The scandal that could bring down Australia's government

Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard gives the thumps up to steel workers at OneSteel"s mill in the Melbourne suburb of Laverton, on July 12, 2010 Prime Minister Julia Gillard is holding on to her majority of one

Related Stories

A new arrival in Australia could reasonably be forgiven for thinking that there was some kind of constitutional requirement making it mandatory for political leaders to spend at least three days each week wearing either a fluorescent orange jacket or a white hard hat.

Virtually every morning, it seems, image-makers in the gainful employ of opposition leader Tony Abbott and Prime Minister Julia Gillard conjure up some kind of unimaginative photo-opportunity, where their leaders appear brandishing a blow-torch, a spade, a butcher's knife, an on-button or some kind of piece of light industrial machinery.

As often as not, Mr Abbott is bemoaning the introduction of the carbon tax, while Ms Gillard is trying to convey the sense that her minority government is capable still of getting big and important things done. Hours later, these images appear on the evening news shows, usually accompanied by a voice-track packed with lame puns from political correspondents whose daily misfortune it is to cover this miserable spectacle.

These are the dog days of Australia's permanent campaign, a rolling partisan battle that began in the weeks after the Copenhagen climate change summit, when Mr Abbott mounted the Liberal comeback, and has gone on pretty much uninterrupted ever since.

Perhaps the only brief respite came in those weeks of uncertainty following the federal election, when the prime minister proved much more accomplished as a backroom negotiator than a front-of-house performer.

Since finalising her deal with the Greens and independents, however, the leaders have been acting as if the campaign never truly finished. For Mr Abbott especially, politics is being conducted at the Defcon 1 level. With Labor just one seat away from losing its majority, war is imminent, and he is therefore in a state of maximum readiness. Now the Liberals are beginning to think that they are on the verge of a fatal strike.

The analogy of the hour, of course, is that the conservative opposition is a heartbeat away from a parliamentary majority. And at present that heartbeat belongs to Labor MP Craig Thomson.

'Protected species'

The member for Dobell is a former national secretary of the Health Services Union, who is accused of paying for escort services and drawing out more than $A100,000 ($104,000; £63,000) in cash on the union credit card. Mr Thomson has claimed that other union officials had access to that credit card, and denies any wrongdoing. But Fairfax media claims to have obtained documents revealing that phone calls were made to two Melbourne brothels in 2006 from rooms hired in his name. Fair Work Australia, the national workplace relations tribunal which carried out an initial probe, has reopened the investigation.

Before these details emerged, Mr Thomson had mounted a defamation suit against the Sydney Morning Herald which first published the allegations. As the Herald's political editor Peter Hartcher notes in a detailed piece, that is fairly standard practice. Just as the case was about to go to court, however, the MP dropped his defamation claim. Now it has been reported that the New South Wales Labor party helped Mr Thomson with his legal bills to the tune of $A90,000. Bankruptcy disqualifies people from sitting in parliament.

Mr Thomson, who entered parliament after the 2007 election, continues to claim that the allegations are "completely untrue". "I've denied these allegations before," he said. "There was nothing there that was new at all."

Publicly at least, he also has the complete public confidence of Ms Gillard, who said he is doing a "fine job" of representing his New South Wales constituents. "I look forward to him continuing to do that job for a very long, long, long time to come." But rarely has the phrase "she would say that wouldn't she" been so applicable. She has no other choice but to back him to the hilt.

Mr Thomson holds his seat in the Central Coast of New South Wales with a majority of 5%. Given the Gillard government's deep unpopularity, the Liberals would be expected to win a by-election at a canter. If Labor loses that seat, of course, it also loses its parliamentary majority.

Mr Abbott has labelled him a "protected species as far as this prime minister is concerned".

So do not be distracted by those fluorescent safety jackets and white hard hats. The story to watch is the one that Labor least wants retold: that of a little-known MP called Craig Thomson. Inevitably and drearily, it has already been labelled the "Hookergate" scandal. But in this instance it is not so much a case of following the money as tracking the credit.

Nick Bryant Article written by Nick Bryant Nick Bryant New York correspondent

Bloomberg's contested legacy as NYC mayor

Michael Bloomberg has overseen the transformation of New York City during his 12 years as mayor. But as he prepares to leave office the billionaire businessman's political legacy is still contested.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Fluorescent jackets and hard hats are merely stage props Julia Gillard uses when she goes on stage to do her act for hapless souls who aren't the least bit impressed. What they want to see her demonstrate is a bit of grey matter between the ears which she obviously hasn't got access to.

  • Comment number 2.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Prediction. Tony Abbott will get elected and be to Australia what George W. Bush was to the US. Who we really need here as leader in these challenging times is Malcolm Turnbull. He's an astute thinker who's not short of ideas, every time I hear him speak I have some hope. Abbott is just negative and divisive - but his brainwashing mantra seems to be working, which I think is a sad reflection on Australian society.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    I'm not sure who will last as leader of their country longer: Gillard or Gaddaffi! It's a pretty tight race even at this late stage.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    It's always entertaining to watch the spectacle of Australian politics. I’ve only been here a few years and I’ve already seen the replacement of a long term Liberal national government, the ousting of the Labour leader who led his party to an impressive victory – that would have taken years to achieve in Britain, the local labour government in WA calling a snap election and getting stuffed by the Liberals after they dumped the continually amusing Tory Buswell .
    The scandals of the Hookergate type are pretty typical for any democratic government in the developed world and any party as well. That’s not to say that wrong doing should not be exposed, especially when it entails inappropriate behaviour.
    Too often we, the electorate, the media and the politicians themselves, deal with complex issues with rhetoric instead of analysis, with difficult decisions with over-simple solutions and with our leaders with stereotypical and clichéd images of conflict.
    So when I see politicians dressed in hard hats and high vis-vests I always have to supress a laugh as, usually, none of them have had experience of manufacturing, or primary product, but I suppose it makes a pleasant change from kissing babies.


Comments 5 of 37


This entry is now closed for comments


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.