Slow response to East Africa famine 'cost 'lives'

 
A severely malnourished Somali child at a refugee camp in Dadaab, Kenya - July 2011 The US government says 29,000 children under five years old died between May and July 2011

Thousands of needless deaths occurred from famine in East Africa last year because the international community failed to heed early warnings, say two leading British aid organisations.

Oxfam and Save the Children say it took more than six months for aid agencies to act on warnings of imminent famine.

Between 50,000 and 100,000 people have died in Kenya, Ethiopia and Somalia.

The agencies say governments, donors, the United Nations and NGOs need to learn from the mistakes.

In a report titled A Dangerous Delay, the agencies say a culture of risk aversion stalled a large-scale aid effort.

They say part of the problem was that the governments of Kenya and Ethiopia were unwilling to admit the scale of the disaster, but also that aid agency staff felt they had seen the problem many times before.

"Many donors wanted proof of a humanitarian catastrophe before acting to prevent one," the report says.

"Sophisticated early warning systems first forecast a likely emergency as early as August 2010, but the full-scale response was not launched until July 2011."

By that time it says "malnutrition rates in parts of East Africa had gone far beyond the emergency threshold and there was high profile media coverage of the crisis".

'Grotesque situation'

At one stage during the East African famine the UN estimated that 10 million people were in need of humanitarian assistance.

Hundreds of thousands of refugees went to camps in search of food, especially those from parts of Somalia where government forces have been fighting Islamist al-Shabab militants.

Analysis

This is a searingly honest report. The agencies admit warnings from a purpose built system that combines satellite imagery with on the ground reporting were not taken seriously enough.

More than six months after those original warnings, when the famine had already taken hold, Oxfam and Save the Children declared the crisis their top priorities. So what went wrong?

Partly it was because the governments of Kenya and Ethiopia were unwilling to underline the scale of the disaster, but partly it was because aid agency staff on the ground failed to persuade others in the agency of the urgency of the crisis.

The openness in the report is refreshing, but how will the international community respond if aid agencies in future call for help, only to find they have overestimated the scale of a problem?

Will they not be accused of scare-mongering to increase the revenues of their organisations? It's a difficult balance to get right.

The report calls on all parties to take crisis warnings more seriously.

"All members of the international system must improve their ability to prevent the worst effects of hunger crises before they happen," it says.

"The scale of death and suffering, and the financial cost, could have been reduced if early warning systems had triggered an earlier, more substantial response.

"In particular, national governments must fulfil their responsibilities to people caught up in crises and demonstrate leadership."

The agencies are urging governments to endorse the Charter to End Extreme Hunger, launched in September.

Kenya and Norway have signed up to it and the UK has expressed support.

"Britain has led the world in tackling food insecurity in East Africa in the last year and we continue to urge others to prioritise this critical issue," the UK's International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell told the BBC.

In the report, Oxfam and Save the Children looked at their own role in the crisis as well as that of other agencies.

"We all bear responsibility for this dangerous delay," said Oxfam's Chief Executive Barbara Stocking.

"It is shocking that the poorest people are still bearing the brunt of a failure to respond swiftly and decisively."

Save the Children's Chief Executive, Justin Forsyth, said clear warnings had been ignored.

"We can no longer allow this grotesque situation to continue; where the world knows an emergency is coming but ignores it until confronted with TV pictures of desperately malnourished children," he said.

 

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 77.

    Any aid should certainly be means tested....

  • rate this
    +64

    Comment number 76.

    Africa is not a poor continent and does not need aid. The wealth from oil should be put back into building an infrastructure that can support the population.
    Individual countries have leaders too willing to sit back and accept back handers from developed nations who rape the land of it's resources, leaving nothing for the majority. It will only get worse as China moves in to take their share.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 75.

    AID SHOULD BE STOPPED! but think deeper.... first of all, we are the promoters and creators of those "fake democracies" in Africa, that aren't able or willing to better their situation by their own efforts. We made "being an African leader" a profitable job. We have made aid to fail and we have spoilt Africa. And if we stop aid today the ones who will suffer most will be the already suffering peop

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 74.

    Prevention is better than cure. We would be helping the poorer parts of the world if we educated them and actively supported a contraceptive program. The Catholic Church needs to wake up and smell the coffee as well.

  • rate this
    +16

    Comment number 73.

    @31.inchindown2

    Oh Africa is a very habitable continent. It has so many resources that countries in Africa could be rich. The problem is that African leaders are just unbelievably corrupt. They do not care about their people. A good example of this is Zimbabwe. When it was Rhodesia, it was a very prosperous place. When Mugabe came to power, we saw the slide to the poor corrupt country it is now

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 72.

    To Polly8122:

    Of course they haven't done any research. Some people just know they are right...

  • rate this
    +28

    Comment number 71.

    Fact: despite the famines of the last few decades the birth rates have never declined and the populations of for example Ethiopia and Somalia have doubled since the 1970's (Ethiopia pop 42m in 1984, now 84.7m(UN, 2011) - this just makes the famines larger each time they occur. If Aid, Female Education and Population control were linked then poverty and famine would cease.

  • rate this
    -23

    Comment number 70.

    People can't help where they are born. How must it feel to watch your kids starve to death when there was nothing you could do about it. Some of the comments made already are really callous.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 69.

    The current interglacial is gradually making these regions less habitable.For 50 years we have given immunisations to keep people alive without considering incompetent farming and how politics prevents migration for food. Birth control or famine or mass migration. The latter risks upheaval in the rest of the world-the areas must depopulate or be controlled by a power able to farm the resources.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 68.

    "Hundreds of thousands of refugees went to camps in search of food, especially those from parts of Somalia where government forces have been fighting Islamist al-Shabab rebels."

    This is a major part of the problem but because oil is not involved there is no UN intervention. These people need infrastructural investment so they can fend for themselves. The other problem is corrupt politicians.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 67.

    Nothing will ever change in Africa until the despots are dealt with , we just give money food etc and they take over distribution right into their own pockets , until the people come out of the 12th century and rid themselves of tribalism and despots nothing will change , it took us a thousand years to get were we are . stop the trade in weapons to these countries its like tanks against chariots .

  • rate this
    +11

    Comment number 66.

    Our Government gives generously on our behalf.

    So don't worry about it.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 65.

    India produces 80 million tonnes of wheat every year, surely the affected african states can trade directly with them. Maybe learn how they too can produce wheat in volume.

  • rate this
    -17

    Comment number 64.

    These droughts used to be very infrequent, but are becoming more frequent due to Global Warming, caused as it is primarily by us rich westerners.

    Left to their own devices they won't just stay there & die, they'll migrate. Think we have an immigration prolem now?

    Just wait until 100 million Africans move to Europe to escpae death......

  • rate this
    +52

    Comment number 63.

    The thing that costs lives in Africa is the corrupt politicians. Plying Africa with aid as we have done for the last 20-40 years just leads them to rely on that aid. It is time Africa took responsibility for its own peoples. The African Union should be sorting these issues out.

    I will not give to African charities as it is just giving corrupt African politicians money.

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 62.

    didnt bono and bob save africa 20+ years ago? both organisations have a bit of a cheek, maybe oxfam should worry mroe about sending its aid quicker instead of refitting its shops and chargeing retail prices for second hand DONATED goods?

  • rate this
    -13

    Comment number 61.

    58. MovingRight

    YAWN!!!!
    ---
    You wanna have a serious think about yourself if you think innocent children dying of starvation is boring.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 60.

    Question for Martin Plaut, "What's the problem with scare-mongering to increase the revenues of their organisations?" in that isn't this OK as the revenues will balance out with time and thousands less will not die? Having resources ahead of crises is far more satisfactory. I'm at loss though of how to solve this annual problem but know these are human lives, just like mine are equally important.

  • rate this
    +8

    Comment number 59.

    They could respond instantaneously and the result would be the same - contraception has to be a big part of the way forward - if these poor kids aren't born into this corrupt conflict torn and basically barren environment then they'll not have to suffer and maybe the population may reduce to a level that the environment can actually support.... I have just seen a creature with four trotters fly...

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 58.

    YAWN!!!!

    Another great attempt at stirring our emotions and handing over cash we no longer have.

    The politicians of these countries all look fat and very well fed, living a life of luxury. Tell them to hand over some of their own cash & food - once they start I'll start.

 

Page 27 of 30

 

More Africa stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.