China accuses the US of Olympic hypocrisy

 
US Olympic athletes from left: swimmer Ryan Lochte, decathlete Bryan Clay, rower Giuseppe Lanzone and soccer player Heather Mitts The Team USA opening ceremony parade uniform by Ralph Lauren has caused controversy

The London games have yet to begin, not a single starting gun has been fired, and already the US and China are slugging it out.

The issue that's got everyone fired up is not who is likely to be top of the medals table or who is the true sporting superpower.

But it is, in a way, about US fears that China is cheating, not on the sporting field but in the economic one, about fears America is losing out to a rival who does not play fair.

It's a row over the blazers and berets, slacks and scarves the US team will wear at the opening ceremony. You can see them here, and a slideshow here. Designed and paid for by the clothing firm Ralph Lauren, they are made in China.

Start Quote

How could he not get it - that manufacturing Team USA in a country that half owns us and has wrecked the domestic garment industry would be like choking on a chicken bone? ”

End Quote Stu Bykofsky Commentator
Congressional outrage

At a time when unemployment in America is 8%, members of Congress said they were outraged that the jackets were not stitched in America.

"I think they should take all the outfits, put them in a big pile and burn them and start over," said the Senate majority leader, Harry Reid, last week.

China's official Xinhua news agency has hit back. "Some US politicians have displayed shades of hypocrisy" said the official Xinhua news agency, in a commentary (which is not the same thing as an official government statement).

"The Olympic spirit, which has nothing to do with politics, chants mutual understanding and fair play, so tagging the uniforms with politics by those US politicians exposes narrow nationalism and ignorance, and violates the original Olympic Spirit" said Xinhua.

But fair play is exactly what many in America worry about. They fear that China, through an undervalued currency, trade barriers and state subsidies to its exporters - in the form of cheap land, cheap loans, export rebates and other help - is hollowing out US industry and jobs.

'Gut punch'

Ralph Lauren was accused of delivering "a gut-punch to most Americans" by Stu Bykofsky, a commentator for the Philadelphia Daily News, who wrote: "How could he not get it - that manufacturing Team USA in a country that half owns us and has wrecked the domestic garment industry would be like choking on a chicken bone? There's something like 600,000 American textile workers looking for jobs."

File photo: US Republican candidate Mitt Romney Mr Romney has called President Obama the "outsourcer-in-chief"

The clothing company now says Team USA uniforms for the next Olympics, the winter games in 2014, will be made in America.

Xinhua put all this down to US sensitivities in what is an election year, saying it is "just another example of the fierce, and sometimes ridiculous, political fighting going on the Capitol Hill in the year of election, which is dominated by economic growth and job creation."

In the past week, President Obama's campaign has attacked Mitt Romney, claiming his firm Bain Capital was responsible for "outsourcing" jobs to China a decade ago.

Romney has fired back, calling President Obama the "outsourcer-in-chief", alleging that US government stimulus money helped create jobs in China rather than America.

Democrat senators now want to introduce legislation to ensure uniforms worn by US teams are produced in the United States.

Economic worries

But the row over jobs and trade has the potential to get much more serious. Romney has, in past months, said he will get tough on China over its trade and currency practices, threatening to declare it a currency manipulator as soon as he enters office.

The Obama administration has begun half a dozen trade complaints against China at the WTO, over rare earth minerals, and solar and wind power subsidies.

Volunteers waiting to greet arriving teams at Heathrow Airport in London The US and China are in a row even before the Olympic games begin

Beneath all the rhetoric lie fears in the US that America is in decline, and China is rising but not playing fair.

In The Beijing Times on Monday Jia Xudong, a researcher at a think tank linked to China's Foreign Ministry, said "due to ideological mischief-making, some Americans intentionally or unintentionally see China as the enemy... Wearing ideological blinkers they look at China, seeing China as a competitive rival, and practising trade protectionism."

But in China, too, there are economic worries. China's economy has been slowing for the past year-and-a-half. Figures last week showed growth at its lowest level since the financial crisis.

At the weekend, Premier Wen Jiabao warned "hardship" may continue.

Right now, China does not need more disputes with the US, but things could get worse. Both countries, concerned about their economies and where growth will come from, will continue to compete for every job and every dollar of trade just as seriously as their athletes fight it out at the Olympics, and that means more trade disputes and more political tensions.

 
Damian Grammaticas Article written by Damian Grammaticas Damian Grammaticas China correspondent

Uncovering China's illegal ivory trade

Demand for ivory in China has pushed levels of poaching to new highs. The BBC's Damian Grammaticas investigates China's illegal ivory traders.

Read full article

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 162.

    #156 Mark - The company is a USA team sponsor. They had the uniforms made and gave them to team USA. There's no profit in the transaction.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 161.

    Outsourcing didn't put the U.S. garment workers out of business...Union instigated greed put them out of business, just as the UAW came close to putting the U.S. auto workers out of business...the people shopping at WalMart, Target, KMart and the like are saying, "We won't pay the inflated Union wages to garment workers!" China is just another choice. If you don't like it, move to Venezuela where the elections AND the prices are fixed.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 160.

    If Congress wants to find fault with the Ralph Lauren designed Olympic uniforms they should start with those hats. Do they look like the kind of headgear that an athlete would proudly keep and wear after the games? I can't imagine an American athlete wearing those silly looking things a second longer than they have to.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 159.

    The US is failing because the US Federal and state governments are failures. California whines for a Federal bailout for a situation that they made all on their own. They could go along way towards getting out of it by using eminent domain and seizing all the houses with non-performing mortgages and then taking up the loansat a rate that the borrowers can afford.

    As for the US unemployment rate 8% is the LameSWtream Media number the real number is 16%+, and that doesn't count the nearly 1million illegals that Obama has "legitimized" to buy votes.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 158.

    You reap what you sow. The hypocrisy here is that America has played unfairly for years. It is rich precisely because it has played unfairly, going to war for oil and outsouricing all of it's manufacturing jobs to immoral sweatshop labour overseas. Its corporations (who in many cases pay low or no tax) then sell the goods back to its own people for massively inflated prices.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 157.

    After reading through the comments, I'm still at a loss as to who is blaming China. Only criticism quoted in this article is directed towards Ralph Lauren.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 156.

    #150 RiceOwl - The company that manufactures the uniform (Ralph Lauren) is American so America would have made some sort of profit off of them regardless of where they were made. Well..maybe not since the company probably has all of it's bank accounts in the Virgin Islands and not taxed. I also assure you that nothing Nike makes is manufactured in the United States. Hasn't been in decades. The company has used slave labor in many countries for years and marketed their shoes for insane prices. As an American, I assure you that I could care less if those teams dump the Nike brand.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 155.

    Every time I read a new statement from Romney, I feel more like not voting for him. The gangs that Romney represents are the real beneficiaries of outsourcing.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 154.

    Ralph Lauren's free Olympic clothing bought it free Olympic advertising. On top of the free promo he will get a tax write-off for the inflated value of his "charitable" contribution

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 153.

    I have a Maglite torch, proudly made in the USA. Quality product. I love it.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 152.

    ayetee - Team U.S.A. ought to surrender their Feinwerkbaus and Steyrs. Pick up a dear old Crossman or a Daisy I suppose
    Actually they don't use any of those. Anshutz is the main one used in most of the world. To be honest, they should use crossman or daisy. Believe it or not, they do have some highly accurate rifles that could compete with those brands. So does beeman. British ammo from eley used to be the main one but winchester is now used. Both are still fantastic.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 151.

    U.S. manufacturing has been regulated out of existance. China has nothing to do with it.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 150.

    So, a global economy is great.... when the U.S. benefits. But not the other way around?

    Hopefully all non-U.S. sports teams (especially national federations) who have kit supplied by Nike, Under Armor, Warrior etc will follow America's lead and go home grown in the future.

    Sure, the products are still made in Asia, but why should multi-millions in profits from the sale of Brazil, Holland, Portugal, Man U, Celtic and Barcelona shirts go straight to Nike's HQ in Oregon? Surely those profits should stay at home?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 149.

    discoclint - If we Americans did demand that our government become socialist do you honestly think that would stop outsourcing to China? Seems that many socialist countries continue to do so with gusto. I know that capitalism isn't perfect and some of its principles have hurt the US economy and you say that we should try socialism and it isn't that bad...well..I am looking at Greece and other parts of Europe right now...um...

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 148.

    Every set of the uniform cost 2000 dollars, wow, I am wondering how much does the chinese work actually get? 10%? 15%? where are the other 85%? All those US politicans accusing China for the faults? Secondly, who paid for those uniforms? If I did my homework right, it is not the US government, not the Tax payer's money, it is from private donations!

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 147.

    This is the company's fault- for choosing money over patriotism
    A true American brand is the one that makes products in America
    ipads, iphones, etc are all Made in China Chinese products

    Americans know that if we want to decrease our debt+trade deficit
    we are going to have to start manufacturing again

    Its not that we are against China
    Its that we are for America

    All patriotic Americans have got to take a stand to save our country
    +supporting Made in USA manufacturing is our way of doing it

    Americans want Made in USA b/c we love our country
    +we want to represent ourselves

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 146.

    Certainly this is a big issue here in the US. Not so much where uniforms are made, but the symbolism of what has happened to so many middle class jobs. Of course the US isn't alone in this plight. What struck me about this article is the ridiculous photo depicting the US team uniforms with the huge American flag.. It is more in line with an armed forces commercial! Contrast that to any other national Olympic team photo, and you'll see happy smiling faces. Is this really the image you want to portray to the world America? Like new military recruits at boot camp?

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 145.

    Now, if there was a native English-speaking US - or UK citizen for that matter - who could contribute a comment like #143 in Mandarin or Cantonese Chinese, *they* would deserve a gold medal. A straightforward respect for people who speak such good English is a pre-requisite for adult debate in my humble opinion.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 144.

    American Olympic athletes wearing Chinese uniforms symbolizes
    the decline of USA economy+the rise of Chinese economy

    American manufacturing corps going to China the last 10 years
    resulted in loss of millions of USA jobs which is why China has space shuttles
    but America can no longer afford them

    I am so proud of Harry Reid+our lawmakers who stepped up to demand Team USA Olympics uniforms be Made in America

    Next hopefully our lawmakers will change our tariffs so that we have the same tariffs on China that they have on us

    America wants to manufacture our own products again

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 143.

    US has adopted capitalism as its political and economical driving force. Capitalism is based on making as much profit as you can. Making clothes in China gives American companies more profit. Its not the company's fault, its your the fact that America demands capitalist policies from its (only) two political parties.
    Try socialism, its not as bad as you think (and its not the same as communism).

 

Page 1 of 9

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.