Australia fails to find an asylum solution

Burmese refugee Mang Thai Par, 7, looks out of a window at her family"s flat which they share with three other relatives in Kuala Lumpur June 24, 2011 Critics say Malaysia does not have the necessary safeguards for asylum seekers

The tagline was the invention of journalists rather than the Gillard government, but when ministers came up with the idea of sending asylum seekers to Kuala Lumpur, they hoped it would offer a "Malaysian Solution".

This was an emergency measure borne of a political and logistical dilemma. The country's detention centres are overcrowded and volatile. Julia Gillard has been hammered in the polls over one of Australia's most toxic political issues. No Labor leader wants to be portrayed as being soft on border protection. Indeed, Paul Keating pioneered the policy of mandatory detention.

However, neither the politics nor the logistics have worked out as the government intended. Not for the first time, the government announced the policy before the details had been hammered out (the equally inaptly named East Timor Solution provided another example).

It did not have the backing of the UN's refugee agency. Initially, the Department of Immigration said the asylum seekers would be sent to Malaysia within 72 hours of arriving at the Christmas Island detention centre, a timeline that it could not meet. There was confusion over whether unaccompanied children would be included in the swap deal. When it emerged that they would be, the government faced fierce criticism for its alleged heartlessness and callousness. The announcement that the asylum seekers would be filmed arriving in and then leaving Australia again brought on another wave of negative international headlines. Some of the world's most vulnerable people were being used as props, was the cry.

Politically speaking, the Malaysian Solution has so far done nothing to halt the Gillard government's slide in the polls. Indeed, it has highlighted another problem: its recurring incompetence. It is not hard to imagine the Malaysian Solution appearing in the curricula of public policy schools around the world as a case study in ineptitude and knee-jerk policy-making.

Malaysia's Home Affairs Minister Hishammuddin Hussein (R) and Australian Immigration Minister Chris Bowen in Kuala Lumpur, July 25 Immigration Minister Chris Bowen (L) is under huge pressure

For Ms Gillard, this is especially problematic. Australians do not require their leaders to be especially charismatic, telegenic or eloquent. But, in a country that has long favoured the practical over the philosophical, there is an expectation of competence.

Lambasted from both the left and the right, the government has now run into interference from the courts. On Sunday, as a plane sat on the tarmac at Christmas Island waiting to transport the first group of asylum seekers to Malaysia, a High Court judge issued a temporary injunction halting the planned departure. On Monday afternoon, the court extended the injunction until later this month, when a full hearing will decide whether the Malaysian Solution is lawful or not.

The government said it had predicted a legal challenge. But Justice Kenneth Hayne, the High Court judge who heard the application from a refugee advocates group, seems to think its lawyers were ill-prepared. He called the government's arguments "half-baked". Again, the accusation, this time from a senior judge, is of incompetence.

In response, embattled Immigration Minister Chris Bowen said there was a clear statutory basis for the policy. The Migration Act allows the immigration minister to "declare" or identify a third country to which asylum seekers can be sent. Under the law, he is also the legal guardian for the unaccompanied children put on boats by their parents in the hope that Australia will offer them asylum.

The government claims that the Malaysian swap deal will ultimately break the business model of the people smugglers, who charge large amounts to ferry asylum seekers towards Australian shores. It says the safety of the asylum seekers lies at the heart of the policy. But Julia Gillard has herself been accused of moral bankruptcy, especially for proposing to send unaccompanied children to Malaysian detention centres.

The lower house of parliament has passed a motion condemning the policy. The UN Human Rights Commissioner has also been vehemently opposed. Now a senior judge, a member of the highest court in the land, has expressed reservations. The opposition wants a return to the controversial Pacific Solution, with the reopening of an Australian-run detention centre on the tiny island on Nauru.

Should the government also look for an alternative solution?

Nick Bryant Article written by Nick Bryant Nick Bryant New York correspondent

Bloomberg's contested legacy as NYC mayor

Michael Bloomberg has overseen the transformation of New York City during his 12 years as mayor. But as he prepares to leave office the billionaire businessman's political legacy is still contested.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 24.

    21 Greg Warner

    Again we have an ill-informed resident of Indonesia opining on behalf of tax-paying Australian residents.

    The Nauru solution was successful because it caused a dramatic reduction in people smuggling flows.

    Which is better, being landed safely and housed and fed on a 27 sq. km island, or drowning and being dashed on rocks off Christmas Island?

  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    22. Charles Peter - Plenty of children are born into far worse situations with heterosexual parents than they are with gay parents. There is no evidence to suggest that having gay parents adversely affects children - and yes, it has been studied. Two loving parents of any kind are better than neglectful parents of any kind, of which there are many.

  • rate this

    Comment number 22.

    The government is clueless abd has lost all sense of moral behaviour. This is another of its botched policies, the other is allowing gay people to rear children... what about the right of the unborn child? the right for a child to have a mother and a father? Its elected ministers get donor sperms.
    Australia is sadly going down the path of moral decay that we now see enacted in the London riots.

  • rate this

    Comment number 21.

    Again we have PeterD's Canadian opinion...ill informed..
    He says the Nauru "solution" was a "success".
    By what definition?
    Almost all the arrivals detained on Nauru were ultimately able to enter Australia.
    During the process extremely high levels of psychological problems were evident.
    Any one who would suggest detaining people on a 27 square kilometre rock should think again.

  • rate this

    Comment number 20.

    marsala, I genuinely feel you are misrepresenting the issue. Australia admits substantial numbers of migrants and refugees annually, and has done so for generations.

    It does not, however, want to create an environment whereby those with money feel they can bypass legitimate migration controls, and queue jump those who are legitimate refugees or those who have been granted residency.


Comments 5 of 24



  • Nigel Farage (left) and Douglas CarswellWho's next?

    The Tory MPs being tipped to follow Carswell to UKIP

  • A painting of the White House on fire by Tom FreemanFinders keepers

    The odd objects looted by the British from Washington in 1814

  • Sailing rock in Death ValleyRock and roll

    Mystery of Death Valley's 'sliding rocks' solved - and more tales

  • Chris and Regina Catrambone with their daughter Maria LuisaSOS

    The millionaires who rescue people at sea

  • President Barack Obama pauses during a press conference on 28 August.'No strategy'

    Obama's gaffe on Islamic State reveals political truth

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.