Did animal cruelty report lead to an over-reaction?

Australian cattle are uploaded at  Tanjung Priok port in Jakarta No Australian cattle will arrive in Indonesia for the next six months

More than a week after its broadcast, powerful reverberations are still being felt from the ABC Four Corners investigation into the mistreatment of Australian cattle in Indonesian abattoirs.

An extraordinarily jolting piece of television journalism, the public response to the footage was immediate and visceral. Before the programme was over, distressed viewers had already started calling their lawmakers demanding an end to live cattle exports to Indonesia.

The following morning, the websites of animal welfare groups, like Animals Australia and RSPCA, could not cope with the number of people who wanted to sign their online petitions. Radio talkback shows were deluged with angry calls.

Australia's butchers have also experienced a backlash. The Australian Meat Industry Council says there has been a 15% drop in sales as consumers shunned beef. And this comes despite many consumers being aware than animals in Australia are slaughtered far more humanely.

Last week, the Australian government announced a ban on live cattle exports to the 12 abattoirs featured in the report. Labor MPs, who had also watched in horror, demanded nothing less.

But under pressure from the public and facing something of a backbench revolt on the issue, now the government has gone further and announced a temporary suspension on all live exports to Indonesia. The ban will remain in place for at least six months, in the hope that safeguards can be introduced at Indonesian abattoirs. Australia's Agriculture Minister Joe Ludwig said the ban would remain in place until the government received assurances that animals would be treated with more care.

Peculiarly, the Four Corners programme - fronted by same journalist, Sarah Ferguson, who was behind the Code of Silence expose of rugby league in 2009 - received its lowest viewing of the year. However, no piece of television journalism aired in Australia in the past 12 months has had such an profound impact on the public and, more importantly, government policy.

There are fears within rural communities that a blanket ban could destroy livelihoods. Australia exports 900,000 cattle each year, and the vast majority go to Indonesia. As this report from the Northern Territory shows, even a temporary suspension will not only hit cattle farmers, but all the support industries, like trucking firms and, more curiously, helicopter mustering groups. There's another piece here about the reaction to the suspension.

The Nationals Senator Barnaby Joyce has said the ban is an over-reaction. "We have over-reached and that will have consequences," he said.

There are voices in the cattle industry who believe that a short-term ban will save the Australian cattle export industry in the longer-term through the introduction of much-needed improvements to the slaughtering process in Indonesia.

So is this a proportionate response? Or will the cost for the rural economy simply be too much to bear?

By the way, for those interested in how the programme was put together, there is an interesting piece here.

Jonathan Holmes, the presenter of ABC's Media Watch, also offers some telling insights on this genre of reportage.

Nick Bryant Article written by Nick Bryant Nick Bryant New York correspondent

Bloomberg's contested legacy as NYC mayor

Michael Bloomberg has overseen the transformation of New York City during his 12 years as mayor. But as he prepares to leave office the billionaire businessman's political legacy is still contested.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 49.

    Please don't believe the Australian government spin on this issue. The original decision to stop the live exports was a knee-jerk reaction by an inexperienced and lacklustre federal minister.
    To make way for this weekend's carbon tax announcement, Joe Ludwig reversed his decision..
    Meanwhile, Australian consumer sentiment keeps diving as we watch Labor spiral out of control.
    Election, please.

  • rate this

    Comment number 48.

    We might talk about the pecking order of humans and animals when determining international, intercultural ethics when it comes to livestock and cattle. Indonesians in the cattle prodding and slaughter industry are not at the top of the pecking order. Therefore, they abuse or use reckless authority down. I think, maybe? May we beware of demonizing slaughterhouse Indonesians.

  • rate this

    Comment number 47.

    #43 Mollypollyfolly - but I am not "going to be transported on a truck etc and have my throat slashed".
    I am a human...you are describing animals, bred to be eaten.
    Of course, the animals should be slaughtered humanely.
    It's when some people refer to other people or practises as "sub human" that I worry.
    Last time a people and their practises were described as sub-human was under the Nazis.

  • rate this

    Comment number 46.

    to anyone who would like some information from a farmers perspective i suggest they read this letter http://community.cowhorse.com.au/profiles/blogs/letter-to-4-corners-by-scot
    this was sent to four corners and it shows the other side of the story

  • rate this

    Comment number 45.

    @32, The Moz: "If only they had of taken out the emotion and appointed livestock supply chain experts to assist the indonesian's to adhere to the licenses granted them."
    THE MEAT AND LIVESTOCK AUTHORITIES, SUCH AS LIVE CORP, HAVE AND DO PROVIDE ASSISTANCE.Why are you commenting on an issue you know nothing about? Maybe we should also take the emotion out of the issue of murder eh?


Comments 5 of 49



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.