Pakistan to boycott Afghan Bonn talks after Nato raid

Supporters of the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) party burn a US flag during a protest in Multan on November 28, 2011, against a Nato strike on Pakistan troops. Many Pakistanis want to cut ties with the US

Pakistan is to boycott a meeting on Afghanistan's future in protest at a Nato air strike which killed 24 of its soldiers at the weekend, officials say.

The decision not to attend came as Nato troops were attacked by insurgents in eastern Afghanistan, some firing from across the Pakistani border.

A BBC reporter with US troops says Nato fired shells into Pakistani territory.

Pakistan says Saturday's air strike violated its sovereignty. Nato has apologised, calling the deaths tragic.

Pakistan has cut crucial Nato supply lines through its territory to Afghanistan. Nato is investigating what happened.

Tuesday's boycott decision came amid mounting public anger in Pakistan and growing demands from opposition parties to sever ties with the US.

The BBC's international news channel has been taken off air amid uproar over the Nato air raid. The move came after the BBC aired a documentary that questioned Pakistan's commitment to tackling militancy - and could be part of a wider crackdown on foreign media coverage in the country.


Since the killing of Pakistan soldiers, the Nato-led mission in Afghanistan has limited operations along the border. The men of Charlie company, 2-28, 172nd infantry, have postponed long-range patrols eastwards to avoid upsetting a delicate diplomatic situation.

Soldiers here think that Pakistan may be turning a blind eye to insurgent attacks from its territory - something Islamabad has always denied. But there's also an acceptance from commanders that this uncertain border is impossible to control, from either side.

For the local Wazir tribe in this part of eastern Afghanistan, the border doesn't exist. The same is true for insurgents who move freely between both countries.

When the Soviets occupied Afghanistan they said it would take a quarter of a million troops to close the border with Pakistan. That's well beyond the ability of not only Pakistan, but also of Afghan and international forces on this side of the border.

Pakistan's Information Minister Firdous Ashiq Awan told the BBC the Nato air strikes were "a violation of all terms and conditions we have with Nato".

"It's a clear-cut attack on Pakistan's sovereignty and integrity," she added.

Sources close to Afghan President Hamid Karzai told the BBC they understood there would be no Pakistani participation in Bonn at all.

Following the boycott announcement, Mr Karzai rang Pakistani Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani to urge him to send his foreign minister.

The Bonn meeting is aimed at bringing together Western and regional leaders to map out a strategy for Afghanistan after the withdrawal of foreign combat forces in 2014.

Pakistan is a key regional player, crucial to any hopes of a negotiated Afghan settlement.

Meanwhile, violence continued along the two countries' border.

The BBC's Quentin Sommerville was with US troops at the Margah outpost in Paktika province - 5km (three miles) from the border - when it was attacked by insurgents firing mortars and rockets from at least three locations, including from inside Pakistan.

US soldiers fired back nearly 50 mortars in response. A nearby base also opened up with heavy artillery, with at least two shells landing inside Pakistan territory, our correspondent says.

F-16 fighter jets were called in, dropping bombs on multiple locations, all within Afghan territory.

None of the American or Afghan soldiers were hurt - it is not known if the insurgents suffered casualties.

Pakistani security personnel chat with a truck driver carrying supplies for NATO forces in Afghanistan returning from Pakistan"s Torkham border crossing after Pakistani authorities shut vital NATO supply routes on November 28, 2011. Nato supply convoys through Pakistan are at a standstill
Under fire

Saturday's air strike has added to the strain on relations between Nato and Pakistan, a crucial ally in the fight against the Taliban.

In recent months, the US military has accused Pakistan's spy agency of supporting militants in Afghanistan. For its part, Pakistan's military was incensed by the US raid which killed Osama Bin Laden on Pakistani soil in May.

Afghan officials have claimed that Nato forces were retaliating for gunfire from the Pakistani side of the volatile border on Saturday, a charge denied by Pakistan's military.

The night-time attack took place at the Salala checkpoint in Mohmand agency, about 1.5 miles (2.5 km) from the poorly delineated border with Afghanistan, early on Saturday morning.


The Pakistani army said helicopters and fighter aircraft hit two border posts, killing 24 people and leaving 13 injured.

Unnamed Afghan officials quoted in The Wall Street Journal said Saturday's air strike was called in to shield Nato and Afghan forces who had come under fire.

One official quoted in the paper said that Kabul believed the shooting came from an army base.

"This is not true. They are making up excuses. What are their losses, casualties?" Pakistani army spokesman Maj-Gen Athar Abbas said in response to the allegations.

US-Pakistan downturn

  • 30 Sept 2010: Nato helicopters kill two Pakistani soldiers, prompting nearly two-week border closure in protest
  • 22 April 2011: Supplies to Nato forces in Afghanistan halted for three days in protest over drone attacks
  • 2 May: US announces Bin Laden's death and says Pakistan not warned of raid
  • 2 June: Top US military chief Adm Mike Mullen admits "significant" cut in US troops in Pakistan
  • 10 July: US suspends $800m of military aid
  • 22 Sept: Outgoing US Adm Mullen accuses Pakistan of supporting Haqqani militant group in Afghanistan; denied by Pakistan

Military sources earlier told the BBC that a US-Afghan special forces mission had been in the area, where a Taliban training camp was believed to be operating.

They said the mission came under fire from a position within Pakistan, and they received permission from the headquarters of Nato's Isaf mission to fire back.

Pakistani officials have consistently maintained that there had been no militant activity in the area. They also said Nato had the grid references of the posts and therefore should not have fired.

Pakistani troops have been fighting the Taliban in the border region for most of the past decade. They still face accusations that they provide sanctuary to some militants launching attacks over the border in Afghanistan.

The US and Pakistan desperately need each other in order to shape the future of a stable and neutral Afghanistan before Western combat troops withdraw next year, correspondents say.

While Pakistani officials facing mounting domestic anger over ties with the US, they have little room for manoeuvre - the country's military is heavily dependent on US aid.

The BBC's Orla Guerin in Islamabad says there is little chance of ties being cut - but Pakistan is determined to send a message that it will not be satisfied merely with condolences from Nato or promises of an inquiry.

More Asia stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.