Is India's lack of toilets a cultural problem?

 
This May 12, 2006 file photograph shows a slum resident (L) as he uses a toilet that opens into the water below as children swim in the water near a protest rally against the government for demolishing make-shift huts at Mandala in Mankhurd in north central Mumbai. India needs to extend sanitation facilities

Related Stories

Is anybody really surprised that nearly half of India's 1.2 billion people have no toilet at home?

Not really. The India Human Development report has been saying this for a while. The situation is worse in the villages, where two-thirds of the homes don't have toilets. Open defecation is rife, and remains a major impediment in achieving millennium development goals which include reducing by half the proportion of people without access to basic sanitation by 2015.

Is the lack of toilets and preference for open defecation a cultural issue in a society where the habit actually perpetuates social oppression, as proved by the reduced but continued existence of low caste human scavengers and sweepers?

It would seem so.

Mahatma Gandhi, India's greatest leader, had, in the words of a biographer, a "Tolstoyian preoccupation with sanitation and cleaning of toilets". Once he inspected toilets in the city of Rajkot in Gujarat. He reported that they were "dark and stinking and reeking with filth and worms" in the homes of the wealthy and in a Hindu temple. The homes of the untouchables simply had no toilets. "Latrines are for you big people," an untouchable told Gandhi.

Many years later when Gandhi began encouraging his disciples to work as sanitation officers and scavengers in villages, his diligent secretary and diarist Madhav Desai noted the attitudes of villagers. "They don't have any feeling at all," he wrote. "It will not be surprising if within a few days they start believing that we are their scavengers."

India's enduring shame is clearly rooted in cultural attitudes. More than half a century after Independence, many Indians continue to relieve themselves in the open and litter unhesitatingly, but keep their homes spotlessly clean. Yes, the state has failed to extend sanitation facilities, but people must also take the blame.

In the upstart suburb of Gurgaon, where I live, my educated, upwardly mobile, rich neighbours sent their pet dogs outside with their servants to defecate and refuse to clean up the mess. As long as their condominium is clean, it is all right. These are the same people who believe that the government is at the root of all evil.

Campaigns

Things are getting better in the villages, however slowly. Only 40% had access to sanitation facilities in 2002. This increased to 51% in 2008-009. More than 60% of homes in Bihar, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Uttarakhand states were still without toilets. There are other interesting behavioural and cultural pointers: Sikh and Christian households had the highest - over 70% - access to improved sanitation. Hindus - at 45% - had the least access.

India provides subsidies to construct toilets and runs sanitation and hygiene campaigns. Federal spending on sanitation was increased nearly three-fold in 2005. In 2003, the government kicked off a scheme to award village councils which are able to eliminate open defecation. Kerala has been the best performer with 87% of its village councils picking up the award. Only 2% of councils in dirt-poor Bihar won in a dismal commentary on the state of its sanitation.

India could take the lead from the tiny states of Himachal Pradesh and Haryana. Both have used and empowered local people to tackle open defecation, build toilets and adopt good waste management. Haryana provides subsidies to poor households to build toilets, and enlists women to run campaigns in what is a largely patriarchal and less progressive state. Volunteers visit homes, encouraging people to built toilets. All homes in Himachal Pradesh have a toilet today, say government surveys. The plan is to get rid of open defecation by the end of this year.

But until the time its people get rid of curious - and skewed - cultural attitudes to community sanitation and hygiene, India will never have enough toilets.

 
Soutik Biswas, Delhi correspondent Article written by Soutik Biswas Soutik Biswas Delhi correspondent

Was India's PM Manmohan Singh undermined by own party?

India PM's Manmohan Singh's authority was curbed by his own party, claims a new book by a former aide

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 1.

    As Soutik pointed out, I too have observed that people dump waste elsewhere while keeping their premises spotless. This sort of selfish behaviour permeates all aspects of life (corruption, crime). Before India sets her eyes on permanent seats in the UN security council, she should bring basic sanitation, health care, education and justice to all.
    Soutik, thank you for bringing up this issue.

  • rate this
    +8

    Comment number 2.

    Back in 1976 I was motorbiking through India. Naturally I stopped to look at interesting historical places such as Ajanta and Ellora. At one place the guardian was delighted when I wanted to use his brand new toilet block. He said a coach load of Indian visitors refused to use it but got off their coach and went to relieve themselves in the bush by the parking area. He was not happy with them.

  • rate this
    -7

    Comment number 3.

    Lost for words, ones your likely to print anyway! Hadn't realised the situation was so poor. Certainly a deterrent to buying foodstuff or fabrics from the sub-continent.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 4.

    Well done Soutik for tackling a rather embarassing issue that India is quick to sidestep in its quest for global success. It is somewhat intriguing that people value education and wealth more than access to basic sanitation. I remember a trip to the country in Andhra Pradesh and while the family stopped off at a local restaurant, I decided to use their loo. I wish I hadn't! NASTY!

  • rate this
    -7

    Comment number 5.

    What about looking at this from a different angle: is pre-occupation of some nations with toilets a cultural issue? Specifically, isn't completely out of control obsession with cleanness an echo of genetical fear of epidemics in overcrowded cities of medieval Europe, which some attempt to enforce of more relaxed cultures?

 

Comments 5 of 55

 

This entry is now closed for comments

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.