch, the Finns and others are with her. But she no longer commands the stage.

In his corner Francois Hollande has the Italians, the Spanish and David Cameron. (What the British want is a much larger rescue fund - the so-called firewall, a massive recapitalising of the banks, and for Germany to stand behind the currency).

The Germans are not inflexible. Recently they have agreed to larger wage settlements.

Their largest union, IG Metall, has just agreed to a 4.3% pay rise for nearly three million workers.

That should increase demand for goods from outside Germany.

The German finance minister has accepted that the country can cope with some more inflation.

The Germans will support new growth measures but they want countries to stick to the targets for reducing their deficits.

That includes France. One of their fears is that France requests an extra year to bring its deficit down to 3%.

If that happens other countries will surely follow.

And then there is Greece.

The official line is that Athens must accept the terms of the bailout deal - including the austerity measures - or "face the consequences".

Everyone will be looking to see whether there are hints that the bailout terms could be softened in the future but the expectation is that the message to Greece will not change.

It is a dinner tonight where no firm decisions will be taken.

It is a curtain raiser for a much more important two day summit in June.

By then Greece will have made its choice and the Spanish banks will have demonstrated whether they need outside help.

Europe could already be a different place.

Gavin Hewitt Article written by Gavin Hewitt Gavin Hewitt Europe editor

Greek crisis deepens amid EU tensions

As time pressures mount, a deal to settle the Greek bailout crisis still hangs in the balance.

Read full article

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 316.

    @301 Danaos
    implying Russia actually gets credit at the same or lower rate as Germany.

  • rate this

    Comment number 315.

    301 Danaos
    "By the way, Russia has offered to lent Greece at the same rate Germany gets."

    We wish you luck. Hope they treat you better than their other 'allies' or Chechnians.
    And by the way, their free spending tourists aren't exactly very welcome in Europe today - they are known to treat the locals with contempt.

  • rate this

    Comment number 314.

    @305 Russian bases? For what, Black Sea Fleet? I was in Sevastopol last year and saw that sorry excuse for a fleet. Most ships had huge weed growth on their anchor chains, clearly indicating that they hadn't left port for months if not years- perhaps not since Rasputin's terror assault on Georgia in 2008. Part of old BSF is now Ukrainian, part Russian, most scrap(ped). Little new construction.

  • rate this

    Comment number 313.

    @287 I can only repeat what our finance minister told parliament: Holland was borrowing at its low interest rate and lending this money to Greece at an interest rate well below the unsustainable rates that Greece would have to pay on the open market. As I understand it, other EZ countries were doing the same.

  • rate this

    Comment number 312.

    mh: "Oh and Hewlet-Packard is shedding 27 000 jobs. Chickens coming home to roost?"

    Margaret,sorry, but you know about IT industry about as much as you now about military matters.

    There's hardly any money to be made in PC manufacturing (even Chinese can build them - from foreign components). HP's made a right decision; just like IBM did dumping their unprofitable PC business on PRC. Lenovo


Comments 5 of 316



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.