Is Uttar Pradesh experiencing a democratic upsurge?

Voters in Uttar Pradesh Uttar Pradesh recorded the best turnout of voters since 1947 on Wednesday

Has India's most populous state of Uttar Pradesh seen an unprecedented democratic upsurge?

Election officials believe so. They say that a record 62% turnout in the first phase of the seven-phase vote on Wednesday is the highest since 1947, up from a dismal average of 46% in the 2007 polls. "It rains votes in Uttar Pradesh," said a clever headline in The Hindu newspaper.

Many political scientists are not so sure.

India's top psephologist, Yogendra Yadav, believes that the high turnout could possibly be linked to something as prosaic as the correction of a "highly defective" voter list - the deletion of people who have died or migrated outside the state, and the inclusion of new voters.

The assumption is that 46 out of 100 people voted in the 2007 elections.

What happens when the voter list does not exclude voters who do not exist or include eligible new voters who do? In effect, you have 46 out of 80 or 90 registered voters who are alive, eligible and turn up at polling stations. You still show a 46% turnout, whereas 46 out of 80 or 90 voters would actually work out at more than 50% turnout.

So is the media brouhaha over the deepening of democracy in Uttar Pradesh justified?

Mr Yadav is again not very sure.

"There could be a minor genuine uptick in participation. We still don't have adequate information to compute these two elements - the actual participation of voters, and the deletion of 'false' voters and inclusion of new ones," he says. In the past two years, more than 17 million new voters have been added to the voter list in Uttar Pradesh.

In states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar which are hobbled by administrative apathy and ineptitude, faulty voter lists may have thrown up low turnouts for years. With election authorities cleaning up the lists and enrolling more voters, turnouts are beginning to look healthy.

Other experts I spoke to do not entirely agree with Mr Yadav's thesis.

They believe that the dramatic "rise" in voting in Uttar Pradesh is a significant development and is related to the political empowerment of the lower castes since the early 1990s. They point to how voter turnouts in southern Indian states like Tamil Nadu climbed to over 60% on the back of greater electoral participation by lower castes and the strengthening of democracy since the late 1960s.

However, that still does not explain why Uttar Pradesh was stuck with a lowly 46% turnout until the 2007 polls.

So who gains from the higher turnout?

In India, conventional political logic says that a high turnout of voters usually goes against the ruling party. In addition, cadre-based parties (BJP, Communists) do well when there is low polling, and consensus-based parties (Congress) do well when there is high polling, the argument goes.

By that logic the high polling should hurt the prospects of the ruling Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) government led by the Dalit icon Mayawati, and help the main opposition regional Samajwadi Party, Congress and even the Hindu nationalist BJP.

But predicting any result in Uttar Pradesh is fiendishly tricky. Many believe that the Uttar Pradesh polls will not throw up a clear winner, despite the so-called "raining of votes".

Or, as Yogendra Yadav says, first we have to be sure whether it really is raining votes in Uttar Pradesh.

Soutik Biswas Article written by Soutik Biswas Soutik Biswas Delhi correspondent

Why India gang-rape film row is extraordinary

A documentary by a British film-maker on the 2012 gang rape and murder of a female student in Delhi kicks up a storm in India.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    TOI news- (Steve) Jobs "may be suitable for high-level political post because honesty & integrity were not required for such positions". But not so for Govt, bureaucrat job under US govt. FBI concluded, "basically an honest & trustworthy person, he is a very complex individual & his moral character is suspect." UP or India need people with high morality & honesty & we do not have many.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Times of India is not so authentic for many. I'm posting the same news from BBC. "Steve Jobs' FBI files question his honesty and morality"- Overwhelming majority of Indian professionals (doctors, professors, scientists, Cxx etc) in India & abroad (many with heavy weight degrees from abroad) have NO sense of honesty, morality and justice.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    We wish Congress and the fake "Gandhi" family's magic will dissipate. The Election Commission’s order not to cover all the statues of Nehru, Indira, Rajeev "Gandhi"—with a cloth so that the voter is not misled, has caused considerable resentment in the BSP (Bahujan Samaj Party) camp. But why were these statues allowed to be erected in the first place?

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    Its a positive development for the people of UP, why because in the past a large section of society unable to exercise their rights due to baised sociopolitico structure ,advent of BSPandSP boost not only their selfrespect but also their share in the powerstructure. Recent overture by the BJP and Congress towards backward communities shows the people oriented democrcy is taking deep roots in UP.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    Heavy rain, biting cold, 55 Assembly seats = 10 districts witness record turnout of over 62% in first phase of polling for the UP assembly. Only 2 districts Balrampur & Siddhartha Nagar recorded less then 60% polling. Though major political parties - Congress, Samajwadi Party & the BJP - claimed main beneficiary, political observers feel that the winds of change are coming.


Comments 5 of 8



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.