Greece: The moment of truth

 
Protester outside parliament in Athens 26 June 2011 Protesters threaten to encircle parliament to prevent deputies from voting

ATHENS For months there have been protests in Greece. Hardly a day has passed without strikes.

There is rising resentment at a recession that only seems to deepen. They have had a year of austerity and now the Greek people are being asked to endure a second of cuts and tax increases. All the signs are that the Greeks have reached a limit.

Last year 400,000 jobs were lost. Almost every street in Athens has boarded-up shops where owners cannot pay their loans. The despair and bitterness are palpable.

For this year an extra 6.5bn euros (£5.8bn) in cuts needs to be found. The middle class will face a solidarity tax. The threshold at which Greeks start paying tax will drop from 12,000 euros to 8,000 euros. The self-employed will be hit with a tax levy.

By 2015 a total of 28bn euros of savings have been earmarked. A fifth of civil service jobs are set to disappear and 50bn euros must be found from privatisations.

Over the next two days MPs are to debate and vote on these austerity measures. If they vote "yes" then Greece will qualify for an emergency loan of 12bn euros (£10.7bn) from the EU and the IMF.

Start Quote

Everything hangs in the balance. In the meantime much of the economy - with the exception of tourism and some exports - is unravelling”

End Quote

One bit of good news for Greece is that French banks have agreed to roll over some of Greek debt. Other banks may follow.

If the MPs vote "no" then Greece is heading for bankruptcy in mid-July and the eurozone will be thrown into turmoil. George Soros warned the other day: "Let's face it, we're on the edge of an economic collapse."

The Greek people have been told this is a historic decision. The future of the country is at stake. On the eve of the debate the Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou said it was a "unique opportunity to keep the country on its feet".

But the people no longer seem to see it that way. Polls suggest that between 70% and 80% oppose the austerity plan.

So does the opposition. They have said "we cannot support a policy that deepens the recession". Indeed the government has not answered the question as to why more austerity will work when it failed the first time round.

Even the new Finance Minister, Evangelos Venizelos, described the new measures as "tough and in many respects unfair", but he added that was the only way to complete negotiations with the country's new paymasters - the EU and the IMF.

The unions have called a 48-hour general strike. This is a now or never moment for them and they have called hundreds of thousands of activists on to the streets.

Police from all over Greece have been summoned to the capital. On Wednesday protesters threaten to encircle parliament to prevent the deputies from voting. Quite simply this is a trial of strength played out on the streets of Athens.

On paper the prime minister should win.

Closed shops in Athens Greek economic hardship is reflected in the rising numbers of boarded-up shops

He has a majority in the parliament but he has doubts. Several deputies have come under fierce pressure in their constituencies to vote no.

That uncertainty has been communicated to Europe's capitals.

When I asked UK Prime Minister David Cameron at a press conference last week whether he believed in giving more money to Greece he said it was wise - particularly for banks - "to prepare for all eventualities".

German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble has sounded a similar note. In Brussels there is talk of officials working on emergency funding that might help Greece get through July whilst further negotiations take place. If correct, it would be a classic EU fudge.

Everything hangs in the balance. In the meantime much of the economy - with the exception of tourism and some exports - is unravelling.

Greek banks lost 8% of their private sector customer deposits this year. I have met several people who are moving their funds outside Greece.

Even with a "yes" vote in the parliament there have to be doubts whether all these measures - particularly the privatisations - will be implemented.

It is difficult to see how the debt mountain will be reduced. That is why most economists believe a default is inevitable - further down the road.

That is perhaps the real game here. Play for a delay, a postponement in the hope that Europe's banks will be healthier and more able to take a hit two to three years from now.

 
Gavin Hewitt, Europe editor Article written by Gavin Hewitt Gavin Hewitt Europe editor

The realities of re-negotiating Europe

UK Prime Minister David Cameron's proposal to re-negotiate the terms of its EU membership will meet stiff opposition in the eurozone, the BBC's Gavin Hewitt writes.

Read full article

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 18.

    Europe is heading down a dark, dark road and taking the entire west with them..
    Letting Greece into the EU was idiotic in the first place. .
    The best Greece can do now is REALLY socialize their economy, nationalize most industry, and start paying back their loans. The citizens simply cannot accept any more "austerity" measures and they won't. Unless drastic action takes place politically-default.

  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 17.

    View from Athens...coffee then off to Syntagma. Buses and trams on strike but they've left the metro running so we can get into the city centre. Nothing to lose anymore. Default. It'll be hard but at least Greece will once more belong (mostly) to the Greeks. Better now than later while some of us have still got some savings to tide us over. Soon we'll have absolutely nothing left.

  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 15.

    China to the rescue! Mind you, Greece still won´t be able to pay, ever. Only lend to governments if they put up collateral is the lesson. Unfortunately, the Greeks paradoxically have the rest of the EU over a barrel and may well fail to enact the necessary reforms but still get the funding they need. God this comments section is way too short to say anything intelligent. We are not twitterers...

  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 13.

    Banks, banks, banks. That's all we ever hear about, whether it's Greece, Iceland, Ireland, the UK... Why worry about putting millions of people out of work, as long as bankers can continue to profit from their greed and misjudgments.

  • rate this
    +10

    Comment number 10.

    Joining the Euro was the worst thing the Mediterranean and poorer countries of the EU could have done ; with low interest rates inviting them to borrow . Greek strikes and demonstrations show the kind of public loyalty the EU can expect in any member state , in such adversity .
    The bailout is to save the Euro and the banks that allowed Greece to become bankrupt , not to save Greece .

 

Comments 5 of 12

 

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • Audio cassette Be kind, rewind

    The cassette is making a comeback, but can business capitalise on a trend without falling victim to a fad?

Programmes

  • Scene from the film TitanicHARDtalk Watch

    The film director 'appalled' at how the movies Titanic and Ironman have been re-cut for China

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.