Exploring North Korea's contradictions


The BBC's Damian Grammaticas inside North Korea

Related Stories

North Korea says it is ready to put a satellite into space this week in a move that has been condemned by America as a clear violation of UN resolutions. The launch is part of celebrations for the 100th birthday of the country's founding President Kim Il Sung, now dead, and is meant to showcase North Korea's achievements. Our correspondent Damian Grammaticas is the only British broadcaster in the usually closed country, invited by the North Korean authorities.

Today we sped, down long, half-empty avenues. Our North Korean minders were taking us out of the capital Pyongyang to the countryside.

Being here, in the world's last Stalinist state, feels like being transported back in time.

North Korea often looks like a place marooned, a survivor from an age when Soviet republics, with their strongmen rulers, were common.

The streets of the capital are lined with rows of towering concrete blocks. But there's not a shop with a window display or advertising hoarding to be seen.

From inside the goldfish bowl of our tour bus we catch glimpses as we are whisked to destinations not of our choosing.

All across Pyongyang, final preparations are being made for the huge celebrations planned for the coming days.

Groups of soldiers work to fix broken pavements, women wash the walls of buildings by the roadside, displays of flowers are being readied.

Huge paintings of North Korea's founding and eternal President Kim Il Sung, head of the dynasty that has ruled the country ever since, dot the streets.

Grim villages

The party is to celebrate his 100th birthday, though he died nearly two decades ago. Like much about North Korea, it seems contradictory.

We were soon out of the city, being whisked past grim-looking villages, and people toiling by hand in bare fields. Lines of tents were pitched on the hillsides where squads of soldiers were camping out.

Our destination, though, was a model project, the Daedonggang Fruit Farm, a thousand hectares of apple trees, all in perfect rows.

A North Korean woman works on an apple farm near Pyongyang on April 10, 2012 The North Korean government is keen to show off large fruit farms as a symbol of its success

It's the way North Korea wants to be seen - ordered, efficient, a modern socialist miracle. The farm, we were told, was made under the instructions of Kim Il Sung's son, the Dear Leader, Kim Jong Il, and is now being guided by his son, Kim Jong Un, the third of the Kims to rule over North Korea.

Kim Dal Hua, one of the workers tending to the apple trees, told us: "I'm very happy working here, it's thanks to Kim Jong Il and Kim Jong Un who ensure we have everything we need."

Everyone here keeps telling us how wise and benevolent the ruling Kim dynasty is.

But somehow there's often a feeling things may not be quite what they seem. When we entered the giant and ultra-modern fruit-processing factory at the farm, gleaming machines were producing cartons of apple juice.

But many of the workers didn't actually look to be doing much, and at one machine the women were picking up the boxes full of juice as soon as they reached the end of the production line and putting them back on the start, juice going round and round in circles.

Turtles for all

Doubts linger too over the centrepiece of the planned celebrations this week, the rocket launch to put a satellite in space. North Korea says the rocket is ready to go. But America insists it will actually be a test of missile technology, and the rockets might, one day, be used to carry nuclear warheads and threaten US cities.

Murals of the two leaders, 9 April 2012 The giant murals of Kim Il Sung and Kim Jong-il are designed to cement the dynasty

But North Korea insists it is misunderstood. That's why it invited our group of journalists in to witness the launch and the celebrations, so it can trumpet its achievement and say it has nothing to hide.

We were shown another brand new farm. This one was also, we were told, built very recently on the instructions of Kim Jong Il. Huge sheds held lines of water tanks to breed turtles, an expensive delicacy when eaten, and an ingredient in traditional medicine too.

The manager Bang Dok Son said the farm had cost "millions" to build, so I asked when it would start to make a profit.

"It is hard to explain if you have a capitalist mindset," said Mr Bang.

"Our leaders built this, instructing us to provide turtles for the people - to us profit doesn't matter."

But as we headed back to the city, we passed stretches of bare fields, then a theme park under construction, and more lines of shabby huts, the contradictions of a country that struggles to feed its people, yet whose leaders dream grandiose dreams.

Damian Grammaticas Article written by Damian Grammaticas Damian Grammaticas China correspondent

Uncovering China's illegal ivory trade

Demand for ivory in China has pushed levels of poaching to new highs. The BBC's Damian Grammaticas investigates China's illegal ivory traders.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 124.

    Apple juice going 'round in circles, buses speeding journalists past undesirable-looking sites, citizens reciting scripts supporting their government...yeah sounds like the same old turtle-eating North Korea.

  • rate this

    Comment number 123.

    So we have NK as a hereditary feudal lord King Son with their thugs to enforce power over its citizens Lord General.
    But the sad part is for the Lords and King that mentally they know they are a failure to their family.A huge embarrassment of the nation compared to others.Sadly unless they choose to have a good life by benefiting the masses the Lord generals and Kings will continue to be ashamed at their inferiority to take care of their own people. Their monuments will be crushed in 100 yrs & faces stamped on by the peasants and soldiers feet.
    Win win and NK leaders could leave a good legacy.

  • rate this

    Comment number 122.

    I am more worried about the endless conveyor belt of apple juice going round and round. What could the "sell by" date possibly be......

  • rate this

    Comment number 121.

    re. 118.SAXON: "So do the USA and they used theirs...
    Who would you trust?"

    Yes we did. Of course you don't bring up the subject of Japan's wartime program to develop atomic weapons, which ironically required the construction of power generation facilities in northern Korea used today to power North Korean weapons development facilities.

  • rate this

    Comment number 120.

    Any agreement with North Korea lasts exactly as long as it takes to deliver the food they demand.


Comments 5 of 124



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.