Held 'hostage' by China


She has described herself as China's "hostage", and her story deserves to be told widely.

Liu Xiaobo (undated photo) Liu Xiaobo was convicted of attempting to 'subvert' the Chinese state

For over a year now Liu Xia has been deprived of her liberty by the Chinese state, for the sole reason, it seems, that her husband won the Nobel Prize.

Liu Xia is guilty of nothing. But she is married to Liu Xiaobo, the Chinese political activist, selected by the Nobel committee last year as winner of the Peace Prize.

That, it seems, is why she has been under "house arrest" since 18 October 2010, though her detention has no discernible legal basis. It is why her case is extraordinary, and why it deserves mention now, one year on from the award of the prize.

When the Nobel committee announced the award Liu Xiaobo was already in jail. He's been there for three years, and has been convicted of attempting to "subvert" China's Communist Party-led state.

His crime was to help author and circulate Charter '08, a bold call for political reform in China. He was tried and convicted. His supporters said the process was unfair, but he at least faced a court.

His wife has committed no crime and broken no law. There don't appear to be any legal charges against her. In fact, she is said to have pleaded with her husband not to take part in drafting the charter. Still she is being held.

I met Liu Xia in Beijing a couple of years ago. A slim woman, now in her early 50s, she is a poet and painter. She looks a little like a Buddhist nun, spectacled, her hair shaven.

Shy and quiet, it's hard to see why anyone would view her as a threat. But even then she was under police surveillance and had to slip out of her home to be able to talk to us.

Cut off

China called the decision to give her husband the 2010 Peace Prize a "desecration" of the idea of peace, and an attack on China's sovereignty and its legal system, saying he was a criminal and should not be honoured.

So it was no surprise that it moved to detain Liu Xia. It was thought China wanted to prevent her travelling to Oslo to collect the award on her husband's behalf, and would quietly lift restrictions on her a few weeks later.

But, now a year on, she is still being held, we believe, in her own home. Her phone line remains cut, her internet connection shut, visitors turned away by guards posted at her compound.

For one - very brief - moment in February, Liu Xia, was, it seems, able to access a computer and have an online conversation with a friend via an instant messaging system.

The BBC saw the transcript of what appeared to be her internet chat which lasted just five minutes. In it Liu Xia said she "can't go out" as her "whole family are hostages".

She added she was "so miserable", saying "I'm crying... nobody can help me".

When the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention asked earlier this year about the restrictions on her, the Chinese government admitted that "no legal enforcement measure" had been taken against Liu Xia. It holds her anyway.

The Nobel committee said one reason for giving Liu Xiaobo the Peace Prize was that China's people had basic rights guaranteed by China's own constitution and international conventions to which China is party, but "in practice, these freedoms have proved to be distinctly curtailed for China's citizens".

The committee members added that "China's new status must entail increased responsibility".


But a year on, China's critics argue that things have only got worse.

Start Quote

Its treatment of her leaves China open to the charge that it is disregarding its own laws”

End Quote

Testifying this week to the US Congressional Executive Commission on China, Li Xiaorong, a member of the campaign group Human Rights in China, attacked Beijing for what she called "the issue of systematic violation by the Chinese authorities of the Chinese law and international human rights law, as evidenced in the persecution of Liu Xiaobo and many other Chinese for exercising their freedom of expression and for engaging in peaceful activism to promote democracy and human rights".

Li Xiaorong claimed that "secret detention and enforced disappearance has been applied on multiple occasions, for example, to many activists and lawyers during the government crackdown on online calls for Tunisian-style 'Jasmine Revolution' protests last February, and to the artist Ai Weiwei".

"In February, within a few weeks, a total of 52 individuals were criminally detained, at least 24 were subjected to enforced disappearance."

China's position is that it is a country ruled by law and that due process is followed.

But Liu Xia too has disappeared from view. Its treatment of her leaves China open to the charge that it is disregarding its own laws. Its actions - locking her up in her home - can be painted by its critics as purely vindictive.

That's hardly the image China wants to paint of itself to the world. At a time when China's economic power is growing, it wants to increase its "soft power" too.

But refusing to let a soft-spoken, shy, middle-aged woman who has committed no crime even step out of her front door freely is unlikely to win China many admirers.

Damian Grammaticas Article written by Damian Grammaticas Damian Grammaticas China correspondent

Uncovering China's illegal ivory trade

Demand for ivory in China has pushed levels of poaching to new highs. The BBC's Damian Grammaticas investigates China's illegal ivory traders.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 34.

    @13 - cxcpro1
    "Grow up a little" is what I say to the western white people. We chinese walked the earth for more than 4000 years and still going strong, our Ideology served us well."

    Maybe you guys have walked the Earth like herd for far too long. It's the people like Liu Xiaobo who wants to stop for a moment and think: we're not herd, we're not animal. We deserve to live with decent life and decent rights just like everyone else who has walked the Earth for far less time.

  • rate this

    Comment number 33.

    Too many people in the West forget that China is a one party dictatorship. Whether its still a communist one, or has now morphed into a fascist state is a debatable point, but no one can deny its a dictatorship of one persuasion or another.

  • rate this

    Comment number 32.

    Western needs a phobia.It was first Nazi's,then Soviets and Communism.Starting with war criminal G.W. Bush and Tony Boy, it turned to be Islamphobia.Socially engineered. Millions of innocent people stamped,suffered. A dangerous gap deliberately opened between Christians and Muslims.Not enough. A new enemy needed! A perfect cut is China.First an Oedipus complex involved,a must hatred.US borrows money from China and bombs Kindergartens in Afghanistan.UK with history of massacres all around the world,shutting parliaments and torturing MP''s now teaches(?) Chinese,democracy? Dunning-Kruger effects

  • rate this

    Comment number 31.

    I belive awarding Nobel price to Liu is a concerted western effort to shame China,just look at Dalai, Ai weiwei n etc.for they dare to stand-up against China,not becos of their contribution to any accademic field.What if China award a national price to d successor of Osama B Ladin?Western nations have 2 standards,when a person kill Americans,he's a terrorist,when some1 kill chinese,such as during 03/14/2008 inTibet,China,then he's a freedom fighter.Any report filed from western meadia,it must be "independently verified"but when filed from China,any hear-say is treated as truth.

  • rate this

    Comment number 30.


    In the West we can overthrow the government every five years, if we like. It's called an "election".


Comments 5 of 34



  • Kim Jong-ilKorean kidnap

    The film stars abducted by North Korea and forced to make movies

  • TabletFeeling flat

    Are tablets losing their appeal?

  • scarlett Johansson7 days quiz

    Did someone try to impersonate Scarlett on the red carpet?

  • Woman reading on subwayCover shots Watch

    The disappearing books of the New York city subway

  • llamasLlama drama

    Two unlikely fugitives go on the run in Arizona

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.