State election deals blow to Germany's Merkel

The SPD's Hannelore Kraft, 13 May The SPD's Hannelore Kraft celebrates with supporters

Related Stories

Chancellor Angela Merkel's conservatives have suffered heavy losses in an election in Germany's most populous state.

Support for the Christian Democrats dropped from 35% to 26% in North Rhine-Westphalia, with the Social Democrats set to return to power with the Greens.

It is the Christian Democrats' worst result in the state.

Analysts say many voters rejected Mrs Merkel's tough line on fiscal discipline as a cure for state debt.

Voters in Greece, France and Italy also recently rejected austerity policies.

In another development, Germany's Pirate Party won seats in North Rhine-Westphalia, making it their fourth state parliament.

The Pirate Party has grown in strength recently with its calls for transparency and internet freedom.

Nationally, Sunday's election will not change the balance of power, whatever the outcome, but opposition leaders warn it may send an important signal ahead of national elections expected in late 2013.

Left out

Official results give the Social Democrats (SPD) 39.1%, the Christian Democrats (CDU) 26.3%, the Greens 11.3%, the Free Democrats (FDP) 8.6%, the Pirates 7.8% and the Left, 2.5%, reported AP news agency.


The elections may worry Chancellor Merkel. The big decline of the vote for the Christian Democrats indicates strong dismay at the policies of her party. In national opinion polls, she - personally - remains popular, but her party, on the strength (or lack of it) of the vote in North Rhine-Westphalia does not.

Furthermore, much of the election was fought on public spending, with the Social Democratic Party asserting its importance, particularly for education. Its share of the vote increased.

There were also signs of resentment within Germany. Some local politicians complained, for example, that swimming pools in their towns in the West of Germany were being closed for lack of money while high spending continued in the old East Germany.

Chancellor Merkel may draw hope or despair from the strong showing of the Pirate Party. With 8% of the vote, it now gets seats in a fourth regional parliament in Germany. Their rise probably threatens the left parties more - but it also signals a disgruntlement with mainstream politics.

The FDP, the CDU's national coalition partner, performed better than expected, increasing their vote by nearly two percentage points and thereby giving the lie to speculation that they might fail to win seats.

The Left, which won 11 seats at the last election in 2010, failed to pass the 5% threshold and are out of the state parliament.

When the CDU and FDP recently lost elections in the northern state of Schleswig-Holstein, Mrs Merkel's party scored its lowest tally there for 50 years.

North Rhine-Westphalia has a history of influencing national politics.

An early election was called in March after the minority SPD-Green government narrowly failed to get a budget passed.

During the election campaign, state premier and SPD candidate Hannelore Kraft emphasised strengthening indebted local communities, investing in education and boosting the state's business appeal.

Her CDU rival, Norbert Roettgen, who is also Mrs Merkel's environment minister, accused the SPD of financial irresponsibility, and held rallies dominated by a huge inflatable "debt mountain", to emphasise the state's problems.

He provoked controversy early in the campaign by refusing to commit to being a full-time opposition leader if he lost. Such a move would cost him his job in Berlin.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Europe stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.