Letter from Africa: Take it or leave it

 
Zanu-PF supporters raise their fists and shout slogans during an election rally in Harare, Zimbabwe, on 28 July 2013

In our series of letter from African journalists, London-based Ugandan writer Joel Kibazo considers how the West appears to be losing its political clout in Africa.

The growth in Africa's economic fortunes and development over the last few years appears to have also brought a new confidence in the way the continent handles itself in the global arena.

In the economic sphere and business, competition, particularly from Asia, has meant that Africans have alternatives to the West.

Much has been said about the growing influence and presence of the Chinese on the continent and increasingly someone's latest smartphone is likely to be from South Korea with a service provider that might be in India.

Start Quote

Who do the British think they are to say who they will deal with or not and in what way? We are not their colony anymore”

End Quote Kenyan diner

But it is in the way Africa handles political issues that this new confidence is most apparent.

The holding of elections is now commonplace in most of Africa, but what has changed is that we Africans no longer seem to want approval of the international superpowers on the outcome.

Where once the norm was to tread carefully and wait for a verdict - or should that be blessing - from the US, the UK , France or Russia on an election, these days it appears it does not matter what those powers have to say.

"Take it or leave it" appears to be the order of the day - and even where there is a domestic dispute about an election outcome, it will be the views of neighbours or other fellow Africans that will carry the day.

Ill-feeling

The sight of the Western powers scrambling for a face-saving position that will leave them with some semblance of respectability after an election is becoming all too familiar.

The two biggest examples in recent months are the election outcomes in Kenya and more recently in Zimbabwe.

Kenya election result 2013

  • Votes cast: 12,221,053
  • Uhuru Kenyatta: 6,173,433 (50.07%)
  • Raila Odinga: 5,340,546 (43.31%)
  • Turnout: 86%

Source: Kenya's Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission

In Kenya, the official line of Western governments was that they did not interfere in the affairs of a country and any election outcome was to be respected as it would be the will of the people.

As I said, that was the official line but there was little disguising the nervousness of the West that surrounded the prospects of Uhuru Kenyatta winning the presidency.

He is accused by the International Criminal Court in The Hague of orchestrating deadly violence after the 2007 election, an allegation he denies.

Many Kenyans were angered by the UK's representative to Kenya, Christian Turner, when he said his government would not get in contact with ICC indictees unless it was "essential".

Kenyan supporters of Uhuru Kenyatta and his deputy William Ruto - 9 April 2013 President Kenyatta and his deputy William Ruto deny ICC allegations of orchestrating deadly violence after the 2007 poll

I was in Nairobi in the run-up to the elections and the ill-feeling towards that statement was palpable.

Over dinner, a friend said: "Who do the British think they are to say who they will deal with or not and in what way? We are not their colony any more."

Ironically, the British high commissioner was only a few tables away in the same restaurant.

Kenyans, in their wisdom, decided to elect Mr Kenyatta and it took a good three weeks before the UK's representative could gain an audience with the new president.

When he eventually did, it was not only to deliver a message of congratulations, but an invitation to attend the Somalia conference in London being hosted by UK Prime Minister David Cameroon.

The newly elected president accepted and attended the meeting in May.

The point had been made. What the British or any other Western power had to say was of little consequence.

It was for Kenyans to decide and they had.

Zimbabwe presidential poll results

  • Votes cast: 3,480,047R
  • Robert Mugabe, Zanu-PF: 61%, 2,110,434 votes
  • Morgan Tsvangirai, MDC: 34%, 1,172,349 votes
  • Turned away: 304,980
  • Assisted voters: 206,901

Source: Zimbabwe Electoral Commission

'Credible'

In Zimbabwe, following the recent presidential and parliamentary elections, the US, the UK and Australia expressed concern after official results gave President Robert Mugabe a seventh consecutive term in office with 61% of the vote.

The Movement for Democratic Change claimed electoral fraud and has taken the matter to the court.

Results published by Zimbabwe's Electoral Commission in the week after the vote showed that more than 300,000 voters had indeed been turned away.

Yet for all that, the African Union observer mission said the presidential elections were "free, honest and credible".

President Jacob Zuma of South Africa, the regional power, congratulated President Mugabe on his re-election, urging opposition groups to accept the results of what he called "the successful harmonised elections".

I would say it is all over bar the shouting: The Constitutional Court has up to two weeks to deliver its verdict, but I do not expect it to change the outcome.

And the views of the West will not matter one single bit.

For good or ill, Africa has clearly decided to go its own way.

If you would like to comment on Joel Kibazo's latest column, please use the form below.

 

More on This Story

Letter from Africa

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 28.

    The West over the years has squandered its opportunities in helping to change things in africa despite the mounting of signs that the continent's demographic change and social development was a desirable cause for a review of Western foreign policy dimension and economic relations . The West just lost it .

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 27.

    LEOPOLD DONCHIELD ZU LEONE II

    How does African constitutional monarchy compare with constitutional monarchy in Europe?

    Leopold Donchield Zu Leone II argues that most countries in Africa are already practising what we know as sub-national monarchy, while just a few with constitutional monarchy system already in place.
    click below:
    http://www.leopoldmaximilian-donchieldzuleoneii.blogspot.com

  • rate this
    -3

    Comment number 26.

    Not just Africa, the rest of the world is waking up to the West's hypocrisy.

    Democratic accountability is nonexistent in the UK & US.
    All government action is about commercial advantage, not principle.

    China has shown that Democracy is no prerequisite to development.
    Education and economic security are.

    Oh, stomping round the world killing thousands of innocent people doesn't help either!

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 25.

    The people who want free and fair elections are the Africans themselves, Kenya and Zimbabwe notwithstanding, but they unfortunately don't have much say in the quality of the candidates running for election.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 24.

    Bring in Egypt, and the fact that the US continues to aid the Egyptian military, notwithstanding the coup and the bloodbath and you start getting some insight as to why the West is not viewed as an honest and impartial broker by many Africans. Commerce has, and continues to be, the real driver for the West's position and interest in Africa.

 

Comments 5 of 28

 

More Africa stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.